The American Way of War as a Do-Over

With General John Campbell’s tour of duty in Afghanistan finished, a

new commander has taken over. Admittedly, things did not go well during
Campbell’s year and a half heading up the International Security Assistance
Force (ISAF) there, but that’s par for the course. In late 2015,
while he was in the saddle, the Taliban took
the provincial capital of Kunduz, the first city to be (briefly) theirs since
the American invasion of 2001. In response, U.S. forces devastated
a Doctors Without Borders hospital. The Taliban is also now in control
of more
territory
than at any time since the invasion and gaining an ever-firmer
grip
on contested Helmand Province in the heart of the country’s poppy-growing
region
(and so the staggering drug funds that go with it). In that
same province, only about half of the “on duty” Afghan security
forces the United States trained, equipped, and largely funded (to the tune
of more than $65
billion
over the years) were reportedly
even present.

On his way into retirement, General Campbell has been vigorously urging
the Obama administration to expand its operations in that country. (“I’m
not going to leave,” he said, “without making sure my leadership
understands that there are things we need to do.”) In this, he’s
been in good company. Behind the scenes, “top U.S. military commanders”
have reportedly been talking up a renewed, decades-long
commitment to Afghanistan and its security forces, what one general has termed
a “generational approach” to the war there.

And yes, as Campbell headed off stage, General John Nicholson, Jr., beginning
his fourth tour of duty in Afghanistan, has officially taken command of ISAF.
Though it wasn’t a major news item, he happens to be its 17th
commander in the 14-plus years of Washington’s Afghan War. If this
pattern holds, by 2030 that international force, dominated by the U.S., will
have had 34 commanders and have fought, by at least a multiple of two, the longest
war in our history. Talk about all-American records! (USA! USA!)

Read more