I worked as Roy Moore’s staff attorney for over three years and know him well. Depicted as a right-wing loon, he’s actually a pensive man who authored thoughtful opinions as chief justice of the Alabama Supreme Court.
Five opinions written by Moore stand out as reasons libertarians could support him in the Alabama primary to fill the U.S. Senate seat once held by Jeff Sessions. Like most of his opinions, these received little fanfare or notice.
*
I.
Ex parte Brooker, 192 So. 3d 1 (Ala. 2015)
Lee Carroll Brooker, now a 78-year-old inmate at Holman Prison, petitioned the Alabama Supreme Court for a writ of certiorari, challenging his sentence to life imprisonment without the possibility for parole for a non-violent crime involving marijuana. The Court denied his petition. Moore dissented, calling the sentence “excessive and unjustified.”
Moore was troubled by testimony regarding the search of Brooker’s residence, where investigators found marijuana plants. One of the investigators testified that Brooker’s son, not Brooker, consented to the search of Brooker’s home. Brooker was not physically present when his son allegedly consented. Brooker testified that, when officers showed up at his house, he asked to see a search warrant, which they did not have. “I’m not consenting to a search,” he claims to have told them.
Moore would have granted Brooker’s petition. “I urge the legislature,” he wrote in his dissent, “to revisit that statutory sentencing scheme [under which Brooker was sentenced] to determine whether it serves an appropriate purpose.”
II.
Ex parte W.F., 214 So. 3D 1153 (Ala. 2015)
Three juveniles, one of whom was a gun enthusiast, set out one evening for a hunting cabin with…