Who Says It’s Necessary?

This essay is taken from Human Scale Revisited: A New Look at the Classic Case for a Decentralist Future by Kirkpatrick Sale, published this month.

Historically there have been four general arguments for the necessity of the state:

  1. To provide defense in case of attack and to guarantee peace and security.
  2. To provide economic regulation and development.
  3. To provide public services beyond the competence of the community and the individual.
  4. To assure social justice and protect the rights of the individual.

These arguments have a persuasive feel to them—they should, they’ve been drummed into us for centuries—but it is fair to ask: do they stand up? are they sufficient justifications for the existence of the state?

Current Prices on popular forms of Gold Bullion

DEFENSE

Traditionally the state’s initial claim to necessity was that it prevented warfare by erecting firm barriers of defense. This is tommyrot: the duration and severity of war has always increased with an increase in state power. Larger states, far from providing peace, merely provide larger wars, having more human and material resources to pour into them. War is the health of the state, as Randolph Bourne has said, precisely because it provides the excuse for increased state power and the means by which to achieve it.

Insofar as “defense” implies security, the state is the instrument least capable of providing this. Indeed, in the contemporary world of massed nuclear weapons, there simply is no defense of the citizens from a hostile aggressor.  The very presence of the state and its huge pile of threatening weapons endangers rather than protects the populace, by inviting pre-emptive strikes.

Human Scale Revisited:…
Kirkpatrick Sale
Best Price: $12.50
Buy New $16.86

Moreover, in the…

Read more