Until the longest war in U.S. history ends, substantive liberty will not return
to American soil. Nothing is more important to freedom than to oppose the militarization
of society because the two social models cannot coexist. Inevitably, one will
overthrow the other.
What Is War? What Is Libertarianism?
The root of the conflict is expressed in the definitions of “war”
and “libertarianism.”
War is traditionally defined as the situation in which one state officially
declares open hostility against the territory and people of another. Sometimes
the word “war” is replaced by euphemistic terms such as “police
action” but this is sophistry.
The purpose of war is to defend the alleged ‘rights’ of the state(s) involved:
territorial sovereignty, control of resources, treaties, spheres of influence,
or a specific political system such as monarchy. War does not defend individuals
or their rights except as an occasional and unintended consequence. Instead,
a warring state deliberately violates the person and property of individuals
within its own territory by using them as resources in the war effort; those
who dissent – by refusing to register, for example – are punished. At the
same time, a warring state destroys the people and property of an enemy nation
as a matter of strategy or as acceptable collateral damage.
By contrast, libertarianism holds individual rights as primary and the initiation
of force as anathema to them.
The two definitions are diametrically opposed and yet some libertarians defend
war, at least in theory, on the basis of self-defense. Is this approach valid?
War as the Antithesis of Self-Defense
The so-called libertarian argument for war runs as follows: individuals have
a right to self-defense, which means they can assign their self-defense to an
agency in the same manner as signing a power of attorney. If necessary, an individual
can properly use deadly force in self-protection, which means the agency can
acquire that right as well. The agency involved in war is the state. But the
foregoing argument is self-contradictory and otherwise objectionable on several
grounds.
First, the objections. Pro-war libertarians assume war is an extension of individual
self-defense. But a cursory review of history shows that wars are overwhelmingly
fought to profit politicians, the military, specific industries and related
corporations. Generally the higher ranks of society – the elite – are the
beneficiaries with the lower ranks – the people – paying a savage price.
The argument also assumes that war places a population at less and not more
risk of attack by both the enemy and by its own state. The opposite is true.
‘Enemies’ who are bombed and watch family members die are more likely to retaliate
than to extend a hand of good will in response. Domestic resisters…