Taking Responsibility for War

On May 10, 92-year-old Henry Kissinger was given the Distinguished
Public Service Award by Secretary
of Defense Ashton Carter.
It does little good to be outraged by this news,
in that Kissinger may have the blood of (at least) hundreds of thousands of
dead people on his hands, but that seems to bother very
few people.
Let us at least not take the time to bother being surprised.

Sure, we can mention former Secretary of State Kissinger, we can
seriously debate how many Cambodians, Chileans, and East Timorese he is responsible
for killing. But at the end of it all, Kissinger is an old man with a funny
accent and even seemingly bold and political (at least when going up against
George W. Bush) people such as comedian Stephen Colbert feel comfortable palling
around with him. If the man who so memorably trashed a sitting president to
his face finds it okay to make cute with Kissinger, yeah, let’s give the man
the finest civilian honor (and, you know, the Nobel Peace Prize. But jokes about
that have been exhausted for decades).

Madeleine Albright, the first female Secretary of State who oversaw
Bill Clinton’s nasty sanctions and sporadic bombing of Iraq in the 1990s is
another officially cute old person accordingly to popular culture. Albright
has made guest appearances on some great
TV shows
. To some, she’s a kind of feminist success story for being so powerful
and also a woman. Debate lingers over the exact body count from the Iraq sanctions.
However, that’s almost beside the point when speaking of Albright. After all,
she said in a 60 Minutes Interview “we think the price is worth
it”
when faced with the number 500,000. Hopefully the number of dead is
a great deal smaller than that – death counts are hard to pin down in almost
every circumstance – but the takeaway is that even half a million would be acceptable
to the great breaker of glass ceilings, Ms. Albright.

But let us not be unkind, or too youthful about this. The LA
Times
recently published an editorial scolding students at Scripps College
for not
wanting Albright as their commencement speaker. 

Now, the question of whether it’s better to welcome a speaker and then question,
protest, or stage some kind of civil disobedience than to get her disinvited
is one thing. But the ease with which the Times dismisses these kids’
objection to Albright is telling. She might open their minds, she will bring
new ideas. You should sometimes listen to nasty people, and it can be educational
to listen to them speak. But you shouldn’t necessarily sit quietly and accept
their presence when they are going to defend their records. It is not “sensitive”
to be bothered by Albright’s presence on campus.

College students may be a little melodramatic with some of their
protests these days, but it’s heartening to see…

Read more