Clinton’s Imperious Brush-Off of Email Rules

State Department functionaries faced a hopeless task as they tried to spin
their own Inspector General’s matter-of-fact critique of former Secretary of
State Hillary Clinton’s imperial attitude toward basic security measures everyone
else is required by law to follow.

It turns out that she deliberately chose to use a hacker-friendly, unprotected
email server, and not so much for convenience – unless you define “convenience”
as the ability to operate in total secrecy with no possibility of being held
accountable for your policies or behavior. In one email to an aide, Clinton
explained, “I don’t want any risk of the personal being accessible.”

When some staffers had the temerity to voice concerns over the vulnerability
of a non-governmental email system, they were warned by their seniors “never
to speak of the Secretary’s personal email system again.” The IG report establishes
that Clinton’s claim that her use of an insecure email system for official business
had been “allowed” is, well, disingenuous.

Pity the State Department spokespeople tasked with putting the best face on
the IG’s stark criticism. Media representatives actually posed some direct questions
to those applying the cosmetics, who showed themselves far more guilty than
Socrates in “trying to make the worst case the better.” At several points, I
sensed them wishing some hemlock came in their job jar.

Just doing their job, I know. But it was bizarrely clear that their instructions
included taking a bullet for Secretary Clinton. It wasn’t really her fault,
you see. It was actually the State Department’s fault, collectively. There were
only a few variations on the meme: “We could have done a better job ensuring
that people understand security policies;” “We could have done better job at
preserving emails;” “We have not lived up to all our obligations.” In other
words, “we” failed the Secretary, not that Clinton failed in her
duty to ensure that government information was properly secure.

I counted no fewer than 15 examples of this kind of self-criticism, and it
was more than a little nauseating. But then, again, if Clinton becomes President,
who wants to be assigned to be deputy chief of mission in Upper Slovobia? It
was encouraging as it was heartening to notice that this time the press corps
was not sitting still for the notion that it wasn’t really Clinton’s fault,
after all.

The fly in the ointment preventing the usual careful orchestration of such
announcements was an early leak of the IG report. Worse still, for the State
Department spokespeople, several of the journalists had actually read the report
and noticed that its declarative prose did not square with the collective self-flagellation
serving as a diversion. Even the mainstream press corps could see through the
…

Read more