The Question Marks over Erdogan

Turkish President Erdogan’s electoral victory opens new risks and some hopes for the region’s future, depending on whether an empowered Erdogan ratchets up his autocratic approach or chooses to ease up on his military adventurism and repression of the Kurds, as ex-CIA official Graham E. Fuller explains.

By Graham E. Fuller

Predictions among Turkey-watchers about the outcome of Turkey’s Nov. 1 elections were mostly wrong – including my own – as President Recep Tayyip ErdoÄŸan managed to regain majority control of Parliament. Anxiety over potential political and social chaos played a significant role in voters’ decisions not to change leadership, particularly when no other party offered convincing leadership qualities (except possibly the new Kurdish party.)

The country is now left with a leader who over the past few years has distinguished himself by a list of negatives: his single-minded pursuit of executive power far in excess of constitutional provisions, his intimidation and harassment of political rivals, the muzzling of the media and the judiciary, and the tightening of the narrowing circle of often corrupt yes-men around him.

In the eyes of many, the country would have been better served by a coalition government that could have delimited ErdoÄŸan’s often arbitrary, paranoid and erratic use of power. But the voters have spoken and supported him for a fourth time. Turkey now faces the uncertain consequences of continuing and controversial single-party (read ErdoÄŸan) rule.

Turkey faces many burning questions, but I’d like to focus here on the most central one – the overarching Kurdish question and its direct links to the fate of Syria, Iraq, Iran and Turkey itself.

Turkey’s Syrian policy under ErdoÄŸan has done more to damage the country than any other issue.

While it was reasonable during the height of the Arab Spring to expect that Bashar al-Assad, too, might soon join the other fallen dictators, he proved remarkably resilient (and increasingly brutal) in crushing all opposition. We need to remember that Assad had been a virtual protege of ErdoÄŸan for over a decade, but when Assad rejected outright…

Read more