Published time: September 06, 2013 04:06
The number of arrests made for low-level violations in New York City grew exponentially over the past decade, a result of the so-called “zero tolerance” policy that sought to prevent people from committing future crimes by arresting them preemptively.
New York Mayor Michael Bloomberg has spent much of his final year
in office defending the city’s stop-and-frisk policy, which a
federal judge ruled was unconstitutional in August. But while he
and Police Commissioner Ray Kelly fended off allegations of
stop-and-frisk’s inherent racial discrimination, complaints about
severe policing have largely stayed out of the headlines.
Nearly 90,000 additional people were arrested in 2010 compared to
when Bloomberg took office in 2002, according to new numbers
published by DNAinfo.com. Then, two years later, 60,000 more
people were arrested than the decade prior.
“The majority of those people were picked up for public
urination, turnstile jumping, drinking on the street, smoking pot
and disorderly conduct, and then put through the criminal justice
system,” wrote criminal justice journalist Murray Weiss.
“As the number of arrests for minor crimes rose dramatically,
arrests for serious crimes — such as rape, robbery and assault —
declined roughly 10 percent during the same period.”
Former New York City Police Commissioner William Bratton
introduced the policy during his tenure in the 1990s, when New
York was struggling to shed the crime image it earned over the
previous three decades.
Despite criticism from civil liberties advocates, Bloomberg
continued that philosophy, cracking down on relatively minor
offenses with the idea that an arrest was preventing an
inevitable future crime.
“Does this approach sweep up some criminals? Yes. Does
it keep them from doing something worse? Probably,” a
former police officer told journalist Weiss. “But is it worth
what it is costing the city in terms of overtime,
police-community relations, and clogging the court system?
I don’t think so.”
Arrests peaked in 2010, with 422,982 people taken into custody,
although 383,869 of those were for low-level offenses. Court
statistics indicate that judges do not take many of the “zero
tolerance” arrests seriously, throwing out approximately 10
percent of New York’s quality-of-life arrests without taking any
court action, according to DNAinfo.com.
Crime has fallen 30 percent during Bloomberg’s tenure, although
he and Kelly have been criticized for crediting stop-and-frisk
and instructing officers to be overzealous. Violent offenses —
murder, rape, and robbery — remain a concerning problem in
cities, but such crime has overall fallen in the US for five
straight years, leading many to wonder whether New York’s
policies are particularly effective or simply part of a national
trend.
“At the end of the day, crime is going to go down, and there
is a validation to the overly zealous approach because it is a
secret to the success,” a former NYPD tactician told Weiss,
later adding that the policies can easily be manipulated by
lawmakers. “You have to constantly re-evaluate what you are
doing and ask, ‘Are you getting the right persons?’”
Republished from: RT
