by T.P. Wilkinson / August 15th, 2016
I do not consider it the sign of an intellectually critical person that he or she has a dogmatically predictable reply to any and every issue. It is perfectly legitimate to have doubts about something.
Actually I have often disagreed with Bill Blum, but then I tend to share Gandhi’s insight about “Western civilization”.
The last two essays that reached me and a good friend of mine in the US seemed quite uncharacteristic not because of some supposed “correctness” or “incorrectness” but because of the absurdity of even phrasing arguments in those terms.
First of all the issue of “political correctness”, as I see it, historically is the cynical application of opposition discourse to obtain perverse if not reverse results; e.g., “reverse discrimination”– a term made infamous in the Bakke case, turned the language of “affirmative action” (already a problematic policy given the racist system in the US) into a tool to defend white male supremacy against supposedly unjust (exaggerated) demands for equality. The “politically correct” position was that taken by the Establishment so as to manipulate the demands of those challenging it in such a way that the majority would oppose what they otherwise might at least rationally accept.
Now, of course, “political correctness” itself has been turned into a term attributed to the ideological “Left” (although there is no such thing in the US) as a…