{"id":2544,"date":"2008-02-27T13:34:43","date_gmt":"2008-02-27T13:34:43","guid":{"rendered":"http:\/\/rinf.com\/alt-news\/911-truth\/bbc-911-conspiracy-files-appeal-hearing-results\/2544\/"},"modified":"2008-02-27T13:34:43","modified_gmt":"2008-02-27T13:34:43","slug":"bbc-911-conspiracy-files-appeal-hearing-results","status":"publish","type":"post","link":"http:\/\/rinf.com\/alt-news\/911-truth\/bbc-911-conspiracy-files-appeal-hearing-results\/","title":{"rendered":"BBC 9\/11 Conspiracy Files Appeal Hearing Results"},"content":{"rendered":"<p><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">No surprise that the complaint was not upheld, The finding is a joke as you would imagine. For example, the BBC&#8217;s idea of &#8216;investigation&#8217; regarding Mayor Willie Brown not flying on 911 is to phone his office and ask if the reports of a tip off were true!<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The entire results below:<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\"><strong>FINDING BY THE EDITORIAL STANDARDS COMMITTEE<\/strong><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\"><strong>9\/11: The Conspiracy Files, BBC Two, 18 February 2007<\/strong><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\"><strong>Summary of finding<\/strong><\/p>\n<p><\/font><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The Committee, in its consideration, noted that four complainants had complained<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">about this programme. Three complaints appeals are addressed in this finding.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The Committee noted all of the concerns raised by the appellants and from their<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">complaints grouped the issues raised under five broad headings:<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">&#8211; Did the programme consider the most significant 9\/11 conspiracy theories?<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">&#8211; Did the programme ensure appropriate representation from both sides of<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">the argument?<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">&#8211; Was there appropriate representation from both sides of the argument?<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">&#8211; Were the arguments articulated clearly?<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">&#8211; Was it appropriate to include Frank Spotnitz to talk about conspiracy theories?<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">&#8211; Did the programme present the 9\/11 theorists in a negative way?<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The appeals were considered against the editorial guidelines concerning accuracy and impartiality.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The Committee concluded:<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">&#8211; Did the programme ensure appropriate representation from both sides of the argument?<\/p>\n<p><\/font><font face=\"Symbol\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">\u00b7 <font face=\"Arial\">it was not a requirement for all theories to be considered in the programme;<\/font><\/p>\n<p><\/font><font face=\"Symbol\">\u00b7 <\/font><font face=\"Arial\">the programme\u2019s purpose was not to solve what had happened on 11<\/font><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">September 2001or to deliver an in depth analysis of each theory or<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">verdict on the veracity of each theory;<\/p>\n<p><\/font><font face=\"Symbol\">\u00b7 <\/font><font face=\"Arial\">the choice of theories reflected the mainstream of theories which the<\/font><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">majority of the audience would have had some awareness of and, as<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">such, was editorially justified; and<\/p>\n<p><\/font><font face=\"Symbol\">\u00b7 <\/font><font face=\"Arial\">it was not a requirement for the programme to consider the \u201chistory<\/font><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">of deceit\u201d to satisfy the guideline to \u201cweigh all relevant facts\u201d<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">&#8211; Was there appropriate representation from both sides of the argument?<\/p>\n<p><\/font><font face=\"Symbol\">\u00b7 <\/font><font face=\"Arial\">the programme had satisfied the requirement of being duly impartial<\/font><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">by providing sufficient information on each theory mentioned to<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">enable the viewer to have had enough understanding of the different<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">arguments to have formed an opinion as to the accuracy of the<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">various statements made;<\/p>\n<p><\/font><font face=\"Symbol\">\u00b7 <\/font><font face=\"Arial\">it was not required to represent every argument or every facet of<\/font><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">every argument to achieve due impartiality;<\/p>\n<p><\/font><font face=\"Symbol\">\u00b7 <\/font><font face=\"Arial\">the programme had provided appropriate and relevant<\/font><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">representatives from both sides of the argument to articulate the<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">various views;<\/p>\n<p><\/font><font face=\"Symbol\">\u00b7 <\/font><font face=\"Arial\">the programme team had ensured that the contributors speaking for<\/font><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">the \u2018truth movement\u2019 had the appropriate credentials to provide an<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">authoritative view of the various arguments; and<\/p>\n<p><\/font><font face=\"Symbol\">\u00b7 <\/font><font face=\"Arial\">the description of Dylan Avery as \u201c23 year old self-confessed drop<\/font><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">out\u201d was used fairly as that was a description he used to describe<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">himself;<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">&#8211; Were the arguments articulated clearly?<\/p>\n<p><\/font><font face=\"Symbol\">\u00b7 <\/font><font face=\"Arial\">that in the presentation of the various theories, including the graphic<\/font><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">representations, the production team had accurately put forward the<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">broad details of each of the theories in way that did not mislead the<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">audience;<\/p>\n<p><\/font><font face=\"Symbol\">\u00b7 <\/font><font face=\"Arial\">the facts, as much as they could be established, had been thoroughly<\/font><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">checked;<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">&#8211; Was it appropriate to include Frank Spotnitz to talk about conspiracy<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">theories?<\/p>\n<p><\/font><font face=\"Symbol\">\u00b7 <\/font><font face=\"Arial\">there was a good editorial reason for a programme looking at the<\/font><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">phenomenon of conspiracy theories to talk to someone who was<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">publicly known and associated with conspiracy theories;<\/p>\n<p><\/font><font face=\"Symbol\">\u00b7 <\/font><font face=\"Arial\">looking at the programme as a whole the views of Mr Spotnitz were<\/font><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">balanced as there was sufficient concerns raised by those in the truth<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">movement to offset those of Mr Spotnitz;<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">&#8211; Did the programme present the 9\/11 theorists in a negative way?<\/p>\n<p><\/font><font face=\"Symbol\">\u00b7 <\/font><font face=\"Arial\">there was no evidence to suggest that the programme had presented<\/font><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">the theorists in a negative way either in the way the individual<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">contributors were referred to or presented.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The complaints were not upheld.<\/p>\n<p><\/font><strong><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">9\/11: The Conspiracy Files, BBC Two, 18 February 2007<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Finding in full<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">1. The item<\/p>\n<p><\/font><\/strong><em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">(taken from the press release)<\/p>\n<p><\/font><\/em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The Conspiracy Files was a series of four programmes exploring the conspiracy<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">theories that have entered the mainstream surrounding some of the biggest Western<\/p>\n<p>news stories of recent years. <\/font><em><font face=\"Arial\">9\/11: The Conspiracy Files <\/font><\/em><font face=\"Arial\">investigated the growing<\/font><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">number of conspiracy theories surrounding the events of 11 September 2001. The<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">programme travelled across the United States, speaking to eyewitnesses and<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">attempting to separate fact from fiction.<\/p>\n<p><\/font><strong><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">2. The complaint<\/p>\n<p><\/font><\/strong><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Three complainants made a similar complaint concerning 9\/11: The Conspiracy Files,<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">details of which are below (section 2.1). The individual complainants also made<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">complaints in addition to these which are captured in section 2.2.<\/p>\n<p><\/font><strong><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">2.1 The complainants made the following points to the BBC:<\/p>\n<p><\/font><\/strong><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The 9\/11 truth movement<\/p>\n<p><\/font><font face=\"Symbol\">\u00b7 <\/font><font face=\"Arial\">The programme showed a clear and deliberate negative bias against those who<\/font><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">describe themselves as the 9\/11 truth movement.<\/p>\n<p><\/font><font face=\"Symbol\">\u00b7 <\/font><font face=\"Arial\">There was a deliberate intent to misrepresent the discoveries of the 9\/11 truth<\/font><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">movement. These show beyond doubt that the official US government version of<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">events of that day was fraudulent. The producers of the programme had no<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">intention of supporting a version of events of that day which conflicted with the<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">official US report.<\/p>\n<p><\/font><font face=\"Symbol\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">\u00b7 <font face=\"Arial\">There were 13 debunkers interviewed and only 3 9\/11 truthers.<\/font><\/p>\n<p><\/font><font face=\"Symbol\">\u00b7 <\/font><font face=\"Arial\">There were many negative inferences about the truth movement such as \u201c<\/font><em><font face=\"Arial\">there<\/font><\/em><em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">are more than fifty conspiracy theories about 9\/11<font face=\"Arial\">.\u201d<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The collapse of the twin towers<\/p>\n<p><\/font><\/p>\n<p><\/font><\/em><font face=\"Symbol\">\u00b7 <\/font><font face=\"Arial\">The explanation in the programme of the collapse of the twin towers (the<\/font><font face=\"Arial\">pancake theory) put forward by Davin Coburn of <\/font><em><font face=\"Arial\">Popular Mechanics <\/font><\/em><font face=\"Arial\">has been<\/font><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">proven by scientists in the truth movement to be unscientific and in violation of<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">the laws of physics. If the towers had collapsed in pancake form, large floor<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">areas would have remained intact with pieces of concrete of varying sizes. There<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">was no mention in the programme that all three buildings fell at freefall velocity<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">and that no steel framed building had ever collapsed due to fires prior to or since<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">9\/11.<\/p>\n<p><\/font><font face=\"Symbol\">\u00b7 <\/font><font face=\"Arial\">If the towers had collapsed in pancake form then by the programme\u2019s own<\/font><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">graphic demonstration they would have taken more than 50 seconds to fall.<\/p>\n<p><\/font><font face=\"Symbol\">\u00b7 <\/font><font face=\"Arial\">In addition the temperature of the burning jet fuel was nowhere near the<\/font><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">temperature needed to melt the central support columns of the twin towers.<\/p>\n<p><\/font><font face=\"Symbol\">\u00b7 <\/font><font face=\"Arial\">The graphic illustrating the collapse of the WTC was misleading<\/font><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The Pentagon attack<\/p>\n<p><\/font><font face=\"Symbol\">\u00b7 <\/font><font face=\"Arial\">The programme\u2019s computer animation of a Boeing 757 entering the Pentagon is<\/font><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">too simplistic to be accepted. A 757 cannot fly at ground level. It would also have<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">been physically impossible for any large aircraft to have hit the Pentagon without<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">leaving devastation in its wake. Instead there was a neat, near-perfect hole and<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">no traces of the large fuselage, the wings, engines or seats, luggage and passenger<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">remains. The programme did not explain these issues.<\/p>\n<p><\/font><font face=\"Symbol\">\u00b7 <\/font><font face=\"Arial\">The interview with Col. Steve O\u2019Brien, pilot of the military plane flying over<\/font><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Washington cannot be relied on. The programme did not mention or question<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">him about the Pentagon\u2019s missile defences which failed to be deployed that day.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Flight 93<\/p>\n<p><\/font><font face=\"Symbol\">\u00b7 <\/font><font face=\"Arial\">The programme did not explain the lack of debris at the crash site of Flight 93.<\/font><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The evidence of eye-witnesses lacked credibility. If the Boeing 757 had crashed at<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">that location there would have been substantial debris.<\/p>\n<p><\/font><font face=\"Symbol\">\u00b7 <\/font><font face=\"Arial\">The evidence of the coroner Wally Miller was unreliable because he changed his<\/font><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">original story.<\/p>\n<p><\/font><font face=\"Symbol\">\u00b7 <\/font><font face=\"Arial\">The programme claimed that debris was not found 8 miles away when local<\/font><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">officials and the FBI clearly stated that it was.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Programme interviews<\/p>\n<p><\/font><font face=\"Symbol\">\u00b7 <\/font><font face=\"Arial\">Many key interviews were not included in the programme. Professor David Ray<\/font><font face=\"Arial\">Griffin (author of <\/font><em><font face=\"Arial\">The New Pearl Harbor<\/font><\/em><font face=\"Arial\">) is widely respected by 9\/11 truth<\/font><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">researchers as a leading analyst of the events of that day. Neither he nor<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Professor Steven Jones was included in the programme.