Merle Haggard vs. Eliot Cohen

Poor Eliot Cohen: one of the principal architects of the Iraq war, and chief
ideologue of Bushism in foreign policy – remember the “freedom agenda”? – he’s
miffed
that “This campaign shows that the foreign policy consensus that
has framed this country’s work overseas since 1950 is in peril.” His ire is
directed at Donald Trump, but he’s more than a little annoyed at the left-wing
of the Democratic party, which is also showing signs of messing around with
the Sacred Consensus. How dare these miscreants challenge a “consensus” that
brought us a whole series of outright military defeats, from Vietnam to the
Iraq war, and cost us tens of thousands of lost lives and an incalculable amount
in dollars! Egghead “intellectuals” like Robert McNamara and Cohen know a lot
more about foreign policy than the denizens of flyover country, such as one
Merle Haggard, who advised us in one of his ditties:

“Let’s
get out of Iraq and get back

on
track

And
let’s rebuild America first.”

Of course, Haggard didn’t know that – as Cohen helpfully points out – he was
invoking a “notorious movement” that “included not only traditional isolationists
but also Nazi sympathizers.” It’s a good thing we have Cohen around to set us
straight: otherwise we might all be turning into little Hitlers when we think
we’re just opposing yet another chickenhawk-inspired war.

More seriously, Cohen’s vaunted “consensus” is an illusion. No one asked the
American people if they wanted to be the world’s policeman. What Cohen means
is that all the Serious People in the Washington Beltway, and the concrete canyons
of New York City, agree that other peoples’ sons and daughters ought to be sent
abroad to fight foreign wars in which America’s real interests are tenuous if
not nonexistent. Outside of that circumscribed world, the “consensus” breaks
down.

The politics of American foreign policy are governed by the tides of partisan
warfare, the ebb and flow of the eternal struggle between “left” and “right.”
Which means that, every decade or so, the political spectrum switches polarities:
witness the transformation of the “isolationist” Old Right of the 1940s into
the warmongering conservative movement of the cold war era. A similar case of
role reversal occurred on the left in the 1990s, when the previously “antiwar”
liberal wing of the Democratic party allied with the usual neoconservative suspects
to bring us the US invasion of the Balkans – and it was conservative Republicans
in Congress who threatened to withdraw funding from Bill Clinton’s conquest
of Kosovo.

This news caught neocon grand strategist Bill Kristol vowing to walk out of
the GOP if it succumbed to “isolationism”: for some reason, the end of the cold
war did not possess…

Read more