So asks Jordan Peterson. In response, he offers food for thought:
The probability that it’s the friendliest and nicest people is very, very low.
I suggest that what he is saying is that the probability that it’s the meanest and nastiest people is very, very high.
Hans Hoppe weighs in on this topic: Why Bad Men Rule:
Free entry and competition in the production of goods is good, but free competition in the production of bads is not. Free entry into the business of torturing and killing innocents, or free competition in counterfeiting or swindling, for instance, is not good; it is worse than bad.
To this we could add Hayek’s well-known chapter from his book Road to Serfdom, Why the Worst Get on Top.
Libertarian political philosophy offers, perhaps, the fewest rules of any political philosophy devised by man. Really, it offers only one rule: do not initiate aggression. I guess the only way to have fewer rules is to offer no rule at all regarding aggression – but then you would have no political philosophy. We need not concern ourselves with this absurdity.
In other words, libertarian political philosophy comes closest to the condition described by Peterson: there are no rules. Therefore, his question is very appropriate for those grounded in libertarian theory to address: in such a condition, who leads? Who makes the rules?

The Road to Serfdom: T…
Best Price: $1.55
Buy New $5.79
Many libertarians would answer: no one. Each individual is an autonomous economic actor, to be bound only by voluntary contractual agreements. This sound good in theory.
I have often posed the question: when has [insert any utopian political scheme] worked out well in practice? Limited government, communism, fascism,…
