Why President Obama Has Difficulty Garnering Respect Internationally

As President Obama gave his valedictory speech to the United Nations General
Assembly and has recently returned from a farewell tour of East Asia, it sure
seems like other countries were dissing him. Rodrigo Duterte, the president
of the Philippines – a small, poor country that has a territorial dispute with
China in the South China Sea and depends on the U.S. military to defend it –
launched a personal profane diatribe against Obama not usually used in diplo-speak.
Obama’s response was to cancel a formal meeting with Duterte, but then the next
day met with him informally anyway. The Chinese insultingly refused to provide
a stairway for the president to exit Air Force One when he arrived in China,
making him exit through his own stairway at the back of the aircraft. Obama
was also reluctant to press small Asian countries – such as Vietnam, Laos, Malaysia,
and the Philippines – on human rights, for fear these countries will be driven
into China’s orbit.

And the problem is not confined to East Asia. Media reports always seem to paint Obama as being hoodwinked and disrespected by Vladimir Putin of Russia – for example, by his brazen annexation of Crimea, his meddling in eastern Ukraine, and his military intervention in Syria to help his ally Bashar al-Assad. And concerning Syria, Obama has been belittled around the world and at home for drawing a red line on Assad’s use of chemical weapons and then not enforcing it.

Yet the problem is not so much that Obama is personally weak as is it that
the United States has been debilitated by the lack of a global grand strategy
– that is, the country has a muddled vision of what it wants to or can sustainably
do in the world. The United States still tries to operate as the world’s policeman,
yet is overextended – accounting for 38 percent of global defense spending but
only 16 percent of its GDP – and has a national public debt of more than $19
trillion. And U.S. foreign policy remains stuck in the Cold War, as it attempts
to woo allies in East Asia to contain a rising China and to continue to expand
NATO in Europe to contain a reawakened Russian bear. Thus, as during the Cold
War, smaller countries can extract goodies from competing big powers, which
simultaneously try to entice and intimidate these lesser players.

Using this Cold War-lite strategy, the United States and its president are thus likely to do some things half-heartedly – such as leaving a small force in Afghanistan while hoping somehow the war will be turned around even though success was elusive at much higher force levels, reinserting a small number of U.S. forces back into Iraq and facing the same problem, and making only a nominal effort to bomb in Syria and provide aid to opposition groups there to pretend to keep up with the Joneses (Russians). The reason all of these efforts are half-baked is…

Read more