The First Amendment Defense Act Will Be Back

Remember the First Amendment Defense Act (FADA), the “right to discriminate against LGBQT people” bill? Introduced last summer, it’s been festering away in the back corners of Congress, but in 2017, it’s likely to roar back onto the agenda — and, moreover, it’s likely to pass. If it does, president-elect Donald Trump has already pledged to sign it into law, and it will change the American landscape forever.

To understand why this bill is worrying so many LGBQT Americans, and some religious officiants too, we have to take a little walk deep into the bowels of Congress, conservative Christianity and the culture wars dominating the American landscape.

On the surface, a First Amendment Defense Act sounds nice, right? We’re all big fans of the First Amendment. The unique protections it offers, and freedom of speech, religion and the press should lie at the core of American values. But the intent of this bill, and the problem, are bound up right in the summary line: “To prevent discriminatory treatment of any person on the basis of views held with respect to marriage.”

FADA was written very specifically with one group of people in mind: Conservative Christians opposed to same-gender marriage, and furious at the rise of same-gender marriage in the U.S. The Supreme Court case affirming the right to marry, Obergefell v. Hodges, was decided just days after this legislation was introduced, and that’s not a coincidence.

OK, but if someone is opposed to same-gender marriage, surely we shouldn’t discriminate against them, right? Freedom of thought is an American value too and we shouldn’t impose our values on others. That’s a noble sentiment, but that’s not what FADA is about. Instead, the law targets “government intrusion” and what people like Mr. Trump call “bullying” in the form of regulations, laws and court decisions protecting equal access to LGBQT people. FADA isn’t about protecting people of faith, but about legitimizing discrimination. The question isn’t “can I deny service to…

Read more