Europe suffered another
tragic terrorist attack Thursday night, as a white semi-truck deliberately
ran over scores of pedestrians in Nice, France. Reports put the death toll at
84 while more than 200 were wounded. The truck driver was also armed and apparently
opened fire on civilians before ultimately being killed by police. At this point,
authorities believe there was only one attacker.
At the time of this writing, there have been no formal claims of responsibility
by ISIS or any other group, but the New
York Times reports that ISIS occasionally takes as reports
as two days before taking credit. We also know relatively little about the attacker
himself, though one report claimed he was Franco-Tunisian.
Given how little information has been publicly released so far, it’s possible
that this was simply a random act of extraordinary violence. It is far more
likely that it was a politically-motivated terrorist attack like the ones in
Paris and Brussels that have also occurred over the past two years. Indeed,
French President
Hollande’s remarks in the wake of the attack mentioned stepping up military
action in Iraq and Syria, so it seems reasonable to assume there’s a plausible
connection to radical groups in the Middle East.
As this appears to be yet another terrorist attack, a couple observations are
worth making.
The False Tradeoff
Typically, the debate following attacks like these proceeds along two dimensions.
There is a proposed domestic response designed to reduce the probability of
similar attacks taking place in the future. And there is a proposed foreign
response to punish the ones responsible – or more realistically, to punish a
lot of random people that have the misfortune of living in the general vicinity
of wherever the attacker and his friends are from. But I digress.
The domestic discussion takes place along the familiar lines of the liberty
vs. security axis. Authorities invariably promise more security if they have
more power over individual citizens. Benjamin Franklin’s famous quote is dutifully
cited in defense. But a terrified and bewildered population is primed for the
security argument, and this side typically wins out.
The problem with the liberty-security debate is that it assumes the tradeoff
is actually possible. Just as economists
used to believe there was a reliable tradeoff between inflation and unemployment,
security experts of today presume that liberty and security have a straightforward
inverse relationship. When economists tried to put their views into practice,
the theory quickly broke down. In the US, the stagflation of the 1970s, characterized
by simultaneously high inflation and unemployment, showed that the previous
assumption did not hold. A dangerous and mistaken paradigm was largely scuttled.
The same thing needs to happen for liberty…