{"id":245761,"date":"2016-05-25T02:24:43","date_gmt":"2016-05-25T02:24:43","guid":{"rendered":"http:\/\/rinf.com\/alt-news\/newswire\/open-borders-in-the-real-world\/"},"modified":"2016-05-25T02:24:43","modified_gmt":"2016-05-25T02:24:43","slug":"open-borders-in-the-real-world","status":"publish","type":"post","link":"http:\/\/rinf.com\/alt-news\/newswire\/open-borders-in-the-real-world\/","title":{"rendered":"Open Borders in the Real World"},"content":{"rendered":"<div readability=\"248.11502069781\">\n<p>Jacob Hornberger has <a href=\"http:\/\/fff.org\/2016\/05\/19\/open-borders-libertarian-position-immigration\/\">written a column<\/a> on open borders. He doesn\u2019t mention my name, but it is pretty clear to whom he is writing.\u00a0 I won\u2019t go through Hornberger\u2019s post line by line; instead, I will focus on his challenge.\u00a0 Forgive the lengthy quote, but the full challenge must be presented:<\/p>\n<blockquote readability=\"33\">\n<p>Consider the following hypothetical. Ever since I presented it many years ago, there has not been one single libertarian advocate of government-controlled borders who has ever been able to refute the principles set forth in the hypothetical. Unless and until any libertarian advocate of government-controlled borders successfully refutes the principles set forth in this hypothetical, the government-controlled borders paradigm will continue to stand as fatally flawed.<\/p>\n<p>Two brothers own adjoining ranches in New Mexico, one on the Mexican side of the border and one on the U.S. side. There is no fence dividing the ranches. There is only an imaginary line known as the U.S.-Mexico border, which also demarks the property line between the two ranches. There is a U.S. highway that runs east-west and abuts the northern border of the U.S. brother\u2019s property. The highway is located 10 miles from the border.<\/p>\n<p>One day, the American brother invites the Mexican brother to come to his home for dinner. The Mexican brother accepts.<\/p>\n<p>Under libertarian principles, do they have the right to do that? Of course they do. Their actions are entirely peaceful. They\u2019re not burglarizing, stealing, murdering, or otherwise violating the libertarian non-aggression principle.<\/p>\n<p>Is the Mexican brother guilty of trespass? Of course not. Trespass is when a person goes onto another person\u2019s property without the owner\u2019s consent and permission. The Mexican brother is going to where he has been invited.<\/p>\n<\/blockquote>\n<p>The principles (including the principles that are implied) can\u2019t be refuted because the principles are a pure libertarian theory (absent the coincident state border between their properties, as there is no way to derive state borders from libertarian theory).\u00a0 If all we need to do is agree on the theory, we can stop here.<\/p>\n<p>However, Hornberger offered a hypothesis; let\u2019s test it in the real world to see if it is true.\u00a0I will break down Hornberger\u2019s hypothetical into its main \u2013 and relevant to libertarian theory \u2013 components:<\/p>\n<ol>\n<li>The implied first step is that the government has no say about who crosses political borders.<\/li>\n<li>Pete invites his brother Miguel to his property.<\/li>\n<li>Pete places a condition on this invitation \u2013 it is an invitation for dinner.<\/li>\n<li>Miguel accepts the invitation.<\/li>\n<li>Pete finalizes the agreement by allowing Miguel into his home and serving him dinner.<\/li>\n<li>The implied last step is that Miguel will not be a burden to any of Pete\u2019s neighbors.<\/li>\n<\/ol>\n<p>In other words, individuals voluntarily make and accept invitations; they may also set conditions on the invitation.\u00a0\u00a0 <em>How can any libertarian disagree with this?<\/em>\u00a0 I don\u2019t.<\/p>\n<p>Now, how does that hypothetical construct work in today\u2019s world of state borders?\u00a0 The German government has, at least for a time last year, removed almost all conditions for transiting borders \u2013 step one from above.\u00a0 This is why I keep pointing to it for libertarian open-borders advocates to deal with.\u00a0 (By the way, Jacob, none has).<\/p>\n<p>So, let\u2019s go to the German <em>real<\/em> as opposed to Hornberger\u2019s <em>hypothetical<\/em>.\u00a0 The government removed all restrictions (I know, not all and not permanently, but as close as we have seen in this world in some time).\u00a0 <em>But where is the voluntary invitation?\u00a0 Where is the conditionality?