The New McCarthyism

Cold War II is upon us. Once again,
to write the phrase “the Kremlin” is to evoke images of an Oriental despotism
both ominous and inscrutable, only slightly less sinister than the Dark Tower. Russia, once
thought to have been liberated from its Soviet chains, is now the new Mordor. And, of course, Vladimir
Putin is the new Sauron:
cunning, amoral, inhumanly ruthless, he is routinely likened to Joseph Stalin,
the Soviet dictator who murdered millions and imprisoned many more in the gulags.

Not that Putin has murdered millions, or even as many as a dozen, but the ethics
of the new McCarthyites — yes, they’re back — aren’t overly punctilious. Their
polemics are even less exacting than their forebears’ for the simple reason
that Communism, as an organized international movement with its epicenter in
Russia, is dead, and will doubtless remain so. Furthermore, “Putinism,” if such
an ideological creature can be said to exist — a problematic proposition — is
not a global movement, let alone an international conspiracy: there are no “Putinist”
parties outside of Russia, assiduously subverting the moral and political foundations
of the West and harboring the 21st century version of the Rosenbergs.
No Whittaker
Chambers
will emerge to reveal the dark secrets of these saboteurs of democracy
and shine a bright light on their moral espionage — but never fear, because
we have Cathy Young.

A columnist for various and sundry outlets, and long associated with Reason
magazine, Young — born Ekaterina Jung — came to the US when she was 17 and
became a naturalized citizen in 1989, the year her book, Growing
Up in Moscow: Memories of a Soviet Girlhood
was published. The book,
which details life under the totalitarian rule of the Communists, might have
ensured her a career as a defected Soviet dissident, perhaps a female version
of Natan
Sharanksy
, but — alas — the Soviet Union fell before such promise could
be fulfilled and she had to find another ideological niche, eventually zeroing
in on the absurdities of radical feminism in her second book, and promoting
a movement known as “Women Against
Feminism
.”

Read more