Nuclear Standoff: Human Conscience Dismissed on a Technicality

Values the size of Planet Earth are at stake, as the American presidential
election grows ever smaller, ever pettier, ever more certain that rancor triumphs
over relevance.

Can you imagine, let us say, an issue the size of global nuclear disarmament
emerging in this race, somewhere between the groper tapes and the hacked DNC
emails? What if – my God – we lived in a country in which such a matter were
seriously and publicly discussed, not shunted off to the margins with a grimace
and a smirk? The only thing that has mainstream credibility in this country
is business as usual, which comes to us wrapped in platitudes about strength
and greatness but in reality is mostly about war and profit and the destruction
of the planet.

Meanwhile it’s three minutes to midnight.

And the Republic of the Marshall Islands has lost its case in the International
Court of Justice. On a technicality, no less! Phon van den Biesen, lead attorney
for the tiny island nation, which had sued the world’s nine nuclear powers –
the United States, Russia, China, Great Britain, France, Israel, India, Pakistan
and North Korea – to begin real nuclear disarmament negotiations, said the case
was dismissed earlier this month on a “microformality,”
which in my layman’s grasp of the matter might be called, instead, a desperate
legal copout.

The case, which, technically, was brought against only three of the nine nuclear
powers, Great Britain, India and Pakistan (because those are the only three
nations that acknowledge the binding authority of the ICJ), was dismissed –
in a split decision that could be called the First World against the rest of
humanity – on the grounds that there wasn’t sufficient evidence of a dispute
between the parties, so the court had no jurisdiction to hear the case on its
merits.

Huh?

The ICJ’s dissenting judges (in the case against Great Britain, the verdict
to dismiss was 9-7, against India and Pakistan it was 8-8), expressed as much
incredulity as I did on hearing the news.

The Marshall Islands lawsuits (a second suit was also filed, specifically against
the United States, in U.S. federal court, and is still pending) demanded compliance
with Article VI of the 1968 Nuclear Nonproliferation Treaty, signed by the US
in 1970, which reads: “Each of the Parties to the Treaty undertakes to pursue
negotiations in good faith on effective measures relating to cessation of the
nuclear arms race at an early date and to nuclear disarmament, and on a treaty
on general and complete disarmament under strict and effective international
control.”

“General and complete disarmament – do these words
actually have meaning?” I asked last January. “Right now the Marshall Islands
stand alone among the nations of Planet Earth in believing that they do.”

This tiny nation…

Read more