<\/em>\u00a0 What is libertarian about <em>no one<\/em> having to offer an invitation but the visitors \/ immigrants come anyway?\u00a0 In other words: where is Hornberger\u2019s complete hypothetical \u2013 six steps?<\/p>\n<p>Now, you might say \u201cbionic, a journey of a thousand miles begins with a single step\u201d or some such ancient Chinese saying.\u00a0 \u201cThe government has fully opened the borders; let\u2019s give the government time to make it a fully voluntary system.\u201d And I would agree in theory (while I was belly-laughing at the thought in reality) unless one concludes the remaining steps have little chance to be implemented in any case and <em>no chance to be implemented if the first step is taken without the rest<\/em>.\u00a0 Let me explain\u2026.<\/p>\n<p>Let\u2019s take the implied last step, as it is easiest to examine: Miguel will not be a burden to any of Pete\u2019s neighbors.\u00a0 But is this how it is working out in Germany?\u00a0 No matter what\u00a0<a href=\"http:\/\/fff.org\/2016\/05\/20\/open-immigration-welfare-state\/\">Hornberger says<\/a> about immigration and the government enforced social programs being two different issues, it is not working this way in Germany; the violation of this last step has followed the first step just as sure as night follows day.<\/p>\n<p>\u201cBionic, those programs already exist \u2013 complain about them separately.\u201d\u00a0 Well, if two wrongs make a right, OK (or to turn Block\u2019s famous example on its head \u2013 maybe I will ask the slave master to whip me even more because I haven\u2019t been whipped enough).<\/p>\n<p>But consider: it isn\u2019t just the expansion of current welfare programs; it is even worse, as the government introduces <em>new<\/em> welfare programs specifically for the immigrants \u2013 such as language skills, job training skills, etc., <em>as they are doing in Germany<\/em>.\u00a0 <em>Programs with their own bureaucracy; programs that will develop their own entrenched interests; programs that would not even exist<\/em> were it not for the \u201copen borders\u201d implied step one.<\/p>\n<p>In addition to opening the border, did the German government also say \u201ceach German resident is only obliged to support individuals he personally invited; each German resident can decide if they want to house or assist the immigrants in some manner; each village or community can decide if they want to offer community centers for residence, training programs for language and job skills; each resident can decide if he wants to pay the cost to support these new arrivals.\u201d?<\/p>\n<p>These are Hornberger\u2019s conditions for open borders; without these conditions in place, what kind of \u201copen borders\u201d exactly is Hornberger calling for?\u00a0 Did the German government allow Friedrich and Abdul to jointly agree to the same conditions, while not burdening Hans with the cost?<\/p>\n<p>No.\u00a0 A central government (Germany) and an even more centralized government (the EU) are cramming things down the throat of the much more decentralized governments (towns, communities, etc.) and down the throats of individuals.\u00a0 <em>Open borders without steps two through six do not mean no government involvement \u2013 it just means different government involvement.\u00a0 It doesn\u2019t facilitate local or individual decision making but expands centralized control.<\/em><\/p>\n<p>Who benefits by this?\u00a0 We know the answer.\u00a0 Most libertarians claim to be against this answer while singing songs towards its aggrandizement.<\/p>\n<p>The government will never offer an out clause to Hans on the \u201copen borders\u201d issue because it would then open the question of property owners having the right to discriminate against <em>anyone<\/em> \u2013 no matter the country of origin.\u00a0 And after the flood of immigrants take advantage of this unconditional open door, the government will have less reason to offer steps two through six when the people \u2013 previous residents and immigrants alike \u2013 call on the government to \u201cdo something about\u201d whatever\u2026<em>just as we are witnessing in Germany.<\/em><\/p>\n<p>This is why Hornberger\u2019s hypothetical doesn\u2019t work in the real world of state borders \u2013 his example doesn\u2019t work because the government will not allow discrimination by a property owner; the government will not allow an individual to \u201copt out\u201d of the support program \u2013 they are instead forced to \u201copt in.