Photo by Karl-Ludwig Poggemann | CC BY 2.0
The authors of our Constitution were of many minds on many issues, slavery most of all. But they all agreed that the United States would be a republic, that there would be no king.
They got what they wanted. We have had an “imperial” presidency for quite a while, but we have never had a monarch – not in the literal sense.
Even so, our founders never quite dispatched the spirit of monarchy, the idea that the state and its laws must be shrouded in majesty. They could hardly have done that and also founded a modern state.
Even in the modern world, political legitimacy depends, to at least some extent, on what Max Weber (1864-1920) called “charisma,” an awareness, usually unconscious but psychologically real, of a connection to a transcendent power that confers authority upon political leaders or upon the offices they hold.
The general idea, in pre-modern times, was that authority was somehow divinely conferred. Modernity disenchants both the natural and social worlds, but not so much as to do away with charismatic authority claims altogether.
We are all naturalists now, and are therefore inclined to think of charismatic authority as a relic of a bygone past. However, at an experiential level, there is no denying that the phenomenon is real.
Nevertheless, nowadays, authority claims depend, for the most part, on factors that are less affectively compelling. Modern states are therefore always at risk of falling…