What, precisely, is the US military for, and what, precisely, can it do? In
practical terms, how powerful is it? On paper, it is formidable, huge, with
carrier battle groups, advanced technology, remarkable submarines, satellites,
and so on. What does this translate to?
Military power does not exist independently, but only in relation to specific
circumstances. Comparing technical specifications of the T-14 to those of the
M1A2, or Su-34 to F-15, or numbers of this to numbers of that, is an interesting
intellectual exercise. It means little without reference to specific circumstances.
For example, America is vastly superior militarily to North Korea in every
category of arms – but the North has nuclear bombs. It can’t deliver them to the
US, but probably can to Seoul. Even without nuclear weapons, it has a large
army and large numbers of artillery tubes within range of Seoul. It has an unpredictable
government. As Gordon Liddy said, if your responses to provocation are wildly
out of proportion to those provocations, and unpredictable, nobody will provoke
you.
An American attack by air on the North, the only attack possible short of a
preemptive nuclear strike, would offer a high probability of a peninsular war,
devastation of Seoul, paralysis of an important trading partner – think Samsung – and
an uncertain final outcome. The United States hasn’t the means of getting troops
to Korea rapidly in any numbers, and the domestic political results of lots
of GIs killed by a serious enemy would be politically grave. The probable cost
far exceeds any possible benefit. In practical terms, Washington’s military
superiority means nothing with regard to North Korea. Pyongyang knows it.
Or consider the Ukraine. On paper, US forces overall are superior to Russian.
Locally, they are not. Russia borders on the Ukraine and could overrun it quickly.
The US cannot rapidly bring force to bear except a degree of air power. Air
power hasn’t worked against defenseless peasants in many countries. Russia is
not a defenseless peasant. Europe, usually docile and obedient to America, is
unlikely to engage in a shooting war with Moscow for the benefit of Washington.
Europeans are aware that Russia borders on Eastern Europe, which borders on
Western Europe. For Washington, fighting Russia in the Ukraine would require
a huge effort with seaborne logistics and a national mobilization. Serious wars
with nuclear powers do not represent the height of judgment.
Again, Washington’s military superiority means nothing.
Or consider Washington’s dispute with China in the Pacific. China cannot begin
to match American naval power. It doesn’t have to. Beijing has focused on anti-ship
missiles – read “carrier-killer” – such as the JD21 ballistic missile. How well
it works I do not know, but the Chinese are…