Scalia's Dead Hand Grips "Systemic Risk" Regulators

President Barack Obama and first lady Michelle Obama look at a portrait of Justice Antonin Scalia as they pay their respects to the late justice in the Great Hall of the Supreme Court building in Washington, Feb. 19, 2016.  (Doug Mills / The New York Times)President Obama and first lady Michelle Obama look at a portrait of Justice Antonin Scalia as they pay their respects to the late justice in the Great Hall of the Supreme Court building in Washington, February 19, 2016. (Doug Mills / The New York Times)

Before MetLife Inc.’s court victory in late March fades from memory, it’s important to grasp the significance of what just happened: A US district judge relied on a Supreme Court opinion written last term by deceased Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia and raised by MetLife’s chief outside counsel Eugene Scalia — Antonin’s son — to ward off a “systemic risk” designation by the Obama administration’s Financial Stability Oversight Council.

The victory by MetLife — the nation’s largest life insurer — opens the door to similar challenges from AIG, GE Capital and Prudential, which were all previously designated as “systemically important financial institutions,” or SIFIs, by the oversight council. The 2010 Dodd-Frank Act authorized the council to supervise such companies if they “could pose a threat to the financial stability of the United States.”

According to a ruling by US District Judge Rosemary M. Collyer, the oversight council — 15 top officials who include the US secretary of treasury, the chairman of the Federal Reserve, the comptroller of the currency and the chairs of the Securities and Exchange Commission and the Federal Deposit Insurance Company — doesn’t have a clue about assessing future financial crises.

Father and Son

In Eugene Scalia’s words, the council’s MetLife designation was “predicated on unbounded speculation, ahistorical analysis, shifting standards, and undisclosed evidentiary material.” Anticipating a potential constitutional appeal, the younger Scalia also noted in his motion for summary judgment that oversight council members exercise legislative, investigative, prosecutorial and adjudicative functions within the executive branch.

In colloquial terms, MetLife’s lawyer told the Obama…

Read more