<\/p>\n<p><\/font><font face=\"Symbol\">\u00b7 <\/font><font face=\"Arial\">Other interviews were not included. There are senior military and intelligence<\/font><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">personnel, government officials, survivors and families of the victims who dispute<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">the official version of events. Witnesses who heard bombs exploding within the<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">buildings before and after they were hit by the aircraft weren\u2019t mentioned.<\/p>\n<p><\/font><font face=\"Symbol\">\u00b7 <\/font><font face=\"Arial\">The use of X-Files writer Frank Spotnitz to debunk the 9\/11 conspiracy claims<\/font><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">was an attempt to discredit the truth movement in the eyes of the audience.<\/p>\n<p><\/font><font face=\"Symbol\">\u00b7 <\/font><font face=\"Arial\">Many pieces of information were left out of the documentary. Several high<\/font><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">ranking people were warned not to go to work or to fly that day but this was<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">never mentioned.<\/p>\n<p><\/font><strong><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">2.2 Individual complaints from the three complainants:<\/p>\n<p><\/font><\/strong><font face=\"Symbol\">\u00b7 <\/font><font face=\"Arial\">The programme used \u2018classic tools of dark images\u2019 to suggest certain individuals<\/font><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">were dubious or sinister.<\/p>\n<p><\/font><font face=\"Symbol\">\u00b7 <\/font><font face=\"Arial\">The sequences introducing Dylan Avery and Professor Jim Fetzer were<\/font><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">unnecessary and used up valuable footage time. They were shot without<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">additional lighting to create a negative impression. The close-up technique used<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">to film Professor Fetzer was disrespectful.<\/p>\n<p><\/font><font face=\"Symbol\">\u00b7 <\/font><font face=\"Arial\">The <\/font><em><font face=\"Arial\">Loose Change <\/font><\/em><font face=\"Arial\">director Dylan Avery was described as a self-confessed \u2018dropout\u2019<\/font><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">even though he never attended college.<\/p>\n<p><\/font><font face=\"Symbol\">\u00b7 <\/font><font face=\"Arial\">The claim that the CIA and the FBI did not have forewarning of the events is not<\/font><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">true. The secret services of many governments had warned the US<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">administration of possible attacks.<\/p>\n<p><\/font><font face=\"Symbol\">\u00b7 <\/font><font face=\"Arial\">No mention was made in the programme of the US government\u2019s history of<\/font><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">deceit or operation Northwoods.<\/p>\n<p><\/font><font face=\"Symbol\">\u00b7 <\/font><font face=\"Arial\">The BBC is on record through a live interview with a BBC correspondent in<\/font><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">New York as having had prior warning of the collapse of Building 7. This is<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">further evidence that the building did not collapse as a result of structural failure.<\/p>\n<p><\/font><font face=\"Symbol\">\u00b7 <\/font><font face=\"Arial\">When Building 7 fell to the ground the programme stated there were no<\/font><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">casualties. However a secret service agent Craig Miller died as a result of that<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">collapse.<\/p>\n<p><\/font><font face=\"Symbol\">\u00b7 <\/font><font face=\"Arial\">Why wasn\u2019t the footage of World Trade Centre owner Larry Silverstein shown<\/font><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">admitting that the authorities decided to \u2018pull\u2019 Building 7?<\/p>\n<p><\/font><font face=\"Symbol\">\u00b7 <\/font><font face=\"Arial\">No mention was made that two aircraft landed at Cleveland Hopkins Airport<\/font><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">due to two separate bomb threats, and that Flight 93 was one of those reported<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">to have landed by locals.<\/p>\n<p><\/font><font face=\"Symbol\">\u00b7 <\/font><font face=\"Arial\">The use of the claim that 4000 Jews stayed away from work on 9\/11 suggests<\/font><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">that those undertaking independent investigations of 9\/11 are somehow anti-<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Semitic.<\/p>\n<p><\/font><font face=\"Symbol\">\u00b7 <\/font><font face=\"Arial\">The programme attempted to influence viewers by ending with the phrase: <\/font><em><font face=\"Arial\">\u201cThe<\/font><\/em><em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">evidence points to a conspiracy after 9\/11, not before. The other 9\/11 conspiracy<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">theories are just that, theories. The evidence doesn\u2019t support them. Case closed.\u201d<\/p>\n<p><\/font><\/em><font face=\"Symbol\">\u00b7 <\/font><font face=\"Arial\">No alternative theories as to the collapse of the twin towers to the official<\/font><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">accounts were given, save for the view of Dylan Avery<\/p>\n<p><\/font><font face=\"Symbol\">\u00b7 <\/font><font face=\"Arial\">The programme omitted to include and investigate an \u201cFBI report\u201d on wreckage<\/font><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">found 8 miles away in New Baltimore<\/p>\n<p><\/font><font face=\"Symbol\">\u00b7 <\/font><font face=\"Arial\">The programme omitted to include interviews with police officers on duty at the<\/font><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">world trade centre, eye witness accounts, a conspiracy theory concerning the<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Mayor of San Francisco and any interview with the head of the largest 9\/11<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">victims group for the film.<\/p>\n<p><\/font><font face=\"Symbol\">\u00b7 <\/font><font face=\"Arial\">There was an imbalance in the interviews as there were less people for the 9\/11<\/font><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">movement than \u201cdebunkers\u201d.<\/p>\n<p><\/font><strong><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">3. Response from the BBC<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">3.1 Response from BBC Information<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The complainants were directed to two blogs written by Mike Rudin,<\/p>\n<p>series producer <\/font><em><font face=\"Arial\">The Conspiracy Files <\/font><\/em><font face=\"Arial\">and Richard Porter, Head of News,<\/font><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">BBC World. The following points were also made:<\/p>\n<p><\/font><\/strong><font face=\"Arial\">There was no editorial interference in the programme. <\/font><em><font face=\"Arial\">9\/11: The Conspiracy Files <\/font><\/em><font face=\"Arial\">was<\/font><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">determined to examine the many conspiracy theories in detail and subject them to<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">forensic examination.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The programme chose three prominent and influential people to make the case that<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">the official account of 9\/11 is wrong and to propose an alternative. The programmemakers<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">did ask Professor Steven Jones for an interview but he declined.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The programme found much evidence which supported the official version of events<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">and which contradicted the various conspiracy theories.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Where there was some evidence of a conspiracy after the event to cover up<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">intelligence failures, this was included in the programme.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The programme was 59 minutes long and therefore could not deal with every issue<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">and every possible argument. The programme-makers chose the strongest and most<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">widely reported arguments for inclusion. They also spoke to and considered many<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">witnesses and experts but in the end made an editorial judgement as to who to<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">include in the programme.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Frank Spotnitz was included to help viewers understand why so many people believe<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">in conspiracy theories generally.<\/p>\n<p><\/font><strong><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">3.2 Response from the ECU<\/p>\n<p><\/font><\/strong><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The 9\/11 truth movement<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The programme was in production for nine months and the producers carried out<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">extensive research in that time. The final programme contained a number of<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">interviews with leading members of the 9\/11 truth movement and gave them the<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">opportunity to explain their theories of what happened on the day.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The programme also included interviews with people challenging these theories to<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">provide the necessary balance on such a controversial subject.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The programme-makers made a conscious decision to concentrate on the opinions<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">of three people who are well regarded in the truth movement and spend time<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">establishing why their views were worthy of consideration. This was considered<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">preferable to covering a greater variety of views in a more cursory manner.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">It is true that more people were interviewed to support the official explanation of<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">events \u2014 but this in itself did not lead to an imbalance. Throughout the programme a<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">great deal of time was spent explaining the theories of the three men, often using<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">material which they had provided. Their contribution amounted to more than eight<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">minutes of the programme. This compares to just over ten minutes devoted to<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">those putting opposing views.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">\u201cIn many cases where there was an exchange of views, the programme-makers gave<\/p>\n<p>the last word to the 9\/11 theorists. <\/font><em><font face=\"Arial\">9\/11: The Conspiracy Files <\/font><\/em><font face=\"Arial\">offered a balanced<\/font><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">analysis of the main theories and I do not believe there is evidence of bias against the<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">9\/11 truth movement.\u201d<\/p>\n<p>The programme\u2019s comment that there are \u201c<\/font><em><font face=\"Arial\">more than fifty different conspiracy theories<\/font><\/em><em><font face=\"Arial\">about 911\/<\/font><\/em><font face=\"Arial\">\u201d is a simple statement of fact providing useful context for the viewer<\/font><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">rather than a negative inference about the truth movement.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The collapse of the twin towers<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">There are a number of explanations as to why the twin towers collapsed and some<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">of these were examined by the programme. Dylan Avery put forward his theory that<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">the buildings were brought down by a series of controlled explosions. This was<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">balanced by the official Federal Emergency Management Association (FEMA) report<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">that said that a combination of the impact of the planes and the ensuing fires<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">weakened the load-bearing beams. The programme-makers had to decide which<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">aspects of the collapse to investigate in the time available, and so included the two<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">most widely discussed explanations.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Davin Coburn has carried out his own research into the collapse and his explanation<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">is shared by many, including FEMA. The purpose of the graphic used to illustrate the<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">official explanation was to show a complicated process in a way that is simple to<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">understand. The programme-makers say that their intention in using the graphic was<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">to clarify one theory rather than to prove its validity.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The graphic was run in slow motion and was not designed to show the actual speed<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">at which the collapse occurred. If the graphic had been shown in \u2018real time\u2019 it would<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">have been too quick to understand. Therefore this was not misleading or inaccurate.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">It is true to say that no other steel framed buildings have collapsed due to fire but it<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">is equally true that no other buildings have been hit at speed by a large passenger jet<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">laden with fuel. It is hard to see how an analysis of other skyscraper fires would<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">have proved what caused the twin towers to collapse.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The Pentagon attack<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Professor Hoffman\u2019s computer animation was shown to help illustrate his<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">explanation for why the hole in the Pentagon wall was so small. The programme did<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">not endorse this view and made it clear it had been challenged by many experts.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Professor Jim Fetzer and Dylan Avery spoke at length to cast doubt on the official<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">version. The programme examined the evidence on both sides but did not draw any<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">conclusions.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The interview with Col. Steve O\u2019Brien who explained that he saw an unidentified jet<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">turn and crash into the Pentagon was balanced with an interview with Professor Jim<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Fetzer who highlighted a number of inconsistencies. The programme therefore<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">offered both sides of the argument and left the viewer to draw his own conclusion.