How do we account for the fact that the pundits and media outlets who have
been wrong about everything are still considered reliably “mainstream” – and
still get to determine the parameters of allowable debate?
Let’s take the most egregious case imaginable – Bill Kristol. Here is someone
who has been wrong about absolutely everything for as long as anyone can remember.
On the foreign policy front, he wasn’t just on the wrong side of the barricades,
he was wrong about the outcomes of our disastrous interventions in Iraq, Afghanistan,
and Libya. Iraq would be a “two month” war, and in Afghanistan we would be welcomed
as “liberators”
(just like in Iraq!). “If we prevail in Libya,” he averred,
“the victory will be America’s.” We did indeed succeed in overthrowing Gaddafi:
and shortly afterwards, a US ambassador was dead and terrorists were cavorting
in the swimming pool of our former embassy.
When it comes to the domestic front, his record is even more dismal: he predicted
Mitt Romney would be a strong GOP candidate for President, he said Barack Obama
wouldn’t beat Hillary in a single primary, and he continually presaged the downfall
of Donald Trump in the Republican primaries.
It’s become something of a
standing joke that the “Kristol ball” is a nearly infallible indicator of
what isn’t going to happen. And yet he’s all over the media – and personally
profiting from his utter wrongness. In 2009, he received the Bradley Prize for
outstanding conservative thinkers, taking home $250,000.
Yes, the
neocons got it wrong, but they weren’t alone: before Dan Drezner was a Washington
Post columnist who is the perfect weathervane by which to chart the prevailing
winds in Washington, the Fletcher School professor of international relations
was a prolific blogger who stated his reasons for supporting the invasion of
Iraq here. My favorite:
“[A] successful invasion not only eliminates the Iraqi threat, but over the
long run it reduces the Arab resentment that feeds Al-Qaeda.”
Since we live in Bizarro World, where up is down, black is white, an analyst
who was completely wrong about the most important foreign policy issue of the
new millennium is naturally going to be rewarded with a column in a major newspaper.
And it wasn’t just
the neocons and their “centrist” enablers who were the wrong-way drivers
of the “Iraq will be a cakewalk” narrative. Who can forget liberal pundit Chris
Matthews proclaiming “We’re all neocons now!”? Howard Fineman told us “We had
controversial wars that divided the country. This war united the country and
brought the military back.” And then there was New York Times reporter
David Carr declaring: “Now liberal commentators must address the victory at
hand and confront an ascendant conservative…