\u201d\u00a0 His example doesn\u2019t work because even if (and also because) the government removes all immigration restrictions, the people \u2013 residents and immigrants alike \u2013 will demand \u201cmore\u201d from the government, not less.\u00a0 <em>Again, see Germany<\/em> \u2013 open borders without Hornberger\u2019s libertarian conditions resulting in calls for \u201cmore\u201d from the government.<\/p>\n<p>Not only is \u201cmore\u201d demanded from the government, but the freedoms previously in place are removed.\u00a0 Consider the great risks now presented to the <a href=\"https:\/\/en.wikipedia.org\/wiki\/Schengen_Agreement\">Schengen agreement<\/a> \u2013 thirty years old and formalized into a treaty in 1999.\u00a0 <em>No border checkpoints at all for travelers between member countries.<\/em>\u00a0 If this disappears (several countries have already implemented internal EU border controls), it is because Germany took only the first step \u2013 <em>the step libertarian advocates for open borders insist can stand alone<\/em>: Merkel said all are welcome.<\/p>\n<p><em>Imagine: Germany and the EU open its external borders to non-Europeans while Germany and several other countries introduce new controls on the internal European borders for Europeans!\u00a0 It would be hilariously funny if it wasn\u2019t true.<\/em><\/p>\n<p>And this is why no advocate for open borders takes up <em>my<\/em> challenge.\u00a0 Libertarian open borders practice only works consistently with the libertarian theory in this world if Hornberger\u2019s entire example is implemented, and not just the implied first step.\u00a0 <em>An agreement between Pete and Pedro is required; an agreement that imposes no unwanted burden on anyone else.<\/em><\/p>\n<p>Otherwise, it is just one more example of government social engineering and forced integration.\u00a0 In other words, just another government program meant to ensure that people clamor for more government.<\/p>\n<p>Does this mean that I advocate government involvement in deciding who crosses borders?\u00a0 <em>Not at all.<\/em>\u00a0 But I do advocate that without the legal ability for individuals to enforce the above six conditions, <em>open borders libertarians are merely calling for bigger government.\u00a0<\/em><\/p>\n<p>I am not a \u201clibertarian advocate of government-controlled borders.\u201d\u00a0 From a strictly libertarian perspective, I do nothing more than present the case: there can be no such thing as <em>libertarian<\/em> open borders in this world where state borders exist.<\/p>\n<p>From the time I began writing on this topic, I will say my position has evolved \u2013 by degrees, but not in direction.\u00a0 Through examining Hornberger\u2019s hypothetical case I will say the same.\u00a0 I thank him for helping me to further clarify my thoughts: that the government eases or eliminates all restrictions on immigration does not complete the libertarian circle \u2013 it does nothing to address the remaining and necessary points of Hornberger\u2019s hypothesis.<\/p>\n<p>Private property owners have no legal means to defend their property if only the first step is taken.\u00a0 Further, they will have even fewer means as society demands more government action as a result.\u00a0 I don\u2019t have to rely on hypotheticals to make my point \u2013 we are living through a real-world example of step one being implemented without steps two through six.<\/p>\n<p><strong>Hornberger offers: Pete voluntarily made the offer.\u00a0 Miguel accepted the offer.\u00a0 Pete guaranteed that Miguel would not be a burden to his neighbors<\/strong>.\u00a0 This is very libertarian, but it isn\u2019t part of the deal when all the government does is open its borders.\u00a0Until the additional steps are part of the deal, there is no such thing as libertarian open borders in a world of state borders, and certainly not one that conforms to Hornberger\u2019s example.<\/p>\n<p><strong>Conclusion<\/strong><\/p>\n<p>What do libertarians do until then?\u00a0 I don\u2019t know \u2013 perhaps an advocate of open borders can offer a suggestion; if they prefer even more government interventions they can keep advocating for fully open borders \u2013 without any of the subsequent conditions in Hornberger\u2019s hypothetical.\u00a0 I am not the one advocating for open borders; it isn\u2019t my problem to solve.