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Flight 93<\/p>\n<p><\/font><em><font face=\"Arial\">9\/11: The Conspiracy Files <\/font><\/em><font face=\"Arial\">included a number of possible explanations for the fate of<\/font><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Flight 93. It accurately reflected the concerns of many people that the lack of any<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">substantial aircraft wreckage casts doubt on the official explanation. The coverage<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">included both sides of the argument.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">They spoke to people directly involved in the investigation to check known facts.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The programme-makers spoke directly to the FBI in Pennsylvania to check what<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">claims had been made by the Bureau. The FBI confirmed that the only debris from<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">the plane found within an eight mile radius was light material such as paper and foam.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The programme gave the last word on this issue to Professor Jim Fetzer and Dylan<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Avery, so the viewer was given plenty of opportunity to consider the sceptical view.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The coroner Wally Miller has gone on record to say that he was misquoted when it<\/p>\n<p>was reported that he said he \u201c<\/font><em><font face=\"Arial\">stopped being coroner after about 20 minutes because<\/font><\/em><em><font face=\"Arial\">there were no bodies there.<\/font><\/em><font face=\"Arial\">\u201d He explained this in the programme. However the<\/font><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">programme also included an interview with Dylan Avery in which he questioned Mr<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Miller\u2019s reliability.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Programme Interviews<\/p>\n<p>The programme-makers read Professor Griffin\u2019s book <\/font><em><font face=\"Arial\">The New Pearl Harbor <\/font><\/em><font face=\"Arial\">and<\/font><font face=\"Arial\">took his views into account when making <\/font><em><font face=\"Arial\">9\/11: The Conspiracy Files <\/font><\/em><font face=\"Arial\">but decided to<\/font><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">concentrate on three other prominent members of the 9\/11 truth movement.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Professor Stephen Jones was approached to take part in the programme but was<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">unavailable.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The programme-makers interviewed many witnesses and experts and sought out<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">viewpoints on the most widely-held theories. They then made an editorial judgment<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">to include what they believed were the strongest and most relevant views.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Eyewitness accounts provide interesting background information but cannot be<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">regarded as providing conclusive evidence. The programme did however address<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">the issue of secondary explosions and gave Dylan Avery an opportunity to explain<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">his theory.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The interview with Frank Spotnitz was included to help the viewer understand why<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">so many people believe in conspiracy theories. In the same section of the<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">programme Alex Jones explained why many people are increasingly willing to<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">challenge the official version of events.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The programme-makers say that they could find no convincing evidence that some<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">senior people had been warned not to go to work at the World Trade Centre that<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">day. They also spoke directly to the office of Mayor Willie Brown of San Francisco<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">who told the programme that he made no changes to his itinerary on the morning of<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">9\/11.<\/p>\n<p><\/font><strong><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">3.3 ECU response to individual complaints from the three<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">complainants<\/p>\n<p><\/font><\/strong><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">There is no evidence to suggest that film-making techniques were used with an<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">\u2018oppressive sinister intent.\u2019 The mood was sombre but consistent throughout the<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">programme.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">A variety of lighting techniques and framing were used throughout the programme<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">and many of the interviewees who oppose the views of the truth movement were<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">also filmed in similar ways.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The programme sought to establish the background of the three members of the<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">truth movement. Far from being a ploy to waste time, this was a way to reinforce<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">their credibility.<\/p>\n<p>The word <\/font><em><font face=\"Arial\">drop-out <\/font><\/em><font face=\"Arial\">is also defined as \u2018a person who rejects conventional society.\u2019 I<\/font><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">think it reasonable to suggest that Dylan Avery has rejected conventional society.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">He walked away from a secure job and moved to Washington DC to pursue his<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">ambition to make films. There are also a number of positive descriptions to establish<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Mr Avery\u2019s credibility and explain to viewers why his views are worthy of inclusion.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">He was described as \u201c<em><font face=\"Arial\">the most prominent voice in the self-styled 9\/11 truth movement\u201d<\/font><\/em><\/p>\n<p><\/font><font face=\"Arial\">and later <\/font><em><font face=\"Arial\">\u201cthe wunderkind\u201d <\/font><\/em><font face=\"Arial\">behind the <\/font><em><font face=\"Arial\">Loose Change <\/font><\/em><font face=\"Arial\">film.<\/font><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The programme did not claim that the CIA and the FBI did not have forewarning of<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">the attacks. The script states:<\/p>\n<p><\/font><em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">\u201cThe FBI and CIA insist they had no specific warnings of the hijackings on 9\/11. But it now<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">seems they were less than full and frank about how much information they did have before<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Al Qaeda attacked.\u201d<\/p>\n<p><\/font><\/em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The programme went on to examine the failure of the intelligence services.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">All three of the main interviewees made a number of claims in the programme<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">accusing the US government of being involved in the events of 9\/11. The<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">programme-makers were entirely justified in letting the leading voices of the truth<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">movement put forward their case without referring to previous unrelated events.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">BBC World\u2019s Head of News, Richard Porter, has explained at length the sequence of<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">events which led to the BBC report about the collapse of Building 7. His blog had<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">already been sent to the complainants.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">On the issue of casualties in Building 7, the programme-makers were quoting from<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">the official FEMA report into WTC 7. This was an independent investigation and noone<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">seems to have yet provided proof that on this particular point it is wrong.<\/p>\n<p><\/font><em><font face=\"Arial\">9\/11: The Conspiracy Files <\/font><\/em><font face=\"Arial\">decided not to include Larry Silverstein\u2019s comments<\/font><font face=\"Arial\">(\u201c<\/font><em><font face=\"Arial\">We\u2019ve had such terrible loss of life, maybe the smartest thing to do is pull it\u201d<\/font><\/em><font face=\"Arial\">) because he<\/font><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">has since issued a statement saying that what he was referring to was the need to<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">pull the fire-fighting contingent out of the building, not pull the building down itself.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The theory that Flight 93 and another aircraft were diverted to Ohio because of<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">bomb threats was well documented in the programme.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The claim that thousands of Jewish people stayed at home that day was examined in<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">the programme, but the script treated the allegations in the same dispassionate way<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">as other claims. The origin of this particular story was explained in the programme.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">There was no suggestion that any of the conspiracy theorists in the programme<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">supported this claim. I do not believe that any average member of the audience<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">would conclude that the programme implied that anyone questioning the official<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">version of events on 9\/11 was anti-Semitic.<\/p>\n<p>It is clear that the sentence \u201c<\/font><em><font face=\"Arial\">Case closed<\/font><\/em><font face=\"Arial\">?\u201d is delivered as a question. The last<\/font><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">comment from the narrator goes even further to make it clear that the final<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">conclusion of the programme is that the truth of what happened on 9\/11 will remain<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">a subject of great controversy:<\/p>\n<p><\/font><em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">\u201cThe 9\/11 conspiracy file is certain to remain open for a very long time to come\u2026.however<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">distressing and painful that will be for the families of those who died that day.\u201d<\/p>\n<p><\/font><\/em><strong><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">4. Further points made to the ESC<\/p>\n<p><\/font><\/strong><font face=\"Symbol\">\u00b7 <\/font><font face=\"Arial\">Dylan Avery is not an engineering expert neither are Alex Jones nor Jim Fetzer.<\/font><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Yet you give time for, and go into graphic and scientific detail of, the official<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">account of the twin towers collapse.<\/p>\n<p><\/font><font face=\"Symbol\">\u00b7 <\/font><font face=\"Arial\">For the truth movement, Flight 93 is the least clear evidence of a government<\/font><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">cover-up.<\/p>\n<p><\/font><font face=\"Symbol\">\u00b7 <\/font><font face=\"Arial\">Regardless of how it got there, it is officially acknowledged that debris from<\/font><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Flight 93 was found 8 miles away \u2014 in New Baltimore, not Indian Lake. The<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">documentary misleads the viewer and misrepresents the 9\/11 truth movement<\/p>\n<p>by stating that \u201c<\/font><em><font face=\"Arial\">it\u2019s claimed Indian Lake is nearly 7 miles from the crash site\u201d <\/font><\/em><font face=\"Arial\">then<\/font><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">stating it\u2019s only 1 mile away as the crow flies. The truth movement though isn\u2019t<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">referring to Indian lake but to New Baltimore.<\/p>\n<p><\/font><strong><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">5. Applicable Programme Standards<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Section 1 &#8211; BBC Editorial Values<\/p>\n<p><\/font><\/strong><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Truth and Accuracy<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">We strive to be accurate and establish the truth of what has happened. Accuracy is<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">more important than speed and it is often more than a question of getting the facts<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">right. We will weigh all relevant facts and information to get at the truth. Our output<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">will be well sourced, based on sound evidence, thoroughly tested and presented in<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">clear, precise language. We will be honest and open about what we don&#8217;t know and<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">avoid unfounded speculation.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Impartiality and Diversity of Opinion<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">We strive to be fair and open minded and reflect all significant strands of opinion by<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">exploring the range and conflict of views. We will be objective and even handed in<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">our approach to a subject. We will provide professional judgments where<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">appropriate, but we will never promote a particular view on controversial matters of<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">public policy or political or industrial controversy.<\/p>\n<p><\/font><strong><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Section 3 &#8211; Accuracy<\/p>\n<p><\/font><\/strong><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Introduction<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The BBC&#8217;s commitment to accuracy is a core editorial value and fundamental to our<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">reputation. Our output must be well sourced, based on sound evidence, thoroughly<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">tested and presented in clear, precise language. We should be honest and open<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">about what we don&#8217;t know and avoid unfounded speculation.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">For the BBC accuracy is more important than speed and it is often more than a<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">question of getting the facts right. All the relevant facts and information should be<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">weighed to get at the truth. If an issue is controversial, relevant opinions as well as<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">facts may need to be considered.