Things My Students Don’t Know

One of the discussion exercises I use in my course on corporate power begins with the bare text of the First Amendment projected on screen at the front of the room. I tell students that this is a recently proposed piece of federal legislation and invite their comments. I also say that if anyone has heard of the proposal, they should remain quiet for the time being and let others speak first.

The comments are always the same. Some students say that the language is old-fashioned, unclear, and likely to produce confusion. After we parse it and clarify what the proposal means, some students argue that it goes too far in allowing people to say whatever they want. Others think the legislation would be a good idea, but they still want the language made more reader friendly.

When I reveal that what’s on the screen is the First Amendment to the U.S. Constitution, and that it has been the law of the land since 1791, students are surprised and embarrassed. Usually, someone will try to save face by saying, “I thought it looked familiar.” The last time I used the exercise, when I identified the text as the First Amendment, one student said, “Man, I feel like I’ve had a shitty education up to this point.”

My students, whose SAT scores are good enough to get them into a selective public research university, are not alone in their ignorance. According to a 2015 survey by the Newseum Institute, 33% of American adults can’t name any freedoms protected by the First Amendment,…

Read more