Late last week, the inspector general of the State Department completed a yearlong
investigation into the use by Hillary Clinton of a private email server for
all of her official government email as secretary of state. The investigation
was launched when information technology officials at the State Department under
Secretary of State John Kerry learned that Clinton paid an aide to migrate her
public and secret State Department email streams away from their secured government
venues and onto her own, non-secure server, which was stored in her home.
The migration of the secret email stream most likely constituted the crime
of espionage – the failure to secure and preserve the secrecy of confidential,
secret or top-secret materials.
The inspector general interviewed Clinton’s three immediate predecessors –
Madeleine Albright, Colin Powell and Condoleezza Rice – and their former aides
about their email practices. He learned that none of them used emails as extensively
as Clinton, none used a private server and, though Powell and Rice occasionally
replied to government emails using private accounts, none used a private account
when dealing with state secrets.
Clinton and her former aides declined to cooperate with the inspector general,
notwithstanding her oft-stated claim that she “can’t wait” to meet
with officials and clear the air about her emails.
The inspector general’s report is damning to Clinton. It refutes every defense
she has offered to the allegation that she mishandled state secrets. It revealed
an email that hadn’t been publicly made known showing Clinton’s state of mind.
And it paints a picture of a self-isolated secretary of state stubbornly refusing
to comply with federal law for venal reasons; she simply did not want to be
held accountable for her official behavior.
The report rejects Clinton’s argument that her use of a private server “was
allowed.” The report makes clear that it was not allowed, nor did she seek
permission to use it. She did not inform the FBI, which had tutored her on the
lawful handling of state secrets, and she did not inform her own State Department
IT folks.
The report also makes clear that had she sought permission to use her own server
as the instrument through which all of her email traffic passed, such a request
would have been flatly denied.
In addition, the report rejects her argument – already debunked by the director
of the FBI – that the FBI is merely conducting a security review of the State
Department’s email storage and usage policies rather than a criminal investigation
of her. The FBI does not conduct security reviews. The inspector general does.
This report is the result of that review, and Clinton flunked it, as it reveals
that she refused to comply with the same State Department storage and transparency
…