Since NATO’s 1999 war on Serbia, U.S. officials have followed a script demonizing
targeted foreign leaders, calling ultimatums “diplomacy,” lying about “war as
a last resort” and selling aggression as humanitarianism
Nicolas J. S. Davies
Since NATO’s 1999 war on Serbia, US officials have followed a script
demonizing targeted foreign leaders, calling ultimatums “diplomacy,” lying about
“war as a last resort” and selling aggression as humanitarianism, says
Nicolas J S Davies.
By Nicolas J S Davies
Across the political spectrum, US leaders insist that they will only go to
war “as a last resort.” They want us to believe that they will try every peaceful
means to resolve differences with other countries before resorting to war. But
if those “peaceful means” mean only ultimatums that are unacceptable to the
target country, then US leaders are simply going through a diplomatic charade
before going to war.
In such a case, “war as a last resort” refers only to the means of achieving
a goal, not to the rights or wrongs of the goal itself. If the underlying purpose
is to impose the will of the US government on another country or society, then
“war as a last resort” amounts to an illegal threat of war to compel a country
to submit to US demands, not a commitment to peace or to the rule of law.
As I wrote last
February, former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton uses the term “diplomacy”
to mean precisely this kind of brinksmanship, which creates a pretext for war
if the other side won’t back down and is quite different from diplomacy
to resolve international disputes peacefully, as required by the United Nations
Charter and customary international law.
When Clinton told a televised “national security” forum that she “view(s) force
as a last resort, not a first choice,” she was echoing what she and Sen. Bernie
Sanders both said in Democratic Party debates. But in Clinton’s case, using
the phrase “last resort” in this way is a clever way to reassure her listeners
without actually modifying her hawkish and coercive approach to international
relations. By contrast, Sanders was on firmer ground since he voted against
two wars on Iraq (in 1990 and 2002), but did vote for war on Yugoslavia in 1999,
a vote he still defends.
In negotiations at Rambouillet, France, in 1999, Secretary of State Madeleine
Albright gave Yugoslavia only a devil’s choice between agreeing to a NATO military
occupation (of all its
remaining territory, not just Kosovo) and a NATO assault. When President
Slobodan Milosevic refused these impossible terms, the West blamed him for triggering
a U.S.-led war that was neither a war of self-defense nor a U.N.-backed collective
security operation. In other words, it was a war of aggression by the US and
NATO against a largely…