Why the Right is Morally Wrong

Why is there so much animosity between Republicans and Democrats, conservatives and liberals? Part of the answer is that many of them have been indoctrinated; they have been taught allegiance to one side over another and never thought to question it. But for many others on both sides, party allegiance is more ideological than cultural. So the original question needs to be rephrased: for these ideological “warriors,” what exactly fuels all of the anger and venom in policy debates about economics, taxes, minimum wage, infrastructure, unions, environment/climate change, immigration, voting rights, gun control, criminal justice, and moral/social issues (abortion, race relations, religion in schools, LGBTQ rights, etc.)?

Underlying all of this bitter polarization and emotional partisanship are two profoundly opposing views about government’s moral obligations to the most vulnerable and historically oppressed members of society. While the left regards government as a force for good, a powerful institution that should be used primarily to help improve such people’s lives and thereby expand their liberty, the right regards government as a necessary evil, an inherently despotic, liberty-diminishing institution that should be used only for the more minimal purposes of maintaining order and security.

What motivates this theoretical difference is a widespread psychological difference. While “leftists” are more likely to trust state authority and acknowledge our mutual…

Read more