FBI Comes After the 4th Amendment

While Hillary Clinton and Bernie Sanders are battling in their final round
in the Democratic primaries and Donald Trump is arguing that Clinton should
be in prison for failing to safeguard state secrets while she was secretary
of state, the same FBI that is diligently investigating her is quietly and perniciously
seeking to cut more holes in the Fourth Amendment to the Constitution.

That amendment – which requires the government to obtain a search warrant
issued by a judge based upon some evidence of criminal wrongdoing, called probable
cause, before the government can search persons, houses, papers or effects –
is the linchpin of the right to privacy, famously referred to by Justice Louis
Brandeis as the right to be let alone.

The Fourth Amendment has a painful yet unambiguous history. The essence of
that history is the well-documented and nearly universal Colonial revulsion
to the British use of general warrants.

General warrants, which were usually issued in secret in London, permitted
British soldiers and agents in America to search wherever they wished and seize
whatever they found. General warrants were not based upon any individualized
suspicion, much less any probable cause. Their stated purpose was the need to
enforce the Stamp Act, a totalitarian measure that cost more to enforce than
it generated in revenue.

The Stamp Act required all colonists to purchase and affix stamps to all legal,
financial, political, personal and public documents. It was billed as a revenue-gathering
measure, but it truly was used as an excuse to humiliate the colonists by permitting
soldiers and agents to enter their homes ostensibly looking for the stamps.
They were really looking for evidence of revolutionary ideas and plans against
the king.

After Americans won the Revolution and wrote the Constitution, they did so
with the determination never to permit the new government here to do to Americans
what the pre-Revolutionary British government had done to the colonists. Their
chosen instrument of that prevention was the Fourth Amendment.

But the feds have been wearing away at the right to privacy for generations.
The Right to Financial Privacy Act (which has nothing to do with protecting
privacy) permits federal agents to obtain certain bank records with search warrants
issued by other federal agents – as opposed to judges – as long as they are
looking for mobsters or drug dealers. The Patriot Act (which has nothing to
do with patriotism) enables FBI agents to issue search warrants to other FBI
agents for certain business records – including doctors’ and lawyers’ offices,
car and jewelry dealers, and the post office – as long as they are looking
for threats to national security. And the Electronic Communications Privacy
Act (which interferes with the privacy of almost all…

Read more