Law Prof Pilloried for Exam Question

Shop all books by Tom Woods

If you’ve listened to me for any length of time, chances are you’ve heard me refer to the three-by-five card of allowable opinion.

As long as you stay confined to the range of opinions on that card, you’ll be in good standing with the media and the establishment.

It’s fun to observe someone who’s never once strayed from that card confront ideas that are nowhere near it. Their brains genuinely do not know what to do.

A spectrum of political options running from Mitt Romney to Hillary Clinton are all their brains are programmed to handle.

Real Dissent: A Libert…
Thomas E. Woods Jr.
Best Price: $7.98
Buy New $18.76
(as of 06:00 EST – Details)

This happened recently with a 3 x 5 card fellow named Elie Mystal.

He was outraged that Josh Blackman, a professor at South Texas College of Law, asked students on a constitutional law exam to consider some of the actions of Abraham Lincoln during the so-called Civil War, and imagine a scenario in which articles of impeachment are brought against a President Lincoln who survived the attack by John Wilkes Booth.

Blackman asks students to assess the strengths and weaknesses of the arguments raised in these hypothetical articles.

Mystal is outraged at the exam questions, and proceeds to launch into a victimology routine: these questions are “racist” and disadvantage black students, etc.

Some lawyer this guy would make! If he gets a case that makes him uncomfortable, he won’t be able to represent his client effectively.



Nullification: How to …
Thomas E. Woods
Best Price: $2.00
Buy New $10.95
(as of 08:25 EST – Details)

More to the point, Lincoln’s own racial views were closer to those of the Ku Klux Klan than to the NAACP, so it’s not…

Read more