The toll of rape and the lack of conviction

Melanie Newman

It’s late 2011. Two senior offices from the UK’s largest police force are attempting to explain, in a long and rambling report, why more suspected rapists aren’t being charged.

The officers, part of a specialist sexual offences unit within the Metropolitan Police, London’s  police force, had been tasked with exploring why more people in the capital were reporting rape but the number of suspects being charged was falling. The explanation, the officers concluded, lay with the victims and the quality of their evidence.

The problem, they reported, was that most rape allegations were made by people in circumstances that could compromise their evidence in court. Victims were frequently young, had mental-health problems, had histories of domestic violence and had used drugs or alcohol before the attack–and these ‘vulnerabilities’ meant their cases were likely to drop out of the criminal justice system long before they reached court: ‘The number of cases where victims have multiple vulnerabilities in their lives is 87%, making them and their evidence less robust when scrutinised in the light of court processes.’

This claim was reiterated several times in the report. Yet its 10 ‘action plan’ points did not include any on how to address allegations by vulnerable people–perhaps through training or a change in investigative approach. The impression left was of an intractable problem which, by ‘diluting focus’, drew attention away from cases with a better chance of ending in conviction.

One woman’s story

Fast forward 18 months to March 2013. A young woman, ‘Beth’, is deciding what to do about her sister, ‘Ella’, who has just revealed that she was raped the evening before by a man who had befriended her. Distressed and complaining of abdominal pain, she needs help. Not knowing where else to go, Beth drives her sister to the accident-and-emergency (A&E) department at King’s College Hospital in south London.

A&E and the Haven, a specialist unit for victims of rape and sexual assault, are just a few minutes’ walk apart on the sprawling King’s campus. On arrival, Beth and Ella are surrounded by professionals who know the Haven is around the corner. Staff working in the unit are specially trained to carry out forensic examinations and to provide everything else that Ella might need, from emergency contraception to counselling to setting up an informal meeting with a police officer.

But for Ella and Beth it might as well be in Australia. They never get near the place. A&E staff liaise with the Haven but King’s protocols demand they wait for hours. Meantime, a doctor suggests Beth might call the police, which she does. She isn’t told that this will mean that Ella loses the option to refer herself to the Haven.

Ella receives a cursory examination before the pair are taken to a police station, where they have a further long wait. After interview, officers decide that Ella has not been raped and send her home.

After spending some 12 hours with NHS staff and police, Ella has not received an internal examination. No arrangement has been made for sexually-transmitted-disease screening and neither has any specialist support been offered.

Ella is extremely distressed by the rape and washes herself obsessively. ‘The failure to refer had a huge impact on my sister who had already been through an awful ordeal, as well as on her family and myself, because we had to deal with the impact on her,’ said Beth.

The Haven said it could not comment on the details of the case but where police were called referral became their responsibility: ‘When someone who has been raped or sexually assaulted attends our emergency department, our clinical teams must carry out medical assessments to ensure that they do not need ongoing care in the acute hospital. They are triaged as quickly as possible and offered the option to speak to the police. If they do want to talk to the police, the police then take the lead on collection of forensic evidence and referral to the Haven.’

One factor played a crucial role in how Ella was treated: she has learning difficulties and autism. With the help of her sister, Ella managed to give a clear account to the A&E doctor of what had happened, including a detailed account of oral and vaginal rape. But after leaving King’s she was interviewed alone by police, who decided that she had only had oral sex–although even if Ella had only been orally raped, she should still have qualified for a Haven referral.

Beth’s view is that her sister’s difficulty in communicating meant she should have been given a thorough examination as a precaution: ‘Given that she had said something different while in the hospital … the police should not have treated what she said in the interview as set in stone.’ Beth said she had later been told by the police that when the man her sister had accused was interviewed he had admitted to having sex but claimed it had been consensual–so the police had decided to take no further action.

Officers had told her they couldn’t put Ella, as a vulnerable person, through the courts. Yet they had not assessed Ella’s capacity before interviewing her or arranged for her to be supported during the interview. ‘It really does cause me great upset when I look back at the complete faith I had in all services involved,’ Beth said.

The Metropolitan Police refused to discuss the case, although it did contact Beth to discuss her concerns.

Read more