The year was 1956: the icy winds of the cold war were blowing across the political
landscape. And it was a presidential election year, pitting the internationalist
Republican Dwight Eisenhower against Adlai Stevenson, the darling of the Democratic
party’s left wing. The “isolationist” faction of the GOP, led by Sen. Robert
A. Taft, had been finally defeated by what Phyllis Schlafly later called the
Republican “kingmakers” of the Eastern Establishment. And the looming menace
of the cold war turning hot was everywhere in
the headlines. While Eisenhower was rallying the nation against the alleged
Communist “threat,” Stevenson was calling for a nuclear test ban, negotiations
with the Soviet Union, and an end to the military draft.
There was no organized libertarian movement at the time, although the people
and institutions that would later emerge as the leadership were beginning to
coalesce. Prominent among them was Murray
Rothbard, then a thirty year old economist and consultant for the Volker
Fund, who was also the Washington correspondent for the quasi-libertarian
Faith and
Freedom magazine. While most if not all conservatives and libertarians
favored Eisenhower, Rothbard shocked his readers with a ringing endorsement
of the liberal Democrat Stevenson.
While opposing Stevenson’s domestic program of more government spending and
expanded social programs, Rothbard explained that it was the Democratic nominee’s
position on the vital foreign policy issues of the day that ought to earn him
libertarian support. While Eisenhower was playing the Soviet “threat” card,
Stevenson was warning of the dangers of a nuclear confrontation between the
two superpowers. Richard Nixon was quick to jump on Stevenson as an “appeaser”
when Soviet Premier Nikolai Bulganin endorsed Stevenson’s nuclear test ban proposal.
The Soviet suppression of the Hungarian revolt further escalated the cold war
hysteria that was sweeping the nation, and Eisenhower easily won a second term.
Yet Rothbard’s dissent was prescient: the Communist system, he wrote in Faith
and Freedom, was “relatively inefficient” and doomed to fail. The enemy,
he pointed out, was not merely communism, but “statism in all its forms.” Furthermore,
under a wartime regime the State made its greatest inroads on the private sector:
America’s wars had always been the occasion for a “great leap forward” in the
power of the centralized State to impinge on every aspect of our lives. The
ultra-conservative readers of Faith and Freedom were not convinced, and
Rothbard was soon out as a columnist – yet his stand against the anti-communist
hysteria and warmongering of the cold war Right was both prescient and principled.
As early as 1952, Rothbard had noted the fatal flaw in the “New Right” of
William F….