How Media Distorted Syrian Ceasefire’s Breakdown

Coverage of the breakdown of the partial ceasefire in Syria illustrated the
main way corporate news media distort public understanding of a major foreign
policy story. The problem is not that the key events in the story are entirely
unreported, but that they were downplayed and quickly forgotten in the media’s
embrace of themes with which they were more comfortable.

In this case, the one key event was the major offensive launched in early April
by Al Nusra Front – the Al Qaeda franchise in Syria – alongside US-backed armed
opposition groups. This offensive was mentioned in at least two “quality” US
newspapers. Their readers, however, would not have read that it was that offensive
that broke the back of the partial ceasefire. On the contrary, they would have
gotten the clear impression from following the major newspapers’ coverage that
systematic violations by the Assad government doomed the ceasefire from the
beginning.

Framing the Breakdown Before the Fact

Corporate media heralded the ceasefire agreement when it was negotiated by
the United States and Russia in February, with the LA Times (2/3/16)
calling it “the most determined diplomatic push to date aimed at ending
the nation’s almost five-year conflict.” The “partial cessation
of hostilities” was to apply between the Syrian regime and the non-jihadist
forces, but not to the regime’s war with Nusra and with ISIS. The
clear implication was
that the US-supported non-jihadist opposition forces
would have to separate themselves from Nusra, or else they would be legitimate
targets for airstrikes.

But the relationship between the CIA-backed armed opposition to Assad and the
jihadist Nusra Front was an issue that major US newspapers had already found
very difficult to cover (FAIR.org, 3/21/16).
US Syria policy has been dependent on the military potential of the Nusra Front
(and its close ally, Ahrar al Sham) for leverage on the Syrian regime, since
the “moderate” opposition was unable to operate in northwest Syria without jihadist
support. This central element in US Syria policy, which both the government
and the media were unwilling to acknowledge, was a central obstacle to accurate
coverage of what happened to the Syrian ceasefire.

This problem began shaping the story as soon as the ceasefire agreement was
announced. On February 23, New York Times correspondent Neil MacFarquhar
wrote a news analysis
on the wider tensions between the Obama administration
and Russia that pointed to “a gaping loophole” in the Syria ceasefire agreement:
the fact that “it permits attacks against the Islamic State and the Nusra Front,
an Al Qaeda affiliate, to continue.”

MacFarquhar asserted that exempting Nusra from the ceasefire “could work in
Moscow’s favor, since many of the anti-Assad groups aligned with the United…

Read more