Wednesday, two shocking videos of police officers
fatally shooting civilians (Alton
Sterling and Philando
Castile) surfaced. The day before, many were appalled to hear the Director
of the FBI announce that Hillary Clinton would not be charged for mishandling
classified information. The two events may seem unrelated, but at bottom, they
concern the same fundamental problem: impunity.
Impunity is the essence of power. What, after
all, is power? Is it simply the capacity to exert unjust force? The ability
to impress one’s will upon the flesh or belongings of another? No, it’s more
than that.
Most anyone can wield unjust force. Anyone
could walk out onto the street right now and exert their will on somebody weaker:
say, pushing over an old lady or stealing candy from a baby. And the toughest,
or most heavily-armed guy in town can strong-arm just about any other single
person.
But isolated incidents of aggression do not
constitute power. The “reign” of the rogue rampager is generally short-lived.
It only lasts until the community recognizes him as the menace to society that
he is and neutralizes him.
Power isn’t simply about the exertion of unjust force. It is about what happens
next, after the exertion. Does the perpetrator generally get away with, or not?
Systematically getting away with it – or impunity – is where power
truly lies. And that is what makes agents of the State different from any other
bully. State agents can violate rights with reliable impunity because a critical
mass of the public considers the aggression of state agents to be exceptionally
legitimate. Impunity is power, and as Lord Acton said, power corrupts.
The Impunity of the Badge
State impunity is at the root of the problem
of police violence. As agents of the exalted State, the police are seen as paladins
of public order. The populace grants cops a special dispensation to commit violence
that would be considered criminal if perpetrated by anybody else. This privilege
is enshrined in law most clearly as the doctrine of “qualified immunity.” As
Evan Bernick of the Institute for Justice wrote:
In the 1967 case of Pierson v. Ray, the Supreme Court held
that police officers sued for constitutional violations can raise ‘qualified
immunity’ as a defense, and thereby escape paying out of their own pockets,
even if they violated a person’s constitutional rights.
When victims of police violence or their heirs
seek redress and are awarded monetary payments, it is taxpayers, and not the
cops, who pick up the tab. Police officers are rarely even prosecuted for violence
inflicted while they’re on the clock. The worst that an offending officer can
generally expect to face is getting fired, but he will more likely just get
a paid suspension.
Thus insulated from responsibility, officer
treatment…