While the mainstream media focuses on losers and winners in the race between
Hillary Clinton and Donald Trump, a largely unreported debate is going on over
the future course of U.S. diplomacy. Its outcome will have a profound effect
on how Washington projects power – both diplomatic and military – in the coming
decade.
The issues at stake are hardly abstract. The United States is currently engaged
in active wars in Afghanistan, Iraq, Syria, Yemen, and Somalia. It has deployed
troops on the Russian border, played push –and-shove with China in Asia, and
greatly extended its military footprint on the African
continent. It would not be an exaggeration to say – as former US Secretary
of Defense William Perry has recently done – that the world is a more dangerous
place today than it was during darkest times of the Cold War.
Tracking the outlines of this argument is not easy, in part because the participants
are not always forthcoming about what they are proposing, in part because the
media oversimplifies the issues. In its broadest framework, “realists” represented
by former National Security Advisor Henry Kissinger, Harvard’s Steven Walt,
and University of Chicago’s John Mearsheimer have squared off against “humanitarian
interventionists” like current UN Ambassador Samantha Power. Given that Power
is a key advisor to the Obama administration on foreign policy and is likely
to play a similar role if Clinton is elected, her views carry weight.
In a recent essay in the New
York Review of Books, Power asks, “How is a statesman to advance his
nation’s interests?” She begins by hijacking the realist position that US diplomacy
must reflect “national interests,” arguing that they are indistinguishable from
“moral values.” What happens to people in other countries, she argues, is in
our “national security.”
Power – along with Clinton and former President Bill Clinton – has long been an
advocate for “humanitarian intervention,” behind which the United States intervened
in the Yugoslav civil war. Humanitarian intervention has since been formalized
into “responsibility to Protect,” or R2P, and was the rationale for overthrowing
Muammar Gaddafi in Libya. Hillary Clinton has argued forcibly for applying R2P
to Syria by setting up “no-fly zones” to block Syrian and Russian planes from
bombing insurgents and the civilians under their control.
But Power is proposing something different than humanitarian intervention.
She is suggesting that the United States elevate R2P to the level of national
security, which sounds uncomfortably like an argument for US intervention in
any place that doesn’t emulate the American system.
Facing Off against the Kremlin
Most telling is her choice of examples: Russia, China, and Venezuela, all currently
in Washington’s…