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">We aim to achieve accuracy by:<\/p>\n<p><\/font><font size=\"2\" face=\"Symbol\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">\u00b7 <font face=\"Arial\">the accurate gathering of material using first hand sources wherever possible.<\/font><\/p>\n<p><\/font><font size=\"2\" face=\"Symbol\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">\u00b7 <font face=\"Arial\">checking and cross checking the facts.<\/font><\/p>\n<p><\/font><font size=\"2\" face=\"Symbol\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">\u00b7 <font face=\"Arial\">validating the authenticity of documentary evidence and digital material.<\/font><\/p>\n<p><\/font><font size=\"2\" face=\"Symbol\">\u00b7 <\/font><font face=\"Arial\">corroborating claims and allegations made by contributors wherever possible.<\/font><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Fact checking<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">We must check and verify information, facts and documents, particularly those<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">researched on the internet. This may include confirming with an individual or<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">organisation that they posted material and that it is accurate. Even the most<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">convincing material on the web may not be what it seems.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Misleading audiences<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">We should not distort known facts, present invented material as fact, or knowingly<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">do anything to mislead our audiences. We may need to label material to avoid doing<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">so.<\/p>\n<p><\/font><strong><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Section 4 &#8211; Impartiality and Diversity of Opinion<\/p>\n<p><\/font><\/strong><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Introduction<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Impartiality lies at the heart of the BBC&#8217;s commitment to its audiences. It applies<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">across all of our services and output, whatever the format, from radio news bulletins<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">via our web sites to our commercial magazines and includes a commitment to<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">reflecting a diversity of opinion.<\/p>\n<p>The Agreement accompanying the BBC&#8217;s Charter<\/font><font size=\"1\" face=\"Arial\">1 <\/font><font face=\"Arial\">&#8230;specifies that we should do all<\/font><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">we can to treat controversial subjects with due accuracy and impartiality in our news<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">services and other programmes dealing with matters of public policy or of political<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">or industrial controversy. It also states that the BBC is forbidden from expressing an<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">opinion on current affairs or matters of public policy other than broadcasting.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">In practice, our commitment to impartiality means:&#8230;<\/p>\n<p><\/font><font size=\"2\" face=\"Symbol\">\u00b7 <\/font><font face=\"Arial\">we exercise our editorial freedom to produce content about any subject, at<\/font><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">any point on the spectrum of debate as long as there are good editorial<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">reasons for doing so.<\/p>\n<p><\/font><font size=\"2\" face=\"Symbol\">\u00b7 <\/font><font face=\"Arial\">we can explore or report on a specific aspect of an issue or provide an<\/font><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">opportunity for a single view to be expressed, but in doing so we do not<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">misrepresent opposing views. They may also require a right of reply&#8230;<\/p>\n<p><\/font><font size=\"2\" face=\"Symbol\">\u00b7 <\/font><font face=\"Arial\">the approach to, and tone of, BBC stories must always reflect our editorial<\/font><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">values. Presenters, reporters and correspondents are the public face and<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">voice of the BBC, they can have a significant impact on the perceptions of our<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">impartiality&#8230;<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Achieving impartiality<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Impartiality must be adequate and appropriate to our output. Our approach to<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">achieving it will therefore vary according to the nature of the subject, the type of<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">output, the likely audience expectation and the extent to which the content and<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">approach is signposted to our audiences.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Impartiality is described in the Agreement as &#8220;due impartiality&#8221;. It requires us to be<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">fair and open minded when examining the evidence and weighing all the material<\/p>\n<p><\/font><font size=\"1\" face=\"Century Gothic\">1 <\/font><font size=\"2\" face=\"Arial\">The words omitted here relate to the 1996 Agreement and Charter and are not relevant to the<\/font><font size=\"2\" face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">2006 Agreement and Charter<\/p>\n<p><\/font><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">facts, as well as being objective and even handed in our approach to a subject. It does<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">not require the representation of every argument or facet of every argument on<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">every occasion or an equal division of time for each view.<\/p>\n<p><\/font><strong><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">6. The Committee\u2019s decision<\/p>\n<p><\/font><\/strong><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The Committee considered the complaint against the relevant editorial standards,<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">including the BBC&#8217;s values and other standards set out in the Editorial Guidelines.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The Committee took into account all the material before it relating to the appeal;<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">this included submissions from all the relevant parties to the complaint who were<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">asked to comment on the material going before the Committee.<\/p>\n<p>The Committee recognised the right to freedom of expression<\/font><font size=\"1\" face=\"Arial\">2 <\/font><font face=\"Arial\">allowed<\/font><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">interviewees to express opinions, content producers to include information and<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">ideas in their output, and audiences to receive them as long as the law, regulation<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">and, in the BBC\u2019s case, the BBC\u2019s Editorial Guidelines were complied with.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The Committee at the outset noted that the programme had not been an<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">investigation which aimed to solve what had happened on 11 September 2001. It<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">recognised that it was one of a series of programmes looking at the phenomenon of<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">the conspiracy theory and in doing so had highlighted a number of specific events<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">where well publicised and popular theories had arisen to contradict the official<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">version of events.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The Committee also noted that it was not within its remit to come to a view as to<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">which, if any of the versions, may or may not have been correct. Its task was to<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">determine whether the programme had been in breach of the BBC\u2019s Editorial<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Guidelines on accuracy and impartiality.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">In considering impartiality the Committee noted that the guidelines required that it<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">must be adequate and appropriate to the output. The Committee took into account<\/p>\n<p><\/font><font size=\"1\" face=\"Arial\">2 <\/font><font face=\"Arial\">Freedom of Expression<\/font><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">1) Everyone has the right to freedom of expression. This right shall include<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">freedom to hold opinions and to receive and impart information and ideas<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">without interference by public authority and regardless of frontiers. This<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Article shall not prevent States from requiring the licensing of broadcasting,<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">television or cinema enterprises.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">2) The exercise of these freedoms, since it carries with it duties and<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">responsibilities, may be subject to such formalities, conditions, restrictions or<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">penalties as are prescribed by law and are necessary in a democratic society,<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">in the interests of national security, territorial integrity or public safety, for<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">the prevention of disorder or crime, for the protection of health or morals,<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">for the protection of the reputation or the rights of others, for preventing<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">the disclosure of information received in confidence, or for maintaining the<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">authority and impartiality of the judiciary.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">that in assessing whether the guidelines were complied with the Committee should<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">consider what impartiality was due to a programme about conspiracy theories taking<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">into account the audience expectation for such a programme and the extent to<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">which the content and approach was signposted to the audience.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The Committee set out five questions it would consider in its finding:<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">A) Were the most significant theories considered?<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">B) Was there appropriate representation from both sides of the argument?<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">C) Were the arguments articulated clearly?<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">D) Was it appropriate to include Frank Spotnitz to talk about conspiracy<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">theories?<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">E) Did the programme present the 9\/11 theorists in a negative way?<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">A) Were the most significant theories considered?<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The Committee was aware that there are a number of conspiracy theories<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">concerning the events leading up to\/on the day of \/on the days after 11 September<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">2001. The Committee noted the six theories the programme concentrated on:<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">i) The attack on the Twin Towers<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">&#8211; Did the planes bring down the Twin Towers or were<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">explosives used by government agencies?<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">ii) World Trade Centre Building 7<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">&#8211; Did WTC7 collapse as a result of the damage and collapse of<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">the Twin Towers or was it deliberately demolished by<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">government agencies?<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">iii) Attack on the Pentagon<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">&#8211; Did a commercial passenger plane crash into the Pentagon or not?<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Was this incident a self-inflicted attack?<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">iv) Flight United 93<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">&#8211; Did Flight United 93 crash as stated officially or was it blown<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">up in mid-air?<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">v) The Jewish community in New York<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">&#8211; Did the Jewish community in New York go to work as planned or<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">had the Jewish community been \u201ctipped-off\u201d by Israeli intelligence<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">to stay away from work?<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">vi) FBI\/CIA Conspiracy<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">&#8211; Did the agencies know of the attacks in advance and ignore<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">them?<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">&#8211; Was there subsequent cover up of failures by the agencies to<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">act on information prior to 9\/11?<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The Committee noted that impartiality:<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">\u201c&#8230; does not require the representation of every argument or facet of every<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">argument on every occasion or an equal division of time for each view\u201d.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The Committee was satisfied that whilst some viewers would not have agreed with<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">the choice of theories included in the programme, the ones that had been included<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">reflected mainstream theories that the majority of the audience would have some<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">awareness of. The Committee was satisfied that the programme had complied with<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">the guideline on impartiality that allowed the programme:<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">\u201c[..] the editorial freedom to produce content about any subject, at any point<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">on the spectrum of debate, as long as there are good editorial reasons for<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">doing so.\u201d<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The Committee recognised that the inclusion of the theory regarding the absence of<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">members of the Jewish community from work on the day of 9\/11 was not one that<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">was supported by the main body of conspiracy theorists. It had originated in the<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Middle East and the programme accurately reflected this. However, the Committee<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">recognised that it was a widely known theory and was established as a theory to<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">those not in the main community of conspiracy theorists. The Committee was<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">therefore satisfied that there was a good editorial reason for considering this theory<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">alongside the other theories included within the programme and no anti-Semitism<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">was implied.