US Foreign Policy Discussions Need a Colossal Dose of Humility

The title of an article posted yesterday at Foreign Policy
blares that “The
Saudi-Iran War is America’s Fault
”. Hmm, yes, probably so, given the endless
flow
of money and weapons the US has gifted to Saudi Arabia over the decades,
as well as the endless provocations directed at Iran. Washington is looking
for any reason to launch an attack against the Islamic Republic, or have an
ally do the dirty work. The political class would love a war between the two,
because it could then pile in behind the Saudis, handing out the latest in Military/Industrial
Complex war toys to the Saudis to use on Iranian civilians. US intel and strategy
would be provided gratuitously to the Saudis, in the same way they’ve given
aid to the Desert Kingdom in their assault on Yemen’s civilians, but orders
of magnitude greater.

The subtitle of the article, however, is quite a bit less heartening: “And
now it’s Washington’s job to make sure it doesn’t spin out of control”. Is
it, really? Why so? Shortsighted interventionism got us to this point where
we have to point out that yes, it probably is the fault of the United States
for the state of affairs between the Saudis and Iran, but does that mean anything
we do could somehow fix the situation? What incentive does Washington have
to prevent the conflict from spinning out of control? There are surely
plenty of pro-war demagogues who would love to see Iran receive the same
treatment
Yemen is taking right now.

Kim Ghattas, author of the Foreign Policy piece, writes under the impression
that not only is it our responsibility to clean up a situation that we created,
but that it is possible to successfully micromanage dealings between states
and somehow achieve something other than the utter chaos that US foreign policy
has unleashed across the Middle East.  From the article:

“The United States cannot ignore or choose to stay out of
the brewing rivalry between Iran and Saudi Arabia. It is not a purely religious
feud, and it is not someone else’s civil war — it’s a hornet’s nest in which Washington
poked its finger by pursuing a nuclear deal with Iran.”

Well, yes, it is someone else’s civil war. The US government should, and does,
have better things to do than insert itself into every far-off conflict or “rivalry”.
Dipping our fingers into affairs of foreign governments that subsequently go
south does give the impression that we have a responsibility to fix it, which
is a good reason to not intervene in the first place. Of Iraq it has been continuously
said that “we own it”, which means that we have a responsibility to “fix it”
somehow.

Read more