As Bob Dylan put it, “the times they are a changing!” – and that is certainly
the case when it comes to the debate over US foreign policy this election season.
A recent
article in the Boston Globe, summarizing the observations of a group
of Brown University students who tracked the foreign policy discourse of the
candidates, underscored what is happening on both sides of the partisan divide:
“As we watched, Republican voters rejected
every candidate who favored their party’s traditional hardline foreign policies,
including Lindsey Graham, Chris Christie, Jeb Bush, and Marco Rubio…. Trump,
the presumptive nominee, has broken with foreign policy dogma on a host of issues.
He asserts that decades of foreign wars have not been good for the United States
– hardly a traditional Republican view.”
The Democratic party, too, is experiencing what these youthful observers describe
as a “foreign policy identity crisis”:
“Clinton, the likely nominee, is an activist by nature and supports escalation
from Afghanistan to Syria to Ukraine. Her opponent, Senator Bernie Sanders,
has condemned her ‘very aggressive policy of intervention’ and said he does
not believe the United States should be ‘the world’s policeman.’ Yet though
Sanders effectively pushed Clinton further left in terms of domestic policy,
he was unsuccessful in changing her deeply held foreign policy views.”
The two parties are undergoing a process of “role reversal,” as these students
put it, right before our eyes. Trump is now attacking “trigger happy Hillary,”
while Mrs. Clinton is parrying these thrusts with accusations that “dangerous
Donald” lacks the steadiness of an Establishment politician who sticks with
the familiar script that casts America in the role of “the indispensable nation”
destined to police the world.
With the fall of the Soviet Union and the evaporation of the international
communist movement as a credible threat to US national security, American conservatives
have been steadily moving – in fits and starts – back to their historic position
of nonintervention in the affairs of other nations. Neoconservatism was an anomaly,
a tangent occasioned by the alleged necessities of the cold war: its life was
prolonged by the 9/11 attacks, but as the effect of that signal event wore off,
and as the country exhausted itself in a futile (and losing) military campaign
to make the Middle East into an Arabic version of Kansas, the rebellion against
the neocons gathered strength and finally triumphed. No matter what the fate
of Trump’s candidacy, and in spite of his other controversial views, he has
succeeded in overthrowing the old GOP foreign policy orthodoxy and replacing
it with what he calls a policy of “America First.”
And while this inward-looking nationalism has its…