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The Committee did not consider it necessary to explore the \u201chistory of deceit\u201d of<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">the US government or Operation Northwood to satisfy the accuracy guideline to<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">\u201cweigh all relevant facts\u2026to get at the truth\u201d. The Committee was satisfied that the<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">theories covered in the programme were sufficient to provide the audience with<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">enough relevant information for them to draw their own conclusions with regard to<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">the activities of the US government in the incidents relating to 9\/11. The purpose of<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">the programme was to consider specific theories related to the incidents on 9\/11<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">and not conspiracy theories relating to other events in US history.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The Committee was therefore satisfied that the programme had presented an<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">appropriate selection of conspiracy theories.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">B) Was there appropriate representation from both sides of the argument?<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The Committee considered how the programme had set about presenting the<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">different theories and rebuttals in looking at the various arguments and theories as<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">to how the event unfolded and who was to blame. In doing so the Committee<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">considered whether the guideline had been met that required the BBC:<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">\u201c&#8230; to be fair and open minded when examining the evidence and weighing all<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">the material facts, as well as being objective and even handed in our approach<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">to a subject. It does not require the representation of every argument or<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">facet of every argument on every occasion or an equal division of time for<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">each view.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The Committee noted how the production team had set out its proposition for the<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">programme:<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Voice over (V\/O):<\/p>\n<p><\/font><em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">We all remember where we were on the day the world changed\u2026<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">\u2026.but do we know what really happened?<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Look closer through the smoke and horror, say conspiracy theories\u2026..<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">\u2026..and you\u2019ll find that not everything was as it first appeared.<\/p>\n<p><\/font><\/em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Alex Jones (AJ):<\/p>\n<p><\/font><em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The bottom line 9\/11 is an inside job. It\u2019s a self inflicted wound, it\u2019s a false<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">flag\u2026terror operation<\/p>\n<p><\/font><\/em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">President Bush:<\/p>\n<p><\/font><em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Let us never tolerate outrageous conspiracy theories concerning the attacks of Sept<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">11<font size=\"1\" face=\"Arial\">th<\/font><\/p>\n<p><\/font><\/em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">V\/O:<\/p>\n<p><\/font><em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Many say the official account doesn\u2019t add up\u2026..<\/p>\n<p><\/font><\/em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Overlay:<\/p>\n<p><\/font><em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Listen, sometimes truth is stranger than fiction.<\/p>\n<p><\/font><\/em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">V\/O:<\/p>\n<p><\/font><em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">\u2026And the questions keep coming<\/p>\n<p><\/font><\/em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Jim Fetzer (JF):<\/p>\n<p><\/font><em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">As Sherlock Holmes was fond of observing, \u201cWhen you have eliminated the<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">impossible whatever remains, however improbable must be the truth.\u201d<\/p>\n<p><\/font><\/em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">V\/O:<\/p>\n<p><\/font><em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">There are more than 50 different conspiracy theories about 9\/11- it\u2019s the first<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">global event in the age of the internet.<\/p>\n<p><\/font><\/em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Dylan Avery (DA):<\/p>\n<p><\/font><em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">We\u2019re just civilians man. We\u2019re people who have questions.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">V\/O:<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">If a large passenger jet crashed into the Pentagon\u2026why was the hole in the exterior<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">wall apparently so small?<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Was wreckage found miles from the crash site of one of the hijacked planes which<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">proved that it was shot down?<\/p>\n<p><\/font><\/em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">DA:<\/p>\n<p><\/font><em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Our government will willingly kill its own citizens for whatever gain it seems<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">necessary and then lie as much as they need to cover it up.<\/p>\n<p><\/font><\/em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">V\/O:<\/p>\n<p><\/font><em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Could a controlled demolition have caused this building to collapse at the World<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Trade Centre?<\/p>\n<p><\/font><\/em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">AJ:<\/p>\n<p><\/font><em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">I don\u2019t believe it was a controlled demolition, I know it was a controlled demolition.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Cheryl Shames (sister of Andrew Zucker) :<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">If these theories were true, then why did my brother go to work that day? Did he<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">want to die? No.<\/p>\n<p><\/font><\/em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">V\/O:<\/p>\n<p><\/font><em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">So why do so many people doubt what the American government tells them about<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">9\/11?<\/p>\n<p><\/font><\/em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">JF:<\/p>\n<p><\/font><em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Well there\u2019s the old saying, just because you\u2019re paranoid, doesn\u2019t mean they aren\u2019t<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">out to get you.<\/p>\n<p><\/font><\/em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The Committee also considered how the programme looked at the various theories<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">included within the programme. The Committee noted other sections of dialogue<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">within the programme. The first section looked at the collapse of the Twin Towers:<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">V\/O:<\/p>\n<p><\/font><em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">In his film Dylan Avery suggests that the Twin Towers were brought down by<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">explosives\u2026<\/p>\n<p><\/font><\/em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Clip from Dylan Avery\u2019s film (Loose Change):<\/p>\n<p><\/font><em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Do you still think that jet fuel brought down the World Trade Centre?<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Watch carefully: The tripod shakes 12 seconds before the North Tower begins<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">collapsing. In all the videos of the collapses, explosions can be seen bursting from<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">the building 20 to 30 stories below the demolition wave:<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Here\u2026 here and here.<\/p>\n<p><\/font><\/em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">V\/O:<\/p>\n<p><\/font><em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The official explanation suggests that when each plane slammed into the tower it<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">damaged the core structure.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Then the ensuing fire weakened the building further.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Although steel needs 1,500 degrees Celsius to melt, at 650 degrees it loses half its<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">strength.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The load bearing beams buckled when they were unable to carry the weight<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">above\u2026..<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">\u2026..and the floors progressively caved in.<\/p>\n<p><\/font><\/em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">V\/O:<\/p>\n<p><\/font><em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">This is three floors of the World Trade Centre &#8211; and everything in them \u2014<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">compressed and fused together into a slab about three feet thick.<\/p>\n<p><\/font><\/em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Davin Coburn (Popular Mechanics):<\/p>\n<p><\/font><em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">When those towers collapsed &#8211; remember those collapses began from the top, they<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">did not begin from the bottom. So when the floors began crashing down upon<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">themselves, the air just simply looked for the path of least resistance and generally<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">that went straight out the windows and a little bit of debris and smoke went with<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">them, and that sort of represents those puffs that some people think were some<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">sort of squibs, or other explosive charge.<\/p>\n<p><\/font><\/em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">DA:<\/p>\n<p><\/font><em><font face=\"Arial\">Their authority is tractors, OK? They should stick to what they know. <\/font><\/em><font face=\"Arial\">Popular<\/font><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Mechanics <em><font face=\"Arial\">is the <\/font><\/em><font face=\"Arial\">last <\/font><em><font face=\"Arial\">company that should be \u201cinvestigating\u201d 9-11.<\/font><\/em><\/p>\n<p><\/font><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The Committee also considered a later section of dialogue where American Airlines<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">flight AA77 crashed into the Pentagon. The programme stated:<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">V\/O:<\/p>\n<p><\/font><em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">As flight AA77 descended in a wide turn over the capital and lined up with its<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">target, there was a military C130 plane -\u2026..<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">\u2026.like this one &#8211; flying above Washington.<\/p>\n<p><\/font><\/em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">JF:<\/p>\n<p><\/font><em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">There\u2019s a lot of suspicion here that that C130 may in fact have been controlling the<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">aircraft that hit the Pentagon.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Commentary Question<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">What you\u2019re saying is that the pilot was the person who caused the crash at the<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Pentagon?<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">JF:<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">I can\u2019t say that for a certainty but there\u2019s a lot of reason to suspect that this circling<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">C130 may have been the control vehicle for the plane that was approaching the<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Pentagon.<\/p>\n<p><\/font><\/em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">V\/O:<\/p>\n<p><\/font><em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">This is that aircraft<font face=\"Arial\">.<\/font><\/p>\n<p><\/font><\/em><em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Steve O\u2019Brien (Lt Minnesota National Guard) (SB):<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Well, here\u2019s a chart of the Washington DC area.<\/p>\n<p><\/font><\/em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">V\/O:<\/p>\n<p><\/font><em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">And this is the pilot.<\/p>\n<p><\/font><\/em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">SB:<\/p>\n<p><\/font><em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">\u2026.and here\u2019s Andrew Air Force base right here<\/p>\n<p><\/font><\/em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">V\/O:<\/p>\n<p><\/font><em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Lieutenant Colonel O\u2019Brien was on a routine flight but as he flew over central<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Washington, Air Traffic Control reported an unidentified jet fast approaching on his<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">left hand side.<\/p>\n<p><\/font><\/em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">NORAD ATC RECORDING:<\/p>\n<p><\/font><em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">&#8211; Latest report, aircraft five, six miles southeast of the White House.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">&#8211; Six miles southeast of the White House?<\/p>\n<p><\/font><\/em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">SB:<\/p>\n<p><\/font><em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">It had that distinctive silver finish. in our minds it was definitely an American airlines<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">aircraft.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Then as he moved to our 11 o\u2019clock position he started his turn. And by the time<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">he got to our 12 o\u2019clock position, right out the front of our aircraft, he was rolled up<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">into about, I would estimate, 30 -40 degrees of bank, which is considerable for<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">commercial airliner.