Bear Crying Wolf?

A perennially bearish hedge fund manager with an Austrian economics bent recently appeared as a guest on the Tom Woods Show.  Tom Woods opened the discussion with:

What do you say to somebody who says, “The trouble with you Austrian-influenced financial guys is that you’re always bearish, so of course you’re going to be right when things go wrong.  Why should I listen to you now?”

Great question.  Are we Austrians eventually right, but always early?  Is this one “big, fat, ugly bubble” that, when it bursts, will vindicate all of us?  Are we just flat wrong?  Is Austrian Business Cycle Theory (ABCT) out of touch with reality?  Or are we stopped clocks, right twice a day, but miss out on a lot of opportunities the rest of the time?

Current Prices on popular forms of Silver Bullion

The answer is not that simple.  It never is.

The problem starts with group dynamics and oversimplified narratives.  Intellectually, we all tend to gravitate to one camp.  Get too close, and we breathe the same air, chew on the same ideas, and insulate ourselves from outside views and feedback.  Often a common narrative forms which never measures up to the complexity of the real world.  Sometimes a group can achieve overnight success, attracting camp followers who pick and choose those ideas that best fit their own narratives, ignoring the rest.  As a result, the group gradually moves away from reality towards soundbites and clichés.

Democracy is clearly susceptible to these tendencies, as Alexis de Tocqueville observed on his travels to America from 1835-1840:

Generally speaking, only simple conceptions can grip the mind of a nation.  An idea that is clear and precise even though false will always have greater power in the world than an idea that is true but…

Read more