Statist Monetary Cranks

I have been writing refutations of monetary cranks for over half a century.

I wrote my first essay on a monetary crank, Gertrude Coogan, in 1965. Her book was Money Creators. It came out in the 1930’s in the Great Depression. That was the golden era of anti-gold standard fiat monetary cranks.

I wrote the essay because R. J. Rushdoony had been taken in by the cranks in the late 1950’s. Specifically, he read the greenbackers. He also read Mises, but he did not understand Mises’ monetary theory.

The greenback monetary cranks have always been opposed to the Federal Reserve. Why? Because the regional Federal Reserve banks are privately owned. They hate all private banking. They are committed statists. They originally were people of the Left in the late 1880’s. Today, they are found on the Right, but they are in no way defenders of the free market. They want Congress in control of money. They also teach that there can and should be zero interest rates in society. This is sheer quackery. It is the equivalent of faith in perpetual motion. Mises was the great opponent of such an idea.

As I say, Rushdoony did not understand Mises on this point. At the William Volker Fund in 1963, where Rushdoony worked, and I was a summer intern, I spent the summer reading Mises. I was paid to do this. It was the best job I ever had. At the Volker Fund, Rushdoony had stocked the give-away book shelf with monetary crank books. I knew there was a problem.

Finally, in 1965, I wrote a long paper for Rushdoony on Coogan when I was in grad school. I did it for free. He immediately dropped references to her. He never quoted a monetary crank’s arguments on money again. He learned.

I published that essay in my book, An Introduction to Christian Economics, in 1973. You can read it 

Read more