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">And then all of a sudden we saw this big explosion.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">And I keyed the mic again and said Washington, this is Gopher 0-6. That plane has<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">hit the west side of the Pentagon.<\/p>\n<p><\/font><\/em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">V\/O:<\/p>\n<p><\/font><em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Later, when Steve O\u2019Brien was back home in Minnesota he found himself at the<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">centre of a conspiracy theory.<\/p>\n<p><\/font><\/em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">SB:<\/p>\n<p><\/font><em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Not having been part of a major event like this before, you\u2019re somewhat detached.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">But when you\u2019re actually a witness to it and actually became a part of these<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">conspiracies, it\u2019s a lot more personal. And concerning to me that people would<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">think that I would have the ability to, or want to do something like this. So it\u2019s a<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">little bit disconcerting, but at the same time it gives you another insight into how<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">wrong a lot of these conspiracies are, but yet they continue and take on a life of<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">their own so to speak.<\/p>\n<p><\/font><\/em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">JF:<\/p>\n<p><\/font><em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">How do you know a single word of what he said is true? His story is inconsistent<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">with the evidence we have. It\u2019s not even physically possible given the laws of<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">aerodynamics that a Boeing 757 could have taken the trajectory attributed to it,<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">which I presume he confirmed which is that this plane barely skimmed the ground<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">en route to its target. That\u2019s not even physically possible, which is a guarantee that<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">what he was saying was false.<\/p>\n<p><\/font><\/em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The Committee was satisfied that in these example extracts and throughout the<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">programme views from both sides of the argument relating to each theory set out<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">above were put forward in a manner that ensured that the programme had achieved<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">due impartiality. The Committee recognised that for those who felt strongly on<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">either side of the argument the programme\u2019s treatment of each theory may have<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">been less detailed than they would have liked, but it was not the purpose of this<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">programme to deliver an in depth analysis of each theory nor a verdict on the<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">veracity of each theory. It was the view of the Committee that the impartiality due<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">to this subject matter, which had been clearly signposted to the audience, was to<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">give sufficient information both in support of the various theories and in support of<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">the official view, to enable the viewer to have a reasonable understanding of the<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">various arguments. The Committee was satisfied that the programme had been \u201cfair<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">and open minded when examining the evidence and weighing the material facts\u201d. As<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">to whether equal time should have been given to both sides of the arguments, the<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Committee noted that as long as the programme was objective and even handed it<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">was not required to \u201crepresent every argument\u201d or provide \u201can equal division of<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">time for each view\u201d. The Committee was satisfied that the programme had been<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">objective and even handed in its presentation of the various theories.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">With regard to some of the complainants\u2019 specific complaints the Committee was<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">satisfied that it was not necessary to include the detail relating to the debris of Flight<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">93 in New Baltimore to meet the guideline on accuracy or to explore this issue<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">further to satisfy impartiality. The Committee was satisfied that the programme had<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">provided sufficient information on the spread of debris of Flight 93 without it being<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">necessary to consider every facet of every theory about the debris to ensure<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">impartiality. The Committee considered the information presented by the<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">production team was sufficiently accurate to have provided viewers with enough<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">detail to understand the general view of the dispute about the area of the debris<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">field. The Committee did not consider it necessary to include additional theories on<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">the spread of debris in order to achieve impartiality. The guidelines state that it is<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">not a requirement for programmes to:<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">\u201c[represent] every argument or every facet of every argument on every<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">occasion\u201d<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The Committee considered the same guideline applied to the complainants concerns<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">that Larry Silverstein and the emergency workers at the scene of the collapse of the<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">WTC7 building were not included or the testimony of the fire-fighters or the theory<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">relating to the Mayor of San Francisco or an interview with Bill Coyle of the coalition<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">of 9\/11 families. The Committee was satisfied that the programme team was entitled<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">to:<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">\u201cproduce content about any subject at any point on the spectrum of debate,<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">as long as there are good editorial reasons for doing so\u201d<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The Committee was, therefore, satisfied that considering the difficulty and<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">complexity of the programme\u2019s subject matter the programme had provided a fair<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">and open minded presentation of the various theories and that it had successfully<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">met the guidelines on due impartiality.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">As to the choice of contributors, the Committee was satisfied that the programme<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">had provided appropriate and relevant representatives from both sides of the<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">argument to articulate the various views. The Committee recognised that with such<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">contentious views being presented not every viewer would be pleased with the<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">choice of contributors. Nevertheless, the Committee was satisfied having<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">considered the programme as a whole that the various arguments of the theories<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">highlighted had been sufficiently articulated to ensure that the lay viewer would have<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">been provided with enough information to have had a basic understanding of the<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">arguments for each of the theories presented.. The Committee considered Dylan<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Avery, Professor Jim Fetzer and Talk-show host Alex Jones appropriate<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">representatives for the \u201ctruth movement\u201d. They had achieved a level of recognition<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">and authority within the pro-theorist groups to be able to articulate the views of the<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">movement in relation to each of the presented theories (with the exception of the<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">theory relating to the Jewish community which was not a view promoted or<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">supported by the majority of those involved in the \u201ctruth movement\u201d). The<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Committee, whilst it accepted that the individual complainants did not necessarily<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">agree with the choice of representative for their views, was satisfied that the<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">production team had ensured that the contributors had appropriate credentials to<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">provide an authoritative view of the conspiracy theorists arguments.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The Committee noted how the programme had introduced Dylan Avery:<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">V\/O:<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Upstate New York \u2014 home to the most prominent voice in the self-styled<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">9\/11 truth movement.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Clip from Loose Change Dylan Avery\u2019s internet film:<\/p>\n<p><\/font><em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">9.38, Arlington Virginia\u2026 Hani Hanjour allegedly executes a 330 degree turn at<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">530 miles per hour, [\u2026] to crash American Airlines flight 77 into the ground floor<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">of the Pentagon\u2026explosion<\/p>\n<p><\/font><\/em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">V\/O:<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Loose Change\u2026\u2026.is the internet film, which, more than anything else, has<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">fanned the flames of 9\/11 conspiracies.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Dylan Avery (DA):<\/p>\n<p><\/font><em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Come on guys\u2026<\/p>\n<p><\/font><\/em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">V\/O:<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">And Dylan Avery is the wunderkind behind that film.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">DA:<\/p>\n<p><\/font><em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">That\u2019s Jonas:<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Howdy!<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Luke \u2014 foot soldier &#8211; one of the best people in New York for truth<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Jay Mandrish &#8211; cook slash dishwasher\u2026 Just kidding man.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">This is our office. No one\u2019s in here yet.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">That\u2019s really about it in terms of this room. And that leads us to my room.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">This is it&#8230;<\/p>\n<p><\/font><\/em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Interviewer:<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">So this is where you work?<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">DA:<\/p>\n<p><\/font><em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">This is where the magic happens. Yes sir!<\/p>\n<p><\/font><\/em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">V\/O:<\/p>\n<p><\/font><em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Loose Change has become an internet phenomenon\u2026. viewed tens of millions of<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">times. To reach a global audience this big in the past, you\u2019d have needed the<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">backing of a Hollywood studio. Now all you need is a modicum of technical<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">knowledge and a bargain basement computer.<\/p>\n<p><\/font><\/em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">DA:<\/p>\n<p><\/font><em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Well Guy, this is the laptop that started it all. In February 2003 after saving up for<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">two months or so I went to a Radio Shack and bought this and had it the next<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">morning and started editing what would become Loose Change, the documentary.<\/p>\n<p><\/font><\/em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">V\/O:<\/p>\n<p><\/font><em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Dylan Avery is riding the crest of a wave of interest in conspiracies.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">\u2026and is being feted by Hollywood. He now has a distribution deal and is recutting<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">his film for cinema release later this year.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Not bad for a 23 year old self-confessed drop out.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The many questions he raises about 9\/11 have proliferated through the internet<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">and have been picked up by mainstream media around the world\u2026<\/p>\n<p><\/font><\/em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The Committee was satisfied that it was reasonable for the programme as part of<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">introducing one of the most famous conspiracy theorists to explain who he is and his<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">background. It is a recognised technique of introducing a significant contributor to a<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">programme and one which was used throughout the programme, one way or<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">another, when introducing the other main contributors to the programme.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The Committee was also satisfied that the description of Dylan Avery as a \u201c23 year<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">old self-confessed drop out\u201d was used accurately and fairly as that was a description<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">he used to describe himself. The Committee also considered the introduction<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">appropriate as it provided specific information as to the contributor\u2019s background<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">and skills as a modern film maker using the internet as a resource for his research as<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">well as an outlet for his film.