<\/p>\n<p><em>Advocates who say \u201clet\u2019s just open the borders and deal with a completely voluntary system later\u201d are no better than most economists and all politicians: they fail to comprehend (or willingly close their eyes to or secretly hope for) the second and third order effects in the process that have been unleashed \u2013 call it the seen and the unseen.<\/em><\/p>\n<p>Unless they address the entire equation \u2013 and not just regarding the government easing of restrictions \u2013 they are advocating for NAP violations and more government programs.\u00a0<em>Don\u2019t believe me?\u00a0 See Germany. <\/em>\u00a0This is where \u201copen borders\u201d without the subsequent libertarian conditions will lead.\u00a0 This is what the libertarian open borders crowd does not face.<\/p>\n<p>Without this, where will libertarianism be?\u00a0 It is a long fall from the top of the ivory tower for those who only focus on theory without considering application and consequences in the real world.<\/p>\n<p>A long fall.\u00a0 That\u2019s where libertarianism will be; splattered at the bottom.<\/p>\n<p>Finally, I went the entire post without mentioning culture \u2013 I had no need, although there were several opportunities.\u00a0 But it is something libertarians might want to consider about the world populated by humans (tough for many libertarians, I have come to realize).\u00a0Let\u2019s just say cultural change driven by voluntary means is a great experience \u2013 it is also unavoidable in human experience, thankfully.<\/p>\n<p>Cultural change driven by governmental eliminating immigration requirements without also including Hornberger\u2019s conditions above is only an open door to societal breakdown and therefore more calls for government intervention (do you think this might be the plan?\u00a0Less common culture = more government? Very <em><a href=\"http:\/\/bionicmosquito.blogspot.com\/2015\/07\/antonio-gramsci-libertarians.html\">Gramscarian<\/a><\/em> of you).<\/p>\n<p>This reality can be ignored in an ivory tower, but it will not disappear.\u00a0 In Germany and throughout Europe they are already paying for it.<\/p>\n<p><em>Reprinted with permission from <a href=\"http:\/\/bionicmosquito.blogspot.rs\/2016\/05\/jacob-hornberger-i-see-you.html\">Bionic Mosquito<\/a>.<\/em><\/p>\n<p class=\"article-author-archives-link\"><a href=\"https:\/\/www.lewrockwell.com\/author\/bionic-mosquito\/\">The Best of Bionic Mosquito<\/a><\/p>\n<\/p><\/div>\n<p><a href=\"https:\/\/www.lewrockwell.com\/2016\/05\/bionic-mosquito\/open-borders-real-world\/\">Read more<\/a><\/p>\n","protected":false},"excerpt":{"rendered":"<p>Jacob Hornberger has written a column on open borders. He doesn\u2019t mention my name, but it is pretty clear to whom he is writing.\u00a0 I won\u2019t go through Hornberger\u2019s post line by line; instead, I will focus on his challenge.\u00a0 Forgive the lengthy quote, but the full challenge must be presented: Consider the following hypothetical. [&hellip;]<\/p>\n","protected":false},"author":1,"featured_media":0,"comment_status":"open","ping_status":"closed","sticky":false,"template":"","format":"standard","meta":{"footnotes":""},"categories":[519],"tags":[],"class_list":{"0":"post-245761","1":"post","2":"type-post","3":"status-publish","4":"format-standard","6":"category-newswire"},"_links":{"self":[{"href":"http:\/\/rinf.com\/alt-news\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/245761","targetHints":{"allow":["GET"]}}],"collection":[{"href":"http:\/\/rinf.com\/alt-news\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts"}],"about":[{"href":"http:\/\/rinf.com\/alt-news\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/types\/post"}],"author":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"http:\/\/rinf.com\/alt-news\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/users\/1"}],"replies":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"http:\/\/rinf.com\/alt-news\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/comments?post=245761"}],"version-history":[{"count":0,"href":"http:\/\/rinf.com\/alt-news\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/245761\/revisions"}],"wp:attachment":[{"href":"http:\/\/rinf.com\/alt-news\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/media?parent=245761"}],"wp:term":[{"taxonomy":"category","embeddable":true,"href":"http:\/\/rinf.com\/alt-news\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/categories?post=245761"},{"taxonomy":"post_tag","embeddable":true,"href":"http:\/\/rinf.com\/alt-news\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/tags?post=245761"}],"curies":[{"name":"wp","href":"https:\/\/api.w.org\/{rel}","templated":true}]}}