Julia La Roche
June 24, 2013
Once again, we have some more embarrassing conversations between bankers…
The Irish Independent, a Dublin-based newspaper, has uncovered tapes of an internal phone conversation from September 2008 between two executives at Anglo Irish Bank during its bailout deal and they sound pretty scandalous. The Irish Independent points out that the recordings show they misled the Central Bank.
The executives from the recording have been identified as John Bowe (head of the bank’s capital markets) and Peter Fitzgerald (director of retail banking).
However, Bowe “categorically denied” that he misled the Central Bank and Fitzgerald, who wasn’t involved in discussions with regulators, said he was unaware of any intention to mislead, the report said.
WARNING: Graphic language!
Either way, the newly revealed recordings are still embarrassing.
Here are some partial excerpts (via the Irish Independent):
The two bankers begin their conversation jokingly comparing themselves to being able to walk on water and drink beer out of both hands.
John Bowe: “Hello”
Receptionist: “John I have Peter Fitz for you.”
Bowe: “Oh yeah, OK.”
Bowe: “As me granny used to say, you must be therapeutic…”
Peter Fitzgerald: “What does that mean? Can I work the computer is it? (Both laugh)
Bowe: “Therapeutic. Therapeutic…I was just ringing you.”
Fitzgerald: “I’m ambidextrous as well. It means I can walk on land and water.” (More laughter)
Bowe: “You can drink, you can drink beer out of both hands…” (laughter)
Then they get down to business. Bowe tells Fitzgerald that they met with the Irish Financial Services Regulatory Authority (IFSRA) the previous day about getting â‚¬7 billion. They laugh how they will never be able to pay it back.
Bowe: “So we went down … and we basically said. In Central, yeah. And I mean, to cut a long story short we sort of said. ‘Look, what we need is seven billion euros…and we’re going to give you and we’re going to give you, what we’re going to give you is our loan collateral so we’re not giving you ECB, we’re giving you the loan clause.
“We gave him a term sheet and we put a pro not facility together and we said that’s what we need. And that kind of sobered up everybody pretty quickly, you know.”
Fitzgerald: “And is that â‚¬7 billion a term?”
Bowe: “This is â‚¬7 billion bridging.”
Bowe: “So … so it is bridged until we can pay you back … which is never.” (Both laugh)
Then they joke how the regulators would need to change their underpants after hearing the terms of that deal.
Bowe: “So under the terms that say repayment, we say; ‘No …'” (laughter)
Fitzgerald: (Laughing) “None…just none. Not applicable. OK and what did he say? ‘I need a change of underwear?’
Fitzgerald: “Jesus that’s a lot of dosh … Jesus f—–g hell and God … well do you know the Central Bank only has â‚¬14 billion of total investments so that would be going up 20 … Gee..that would be seen.
Bowe: (Laughing) “There was a bit of that … there was a bit of that. ‘And how would we do that? We would need to give you … we need to … ‘Jesus you’re kind of asking us to play ducks and drakes with the regulations.’ And we said: ‘Yeah.’ We said: ‘Look what we are telling you is if we get into difficulties, we have 100,000 plus lump sum depositors in Ireland all of whom would be very vocal.'”
Fitzgerald asks Bowe how he came up with the 7 billion figure. Bowe responds that like then-CEO David Drumm, he picked it out of his “arse.”
Fitzgerald: “Ah we are, yeah, yeah and, em, what, how did you arrive at the seven?
Bowe: “Just, as Drummer would say, ‘picked it out of my arse’, you know. Em … I mean, look, what we did was we basically said: ‘What is the amount we can securitize over the next six months?’ And basically say to them: ‘Look our problem is time, it’s not our ability to create the liquidity, the enemy is time here.'”
Bowe: “So we can rebuild, in other words, we can rebuild the liquidity off our loan book, but what we can’t do, we can’t do it now and the balance sheet’s leaking now.”
Bowe tells Fitzgerald that they actually need more money than the 7 billion figure.
Bowe: Yeah and that number is seven, but the reality is that actually we need more than that. But the strategy here is you pull them in, you get them to write a big [check] and they have to keep, they have to support their money, you know.”
Fitzgerald: “Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. They’ve got skin in the game and that’s the key.”
Bowe: “They have and they have invested a lot. If they saw, if they saw, the enormity of it up front, they might decide, they might decide they have a choice. You know what I mean? They might say the cost to the taxpayer is too high. But … em … if it doesn’t look too big at the outset…if it looks big, big enough to be important, but not too big that it kind of spoils everything,
Fitzgerald: “Yeah, Yeah.”