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">A) Were the arguments articulated clearly?<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The Committee was satisfied that in the presentation of the various theories<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">referred to above, including the graphic representations, the production team had<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">accurately put forward the broad details of each of the theories and, therefore, did<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">not mislead. The facts as much as they could be established had been thoroughly<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">checked. The inclusion or exclusion of facts and interviewees was for the BBC to<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">determine as long as the guidelines were complied with. The Committee was<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">satisfied that the programme\u2019s choice of contributors, whilst not to the liking of all<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">the viewers, had ensured that the various theories and rebuttals had been clearly and<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">appropriately articulated to enable the audience to come to an appropriate<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">understanding of the various arguments.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The Committee was also satisfied that the programme in choosing the contributors<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">to articulate the various arguments, both for and against each theory, had carried<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">out appropriate checks on the contributors suitability and understanding of the<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">issues to ensure that each view was presented clearly and accurately.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The complaint was not upheld.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">As to the individual theories presented by the programme:<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">(1) ATTACK ON TWIN TOWERS:<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The Committee was satisfied that the programme had provided an accurate<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">description of the official explanation of how the Twin Towers collapsed. The<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Committee was also satisfied that the accompanying graphic had clearly set out<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">the official version of the Twin Towers collapse. The Committee recognised that<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">the explanation (which included the graphic) had, by its nature, been relatively<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">simple, but this had been acceptable given the time that the programme could<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">devote to the theory. The Committee also noted that an alternative explanation<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">for the collapse had been put forward by the programme. As to whether equal<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">time should have been given to both of these views, the Committee did not<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">believe it was necessary to achieve impartiality. The relevant BBC guideline<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">makes clear in order to achieve due impartiality:<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">\u201cIt requires us (the BBC) to be fair and opened minded when examining the<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">evidence and weighing all the material facts, as well as being objective and<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">even handed in our approach to a subject. It does not require the<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">representation of every argument or facet of every argument on every<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">occasion or an equal division of time for each view\u201d<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The Committee also noted that it was not a requirement for the programme to<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">present every argument or every facet of an argument to achieve impartiality.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The programme had put forward an opposing argument regarding the collapse of<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">the Twin Towers and from that the audience would have had sufficient<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">information to have understood that there were alternative opinions to the<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">official version of the event.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">(2) BUILDING 7<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The Committee noted that the description of this theory was similar in form to<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">that of the collapse of the Twin Towers with first a conspiracy theory being put<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">forward and then the official explanation. The Committee was satisfied that the<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">narrative of the theory and the official version of events were even-handed. The<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Committee noted that the alternative view which was given further context by<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">the suggestion that a number of Government agencies had offices in the WTC 7<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">and was demolished to hide evidence of a deliberate policy by the US<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">government to bring down the Towers and blame external forces, was raised<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">without rebuttal. The Committee was also satisfied given the context and time<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">in which to provide detail of both views that the arguments had been accurately<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">presented.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">As to the issue of whether it had been accurate for the programme to state:<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">\u201cThe building had been evacuated and there were no casualties\u201d<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The Committee noted that the source for this statement had been the Federal<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Emergency Management Agency (FEMA). As such, in the face of no other<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">evidence to disprove this report the Committee was satisfied that this statement<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">was accurate as far as was known, but it did accept that others took a different<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">view to the official statement.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Nevertheless the Committee was satisfied that the reporting of the lack of<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">injuries was not evidence of bias by the programme in favour of the authorities<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">or part of a cover-up.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">(3) ATTACK ON THE PENTAGON<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The Committee noted that in the programme one theory concerning the attack<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">on the Pentagon was presented. It noted how the two views were addressed<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">and was satisfied that the presentation of both arguments relating to this<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">particular theory was accurately and impartially portrayed. It also considered the<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">narrative for either view provided sufficient opportunity to ensure that the<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">viewer was not misled as to the explanation of the varying opinions.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The Committee noted that this was not the only theory relating to the Pentagon<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">attack but was one which many people viewing the programme would have been<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">aware of. The Committee also noted that the choice of which theory to be<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">considered within a programme was for the programme makers to decide, it was<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">not a requirement of the programme to consider all theories or issues related to<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">a particular event as stated in the BBC\u2019s editorial guideline on achieving<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">impartiality<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">\u201c[impartiality] does not require the representation of every argument or<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">facet of every argument on every occasion or an equal division of time for<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">each view\u201d.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Therefore the Committee was satisfied that it was not necessary for the<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">programme to raise the question as to whether the Pentagon was protected<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">from attack with a missile defence or that a Boeing 757 could not physically fly at<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">ground level.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">(4) PENTAGON PART 2<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The Committee was also satisfied that the differing opinions of the official<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">version and \u201ctruth movement\u201d were clearly and fairly presented in the<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">programme and that both views were provided with sufficient time to put their<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">case. The Committee considered the presentation of the theory was accurate<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">and impartial.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">(5) FLIGHT UNITED 93<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The Committee was also satisfied that the two theories presented about Flight<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">93, plus the official version of the events, were given sufficient time to enable the<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">viewer to understand each version and that the arguments had been presented<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">accurately and impartially.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The Committee did not agree that the programme, in looking at the incident of<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Flight 93 was required to consider all theories and reports relating to the<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">wreckage of this plane to ensure accuracy and impartiality regarding this<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">particular incident. The Committee recognised that it was up to the programme<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">makers and BBC management to decide as to which theories it would consider<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">in order to provide a reasonable representation of the theories surrounding the<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">incidents related to 9\/11 as stated in the BBC\u2019s Editorial Guidelines:<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">\u201cwe exercise our editorial freedom to produce content about any subject, at<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">any point on the spectrum of debate as long as there are good editorial<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">reasons for doing so\u201d<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">(6) FBI\/CIA CONSPIRACY<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The Committee noted how the programme considered the involvement of the<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">FBI\/CIA with regard to the events of 9\/11. It noted how the programme set out<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">its investigation:<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Voice over:<\/p>\n<p>\u201c<\/font><em><font face=\"Arial\">And there\u2019s one story where the evidence does stack up against the Government.<\/font><\/em><em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The FBI and CIA insist they had no specific warnings of the hijackings on 9\/11.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">But it no seems they were less than full and frank about how much information<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">they did have before Al Qaeda attacked.\u201d<\/p>\n<p><\/font><\/em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The theory being investigated was one of governmental cover up following 9\/11<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">into what the FBI\/CIA had known of the hijackers in the period before 9\/11.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The Committee then noted how the programme presented this argument with<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">the testimonies of officers from both agencies and with the comments of Bob<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Graham the Co-Chair of the Congressional inquiry into 9\/11.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The Committee recognised that in the presentation of this theory a conspiracy<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">theorist had not been included to offset the views expressed by the officers of<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">the two agencies. However, the Committee did not consider it was necessary<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">for a theorist to be included in this section of the programme to ensure balance.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The question was whether the agencies had known of the hijackers prior to 9\/11<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">and if they had, was the US government honest in what it said about the extent<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">of its knowledge after the event?<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The Committee noted some of contributions made to the programme:<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Dale Watson (Head of Counter Terrorism 1999-2002 FBI):<\/p>\n<p><\/font><em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">\u201cI knew another attack was coming. I knew another attack was coming. The<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">obvious question behind that is why didn\u2019t you do something about it? We had no<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">specific information. It was just this gut feeling\u2026 it was just they\u2019re planning<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">something. We would see the planning\u2026.the communications or whatever we<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">were monitoring would drop off and then you would know\u2026this is not a good<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">time.\u201d<\/p>\n<p><\/font><\/em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Voice over:<\/p>\n<p><\/font><em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">\u201c17 days before 9\/11, the penny dropped.