What Lessons Can We Learn From October 1917?

Vladimir Lenin and Julius Martov. Vladimir Lenin and Julius Martov. (Image: Jared Rodriguez / Truthout)

One hundred years ago, the Russian Revolution changed the world. Ever since then, it has been contested history. China Miéville’s October: The Story of the Russian Revolution tells the story of not one but two revolutions that took place in 1917 and the extraordinary events surrounding them: a remarkable story of uprisings and repression, heroism and folly, triumph and tragedy. Get your copy by making a donation to Truthout!

“Stalin, of course, was not yet Stalin.”

This sentence, appearing less than one hundred pages into China Miéville’s October: The Story of the Russian Revolution, sums up the biggest challenge of writing a fresh history of the events of 1917. As Miéville writes, “any account of the revolution is haunted by a ghost from the future” — and not just the ghost of Joseph Stalin.

When we first encounter them in this book, Lenin is not yet Lenin in that sense, Trotsky is not yet Trotsky, even if they were already going by those names. October is, in one sense, an origin story for the “heroes and villains” who have been rendered such by a century of revolutions inspired by them, internal socialist and communist argument about their relative merits, and conservative and liberal smears.

That last factor is crucial and forms the biggest argument for educating oneself about the Russian Revolution. Decades of anti-communist propaganda and miseducation about Russia in the United States are still having a malign effect on the political discourse. For an example of this, one has only to look at how often Soviet iconography or language crops up in discussion of Donald Trump’s connections to modern Russia, from tweets to protest signs. Meanwhile, many American socialists still feel the need to specify that their socialism is not the Russian kind.

The Russian Revolution, then, carries a signifying meaning that is far in excess of the extent to which it is actually understood, even in terms of the…

Read more