{"id":115515,"date":"2014-04-30T19:46:20","date_gmt":"2014-04-30T19:46:20","guid":{"rendered":"http:\/\/rinf.com\/alt-news\/?p=115515"},"modified":"2014-04-30T19:46:20","modified_gmt":"2014-04-30T19:46:20","slug":"fccs-threat-net-neutrality","status":"publish","type":"post","link":"http:\/\/rinf.com\/alt-news\/editorials\/fccs-threat-net-neutrality\/","title":{"rendered":"FCC\u2019s Threat to Net Neutrality"},"content":{"rendered":"<p style=\"color: #444444;\"><b>Dennis J Bernstein<\/b><\/p>\n<p style=\"color: #444444;\">Media democracy advocates are up-in-arms over a report that the Federal Communications Commission is set to propose rules on Internet traffic that would allow broadband providers to charge companies a premium for access to their fastest lanes.<\/p>\n<p style=\"color: #444444;\">Opponents to this rule argue that the fast lanes would be out of reach for non-profits, independent creators and small businesses, thus moving away from a democratic Internet in favor of one that favors big companies that can pay more.<\/p>\n<p>Flashpoints host, Dennis J Bernstein spoke last week to Craig Aaron, president of the advocacy group Free Press, about the FCC plan to destroy net neutrality in the name of saving it.<\/p>\n<p>DB: You said today, sir, that in implementing these changes, if they occur, the FCC is aiding and abetting the largest ISPs in their effort to destroy the open Internet. Please begin by explaining your understanding of the changes, and how they are contrary to the notion of net neutrality.<\/p>\n<p>CA:\u00a0Essentially, this is not net neutrality these new rules. It looks a lot more like the end of net neutrality. The problem with the FCC\u2019s approach, as it has been described in the press \u2014 and there\u2019s been no indication from the FCC that any of those reports are inaccurate \u2014 is that it would essentially open the door to letting the most powerful Internet service providers, the big phone and cable companies, and the biggest content companies, carve out an express lane on the Internet for their content. Where they could pay for preferential treatment, pay for priority, so that their traffic reached the audience faster than everybody else.<\/p>\n<p>Essentially, they would speed up a few big guys and slow down everybody else. This is a very attractive model to the big Internet service providers but it\u2019s never been the way the Internet has worked. So this would, fundamentally, change the free and open Internet as we have known it, and, I think, furthermore the FCC\u2019s approach here, really leaves them all but unable to stop any kind of blocking or discrimination online.\u00a0They are sanctioning some of it, I think they are going to be unable to really stop any bad behaviors. It\u2019s really from top to bottom a terrible approach that doesn\u2019t serve the average Internet user at all.<\/p>\n<p>DB:\u00a0Let\u2019s talk about that, the average Internet user. How would they lose and say a little bit more about how corporations would gain?<\/p>\n<p>CA:\u00a0First of all, you have to understand as I\u2019m sure, most of your listeners know, there aren\u2019t a lot of choices when it comes to your Internet service provider. You are lucky, if you want truly high speed Internet capable of regularly streaming video, you\u2019ve got at best, where you live, one or at most two choices. And if those companies decide they are going to discriminate or interfere, there\u2019s really not anywhere for the average customer to turn.<\/p>\n<p>And because they don\u2019t face any competition and, therefore, don\u2019t really need to serve the needs of their customers, these companies are finding other ways to price gouge. So you\u2019re already paying your $50, $60, $70, $80 a month for their service which is supposed to bring you the entire Internet.<\/p>\n<p>And now they\u2019re saying \u201cWell, what if we charged some of these bigger companies an extra fee to reach you over that last mile a little faster in an express lane?\u201d And what this essentially does is it creates an incentive for them to create congestion or to create artificial scarcity. Because the only way they can get these big companies to pay up, is if the main road is always jammed.<\/p>\n<p>So what you end up with is a divided Internet. A fast lane for the haves, these big content companies, Hollywood studios, maybe people like Netflicks or Google. And everybody else gets stuck on the cyber equivalent of the winding dirt road where their independent content, their start-ups and competition never gets a chance to get the same kind of foot hold. And that really fundamentally changes the way the Internet is supposed to work.<\/p>\n<p>DB:\u00a0The FCC has not been really doing a good job for the people. The courts have taken some action to restrain them from going down this path. Could you explain the legal battles that have been happening?<\/p>\n<p>CA:\u00a0Sure. It\u2019s hard to do without getting a little bit wonky, but I\u2019ll try not to delve too much into the minutiae of the telecom law. But, basically, if you go back to the last time the nation\u2019s communications laws were updated was in 1996. The word Internet only appeared maybe 11 or 12 times in a huge bill. That bill had a lot of problems. It was especially bad in terms of media consolidation and in allowing radio to become especially heavily concentrated, but when it came to Internet policy there were a number of good things in that legislation.