Did BT spy on 36,000 customers?


BT tested secret “spyware” on tens of thousands of its broadband customers without their knowledge, it admitted yesterday.

It carried out covert trials of a system which monitors every internet page a user visits.

Companies can exploit such data to target users with tailored online advertisements.

An investigation into the affair has been started by the Information Commissioner, the personal data watchdog.

Privacy campaigners reacted with horror, accusing BT of illegal interception on a huge scale. Yesterday, the company was forced to admit that it had monitored the web browsing habits of 36,000 customers.

The scandal came to light only after some customers stumbled across tell-tale signs of spying. At first, they were wrongly told a software virus was to blame.

Executives insisted they had not broken the law and said no “personally identifiable information” had been shared or divulged.

BT said it randomly chose 36,000 broadband users for a “small-scale technical trial” in 2006 and 2007.

The monitoring system, developed by U.S. software company Phorm, accesses information from a computer.

It then scans every website a customer visits, silently checking for keywords and building up a unique picture of their interests.

If a user searches online to buy a holiday or expensive TV, for example, or looks for internet dating services or advice on weight loss, the Phorm system will add all the information to their file.

One BT customer who spotted unexplained problems with his computer was told repeatedly by BT helpdesk staff that a virus was to blame.

Stephen Mainwaring, who runs an online company in Weston-super-Mare, Somerset, has made a formal complaint to the Information Commissioner and is considering legal action.

Nicholas Bohm, of the Foundation for Information Policy Research, said BT’s actions amounted to illegal data interception.

He told the BBC: “It seems a clear-cut case of illegal interception of communication.”

Sir Tim Berners-Lee, the British inventor and founding father of the worldwide web, said a person’s data and web history are private property.

“It’s mine – you can’t have it,” he added.

“If you want to use it for something, then you have to negotiate with me. I have to agree, I have to understand what I’m getting in return.”

Emma Sanderson, head of value-added services at BT, said it had not broken the law.

“It was completely anonymous and no personally identifiable information was shared. No information was stored or divulged.”

A further trial is planned in the next few weeks, BT said, but customers will be asked in advance.

A spokesman said the Phorm system did not record details of which websites a user visited, but only keywords from the content which flagged up topics the customer is interested in.

Phorm uses anonymous code numbers for each computer, he said, rather than recording individuals’ names.

– Social networking website MySpace has teamed up with record labels Universal Music Group, Sony BMG Music Entertainment and Warner Music Group to launch a rival to Apple’s music download service iTunes.