Court Case of Suspected Terrorist
A JURY in the trial of a student accused of terror offences must decide if he is “a wannabe suicide bomber” or a “foolishly stupid young man” simply researching Islamic terrorism.
Prosecutor Brian McConnachie, QC, yesterday told the members of the jury they should convict Mohammed Atif Siddique, 21, of three out of four terror charges he faces.
Siddique’s counsel said the suggestion was “unpalatable and ridiculous” and argued it was legitimate for the accused to access information to understand Muslim terrorists’ behaviour.
Siddique, of Alva, Clackmannanshire, denies the terror charges and a breach of the peace.
Summing up the case for the prosecution, Mr McConnachie said: “This is not someone who is systematically carrying out research into Islamic politics and the difficulties facing Muslims in the Middle East, this is a wannabe suicide bomber.”
And, referring to documents and videos allegedly found on Siddique’s computer and a CD discovered under a carpet in his family home, Mr McConnachie added: “The whole ethos is to get the message across as to what people should be doing.
“It is saying if you are a Muslim you should be going to [wage] Jihad [holy war].”
Mr McConnachie said it was very significant that Siddique allegedly took the name Yah Yah Ayash as one of his aliases during online chats.
Ayash was Hamas’s chief bomb-maker, responsible for making the explosives used by suicide bombers in Palestinian and a man revered by both Hamas and al-Qaeda.
Donald Findlay, QC, defending, began his speech by quoting from the Koran and said the jury should not be “bound into a conviction” through a “fear or alarm” of Islam.
And Mr Findlay claimed that the suggestion that Siddique wanted to be a suicide bomber “has no crumb of evidence”.
The QC criticised a website run by terrorist expert Evan Kohlmann, who earlier gave evidence against Siddique, - claiming its content, such as the beheading of a US hostage, was the “most horrific ever shown to a jury”.
He added: “It is not challenged that he [Siddique] downloaded material. If it was training, then so is Evan Kohlmann’s [material].
“Instead of being brought from the US to be put in the witness box, he should have been put in the dock.
“Is it not legitimate that Mr Siddique can find out why young Muslim men like him act the way they do? It would not matter if he had 100 times the amount of material he had. You, the jury, have to be satisfied that it was for a terrorist attack.”
Mr Findlay concluded: “He [Siddique] is a young man who has said things that are distasteful, which you may not agree with. However, that does not make him a suicide bomber.
“You cannot put someone on trial for what he says or thinks.
In this country, we have the right, protected by law, and the freedom to do, say and think what you like.
“We also have the freedom to be wise or foolish.”
The jury is expected to retire to consider its verdict today.
Have Your Say: Court Case of Suspected Terrorist
Please read our posting guidelines before posting.
Alternatively you can discuss this report here.
This entry was posted on Friday, September 14th, 2007 at 3:34 am and is filed under Breaking News . You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.
Translations
Loading ...Related News
- De Menezes shooting trial jury out
- Countdown: Wounded vet calls Limbaugh’s comparison of him to suicide bomber ‘repugnant’
- Four guilty of plotting July 21 suicide attacks on London transport system
- Negativity on Islam ‘fuels tension’
- Al-Qaeda warns of attacks ‘worse than 9/11′
Email This Page To A Friend
Latest Headlines
- L.A. City Council Decides to Outlaw New Fast Food Restaurants
- A Cultural History of the Magic Mushroom
- US oil pipeline politics and the Russia-Georgia conflict
- Pentagon can’t find $2.3 trillion, wasting trillions on ‘national defense’
- New Guidelines Would Give F.B.I. Broader Powers
- Scientists to study synthetic telepathy
- London tube workers hit back at profiteers
- Britain’s terror laws have left me and my family shattered
- Police to get £40m mobile fingerprinting kit
- Libby questioned on forged letter linking Saddam to 9/11
More Breaking News
Archive
