A couple of days after the US presidential upset, we’re in the precarious intermezzo where the dust is settling but impressions still linger. While the torrent of Wednesday morning quarterbacking by sundry wonks, mavens and talking heads certainly contains elements of good analysis, it’s wise to capture some subtler points before they get lost in the palliative mainstream spin. The following list – not necessarily original and certainly not exhaustive – is an attempted contribution, by way of highlighting some of the less obvious losers in Tuesday’s outcome, along with associated lessons.
- Private polling. Beyond the obvious, it is high time to thoroughly reexamine its role in elections for public office. Its controlling influence in determining who gets to participate in the highly influential nationally televised debates is already scandalous and of questionable legality; this latest debacle simply means it should be banished from the process forever. There are strict, publicly accountable processes determining which presidential tickets get to be nationally balloted (i.e. exposed to enough electoral votes to be able to win), and they should get to participate in nationally broadcast debates, if any. Period.
- Mainstream media. The standard retort of the industry was summarized by the PBS Newshour anchor’s response to bias criticism the day after the election, stressing alleged media reliance…