Hillary’s Plan To Combat ISIS Won’t Work

In contrast to most Republican candidates, who have given us general platitudes
about “getting tougher on terrorism” or vague promises to use more
ground troops in Iraq or Syria, Hillary Clinton has proposed a more concrete
program for battling ISIS; unfortunately most of it is bad.

The centerpiece of her proposal is to set up a no-fly zone in northern Syria
near the Turkish border, which would allegedly protect Syrian refugees, cut
ISIS supply lines, and give the United States leverage against Russia in any
settlement of Syria’s civil war. President Obama has rejected this idea for
several good reasons, the best being that it would definitely lead to war with
Bashar al Assad’s Syrian government (his air defenses would need to be knocked
down) and, even more dangerously, possibly with the nuclear-armed Russia, which
has aircraft flying over Syrian air space in defense of Assad’s regime. To avoid
the possibility of war with Russia, Mrs. Clinton would need to get the Russians
to cooperate with the no-fly zone, which she is confident of under her expert
presidential leadership but which is unlikely.

Reasons number two and three are that a no-fly zone would deepen U.S. involvement
in the Syrian quagmire and has no legal basis (even overlooking of course that
U.S. bombing of Syrian territory without a proper congressional authorization
is already illegal and unconstitutional). A no-fly zone would involve expensive
constant air patrols and the insertion of U.S. ground forces to protect the zone
— the tip of the iceberg of possible escalation that doesn’t solve the
overall problem. Finally, even if a no-fly zone garnered the United States leverage
to get a good settlement with Russia of the Syrian civil war, it may not be
worth the paper it’s written on. In the international system, great powers are
usually accustomed to coercing lesser entities to do what they want. The brutal
and wild Islamist groups opposing Assad — ISIS, al Qaeda’s affiliate al
Nusra, and some other radical Islamist groups — will probably not pay any
attention to the United States and Russia. They will either need to be smashed
using military power or be made to lose their cache by their heinous violence
becoming obsolete.

Read more