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Had the two terrorists in San Diego been arrested, there was a chance that the<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">whole plot could have been prised open\u2026. but they had long moved on and<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">disappeared.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">It wasn\u2019t a lack of intelligence; it was a failure to act on that intelligence.\u201d<\/p>\n<p><\/font><\/em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Michael Scheuer (Chief of Osama Bin Laden Unit 1996-1999 CIA):<\/p>\n<p><\/font><em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">\u201cCertainly the idea that they couldn\u2019t be found in the US was true but only because<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">the FBI is such an incompetent organisation.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">There\u2019s no intelligence problem. You can\u2019t have an intelligence failure when you<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">have information and you refuse to act on it. And that\u2019s what Americans should<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">understand. If there was a conspiracy, it was a conspiracy to avoid taking a risk.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Not a conspiracy to make sure America got attacked.<\/p>\n<p><\/font><\/em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The Committee also noted the following exchange:<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Voice over:<\/p>\n<p><\/font><em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">\u201cIn Washington after the attacks, a Congressional inquiry tried to find out what had<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">gone wrong at the CIA and FBI.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">It uncovered that not only were there intelligence mistakes before 9\/11, but also<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">that afterwards the government had been less than open in admitting to those<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">failures.\u201d<\/p>\n<p><\/font><\/em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Bob Graham (Co-Chair of the Congressional Inquiry into 9\/11):<\/p>\n<p><\/font><em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">\u201cI can just state that within 9\/11 there are too many secrets. That is information<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">that has not been made available to the public for which there are specific tangible,<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">credible answers. And that that withholding of those secrets has eroded public<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">confidence in their government as it relates to their own security\u201d<\/p>\n<p><\/font><\/em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Voice over:<\/p>\n<p>\u201c[\u2026] <\/font><em><font face=\"Arial\">Senator Graham found that the cover-up led to the heart of the<\/font><\/em><em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">administration.\u201d<\/p>\n<p><\/font><\/em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Bob Graham:<\/p>\n<p><\/font><em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">\u201cI called the White House and talked with Miss Rice and said look we\u2019d been told<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">that we\u2019d get cooperation in this inquiry. And she said she\u2019d look into it and nothing<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">happened.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">&#8211; Was there any sense of embarrassment or apology or\u2026?<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">No, embarrassment, apology, regret those are not characteristics associated with<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">the current White House.\u201d<\/p>\n<p><\/font><\/em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Interviewer:<\/p>\n<p>\u201c<\/font><em><font face=\"Arial\">So it was a conspiracy to cover up the fact that blunders had been made in the<\/font><\/em><em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">lead up to 9\/11?\u201d<\/p>\n<p><\/font><\/em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Bob Graham:<\/p>\n<p><\/font><em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">\u201cIf by conspiracy you mean more than one person involved, yes, there was more<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">than one person and there was some collaboration of efforts among agencies and<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">the administration to keep information out of the public\u2019s hands.\u201d<\/p>\n<p><\/font><\/em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The Committee was satisfied that the theory the programme it had set out to<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">consider i.e. US government cover up as to what the two agencies had known of<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">the hijackers prior to 9\/11, had been handled appropriately. Opinions from<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">people working with the agencies at the time of 9\/11 showed the varying views<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">on culpability of the two agencies as to how much information was known and<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">what could have been done to prevent the attacks from happening. In terms of<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">what happened after 9\/11 Senator Graham was entitled to express his opinion as<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">chair of the congressional inquiry as to whether the administration had been \u2018less<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">than open\u2019. A conspiracy theorist\u2019s view was not required here.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The Committee recognised that this was only one of a number of theories<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">surrounding the possible involvement of the FBI\/CIA into the events of 9\/11. But<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">noted that the choice of which theory to be considered within a programme was<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">for the programme makers to decide, it was not a requirement of the<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">programme to consider all theories or issues related to a particular event to<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">ensure impartiality.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">As to whether the agencies had actually been involved in masterminding the<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">events of 9\/11 the Committee noted that the \u201ctruth movement\u2019s\u201d perspective on<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">this issue had been raised in an earlier section of the programme which referred<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">to the alleged deliberate demolition of both the CIA\u2019s and FBI\u2019s offices in WTC7.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The Committee recognised that whilst this issue had not been expounded upon<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">beyond the reference in the earlier part of the programme, to not mention it<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">further was not a breach of guidelines as the programme was left to decide what<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">it could and could not cover in the time it had to put forward the range of<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">theories surrounding 9\/11.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">D) Was it appropriate to include Frank Spotnitz to talk about conspiracy theories?<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The Committee noted the dialogue and the introductory contribution of Frank<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Spotnitz:<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">V\/O:<\/p>\n<p><\/font><em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Among those who understand why conspiracy theories take root are people who<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">make a living\u2026. out of telling stories.<\/p>\n<p><\/font><\/em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Frank Spotnitz (FS):<\/p>\n<p><\/font><em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">I, not surprisingly, have thought a lot about conspiracy theories and why they\u2019re<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">popular because it was so much of our bread and butter on the X Files, which I<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">wrote for, for eight years.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">We\u2019re all storytellers. Narratives about who we are, about who the people in our<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">lives are and about the world around us, we collect the information we have and we<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">construct these narratives and they help us make sense of that\u2019s going on. And I<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">think we still live by these narratives and there\u2019s, there\u2019s religious myths we live by.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">But now in the modern age, particularly popular are the secular myths, there are<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">these conspiracy theories. And assemble bits of information and tell ourselves<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">stories. And I think the world is so complicated that conspiracy theories are very<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">appealing, cause they take only a few bits of information and string them together<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">in a way that seem logical, and to certain people, with a certain political or<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">ideological bent, pleasing in fact because it, it vindicates, it justifies what you already<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">believe.<\/p>\n<p><\/font><\/em><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The Committee was satisfied that there was a good editorial reason for a<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">programme looking at the phenomenon of conspiracy theories to talk to someone<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">who was publicly known and associated with conspiracy theories. The Committee<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">considered Mr Spotnitz\u2019s contribution was relevant to the subject matter being<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">discussed and that his credentials as a suitable contributor spoke for themselves.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The Committee also recognised that as Mr Spotnitz was himself associated to a<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">specific conspiracy theory concerning the incidents of 11 September 2001 it was<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">reasonable for the programme to include his views on the background to the<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">rationale of why conspiracy theories arise. As to whether his views were balanced<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">the Committee was satisfied that looking at the programme as a whole there was<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">sufficient concerns raised by those in the truth movement to offset those of Mr<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Spotnitz. His contribution had not been a breach of guidelines.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The complaint was not upheld.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">E) Did the programme present the 9\/11 theorists in a negative way?<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The Committee was satisfied that there was no evidence to suggest that the<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">programme had presented the theorists in a negative way either in the way the<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">individual contributors were referred to or in how they were presented i.e. filmed.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The Committee was satisfied that it was appropriate to refer to Dylan Avery as a<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">\u201cself confessed drop-out\u201d as that was a description he had given himself. As to the<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">suggestion that the programme had filmed the conspiracy theorists in a negative<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">manner, the Committee was satisfied, having viewed the programme, that that there<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">was no evidence to support that complaint.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">The complaint was not upheld.<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">In conclusion, the Committee did not uphold any of the complaints raised against the<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">programme regarding issues of accuracy or impartiality. The Committee noted that<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">the programme had presented some of the most well known theories in a fair and<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">accurate manner, ensuring that the arguments had been articulated clearly. The<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">choice of contributors was credible and appropriate including that of Mr Spotnitz,<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">who provided a relevant contribution to the understanding of the nature and<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">phenomenon of the conspiracy theory &#8211; the purpose of the programme. The<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Committee found that there was no evidence that the editorial independence of the<\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">BBC had been compromised.<\/p>\n<p><\/font><strong><font face=\"Arial\"><\/p>\n<p align=\"left\">Finding: Not upheld<\/p>\n<p><\/font><\/strong><\/p>\n","protected":false},"excerpt":{"rendered":"<p>No surprise that the complaint was not upheld, The finding is a joke as you would imagine. For example, the BBC&#8217;s idea of &#8216;investigation&#8217; regarding Mayor Willie Brown not flying on 911 is to phone his office and ask if the reports of a tip off were true! The entire results below: FINDING BY THE [&hellip;]<\/p>\n","protected":false},"author":1,"featured_media":0,"comment_status":"open","ping_status":"open","sticky":false,"template":"","format":"standard","meta":{"footnotes":""},"categories":[3,20,7,18],"tags":[],"class_list":{"0":"post-2544","1":"post","2":"type-post","3":"status-publish","4":"format-standard","6":"category-911-truth","7":"category-general","8":"category-media-news","9":"category-latest-news"},"_links":{"self":[{"href":"http:\/\/rinf.com\/alt-news\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/2544","targetHints":{"allow":["GET"]}}],"collection":[{"href":"http:\/\/rinf.com\/alt-news\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts"}],"about":[{"href":"http:\/\/rinf.com\/alt-news\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/types\/post"}],"author":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"http:\/\/rinf.com\/alt-news\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/users\/1"}],"replies":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"http:\/\/rinf.com\/alt-news\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/comments?post=2544"}],"version-history":[{"count":0,"href":"http:\/\/rinf.com\/alt-news\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/2544\/revisions"}],"wp:attachment":[{"href":"http:\/\/rinf.com\/alt-news\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/media?parent=2544"}],"wp:term":[{"taxonomy":"category","embeddable":true,"href":"http:\/\/rinf.com\/alt-news\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/categories?post=2544"},{"taxonomy":"post_tag","embeddable":true,"href":"http:\/\/rinf.com\/alt-news\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/tags?post=2544"}],"curies":[{"name":"wp","href":"https:\/\/api.w.org\/{rel}","templated":true}]}}