Buying into the narrative that Iran is a rogue nuclear state could harm the
thawing of relations between the country and the US
I’m glad that the United States and Iran reached an agreement in Vienna after
nearly two years of negotiations and 35 years of enmity. A failure to do so
under present political conditions would certainly have left a festering conflict
with unpredictably bad consequences. And the successful negotiation of such
a far-reaching agreement in which both sides made significant concessions should
help to moderate the extreme hostility that has been building up in the United
States over the years.
But my enthusiasm for the agreement is tempered by the fact that the US political
process surrounding the Congressional consideration of the agreement is going
to have the opposite effect. And a big part of the problem is that the Obama
administration is not going to do anything to refute the extremist view of Iran
as determined to get nuclear weapons. Instead the administration is integrating
the idea of Iran as rogue nuclear state into its messaging on the agreement.
Secretary of State John Kerry’s testimony before the Senate Foreign Relations
Committee on Thursday makes the administration’s political strategy very clear.
In two sentences, Kerry managed to combine the images of Iranian-supported terrorism
and sectarian violence across the entire region and Iranian determination to
get nuclear weapons. He told the Committee about the administrations plans
to “push back against Iran’s other activities — against terrorism support, its
contribution to sectarian violence in the Middle East,” which he called “unacceptable”.
Then he added: “But pushing back against an Iran with nuclear weapons is very
different from pushing back against Iran without one.”