Make America Good Again

It could be any of three senses, each of which was expounded by the great American journalist Randolph Bourne in his 1918 essay “ The State.”

They could mean America the Country. According to Bourne, when speaking of country or nation:

“We think vaguely of a loose population spreading over a certain geographical portion of the earth’s surface, speaking a common language, and living in a homogeneous civilization. Our idea of Country concerns itself with the non-political aspects of a people, its ways of living, its personal traits, its literature and art, its characteristic attitudes toward life.”

Or they could mean America the State. According to Bourne:

“The State is the country acting as a political unit, it is the group acting as a repository of force, determiner of law, arbiter of justice.”

It is important to note that Bourne’s idea of the State is distinct from his idea of government, which is:

“…the machinery by which the nation, organized as a State, carries out its State functions. Government is a framework of the administration of laws, and the carrying out of the public force. (…) That the State is a mystical conception is something that must never be forgotten. Its glamor and its significance linger behind the framework of Government and direct its activities.”

And in wartime, the State eclipses all else, as the alarmed populace amalgamates into a herd, huddling and stampeding in unison under the guiding rod of government-as-shepherd:

“Wartime brings the ideal of the State out into very clear relief, and reveals attitudes and tendencies that were hidden. (…) For war is essentially the health of the State. The ideal of the State is that within its territory its power and influence should be universal. (…) And it is precisely in war that the urgency for union seems greatest, and the necessity for universality seems most unquestioned. The State is the organization of the herd to act offensively or defensively against another herd similarly organized. The more terrifying the occasion for defense, the closer will become the organization and the more coercive the influence upon each member of the herd.”

Bourne noticed a key problem for clearly thinking about these matters:

“The patriot loses all sense of the distinction between State, nation, and government.”

As a result, these terms have become thoroughly confused.

 

Read more