<\/p>\n<p>But, as the FCC went about implementing that legislation, the big companies started to pick away at it.\u00a0And so, from that, including in 1996 and all the way until 2002, and really all the way, as long as we\u2019ve had networks, telecommunication services, the phone network was treated under what\u2019s called Title 2 of the Communications Act.<\/p>\n<p>And there were certain requirements that came with that, including no discrimination. And treating it as a telecommunications service is what provided the protections that prevented AT&amp;T from dictating what kind of answering machine you could attach to your line. It\u2019s what opened things up so there was competition for long distance telephone service, where prices actually went down. It\u2019s what created an environment back in the days of dial-up where you maybe had 10 or 12 different choices for your Internet service provider. That\u2019s because the big phone companies were required to share their lines and offer them at a fair and competitive wholesale rate to other companies. Consumers benefitted.<\/p>\n<p>But, when Cable decided to get into the broadband business, they didn\u2019t want to follow the same rules. And they were traditionally regulated under a different part of the Communications Act, Title 6. So, they went to the FCC, this is during the Bush administration, they went to the FCC, under the chairmanship of Michael Powell, Colin Powell\u2019s son, and they said \u201cHey, we don\u2019t want to have these rules that apply to the telephone companies. We want you to change the way that broadband is classified under the law. So instead of broadband being a telecommunications or transmissions service, as it always had been, they were now going to be an information service.<br \/>\nAnd lump in the pipes going into your house with the content riding over those pipes.<\/p>\n<p>And the FCC insisted when they did this, that they could still find ways to stop that behavior. They got sued. It was a case that went all the way to the Supreme Court called Brand X. And what the Supreme Court ultimately ruled was, not that, this was a good or bad policy, but that it was up to the FCC. There were some scathing dissents including a very good one from Justice [Antonin] Scalia, but in the end that was the rule.<\/p>\n<p>So once Cable didn\u2019t have to play by those rules, the phone companies went to the FCC and said \u201cWell, we don\u2019t want to play by those rules either.\u201d And the FCC said \u201cOkay, broadband is now no longer a telecommunications service, even though it obviously is a telecommunications service, but under the law we\u2019re going to treat it as an information service. But don\u2019t worry we\u2019re going to apply ancillary authority to protect from bad behavior.\u201d<\/p>\n<p>Fast forward a little bit, and now we start to have the net neutrality wars and net neutrality fights because when they got rid of Title 2, they got rid of non-discrimination protections. So things that had always been baked into the law were suddenly gone. And there were a lot of fights in Congress about whether that would be re-established, no law was ever passed. And eventually Comcast actually got caught blocking Internet traffic in 2007. They were caught blocking lawful file sharing using Bit Torrent. The FCC, under a Republican administration, moved to sanction them and stop them from doing it.<\/p>\n<p>And Comcast chose to sue the FCC saying they lacked the authority, and the court agreed. They said, \u201cIf you are going to declare yourselves, that broadband is not a telecommunications service, you can\u2019t make these kinds of rules.\u201d\u00a0This was sent back to the FCC which is now under control of the Democrats. They had an opportunity to do what\u2019s called reclassifying broadband, in other words they could undo the decision that the Bush administration made, but, they chose not to do it.<\/p>\n<p>And instead they crafted a convoluted, watered-down set of rules that were meant to protect net neutrality, the inevitable results of which is they were sued again, this time by Verizon saying that they didn\u2019t have the authority to make these rules. And in January of this year, the same federal appeals court, the D.C. Circuit, ruled that again, the FCC did not have the authority to make these rules. And it\u2019s important to note that the court did not rule that the net neutrality was a bad policy, a bad idea, that it wasn\u2019t a worthy goal. They just said that the FCC couldn\u2019t do it the way they were doing it.<\/p>\n<p>And it went back to the FCC, again, now under the chairmanship of a guy named Tom Wheeler, who was a big Obama bundler and formerly the head of both the biggest cable lobbying association and the biggest mobile phone wireless lobbying association.<\/p>\n<p>DB: Wait, wait. The head of the current FCC, Chairman Tom Wheeler was a corporate lobbyist for these media companies?<\/p>\n<p>CA: Absolutely right. In the 1980s and early 1990s he was the nation\u2019s top cable company lobbyist. And in the early 2000s he was the nation\u2019s top wireless association lobbyist. Then he got very involved in the Obama campaign, and here he is now chairman of the FCC. Interestingly, the new head of the Cable lobby is Michael Powell, the guy who started this whole mess.<\/p>\n<p>So that tells you a lot about what\u2019s happening at the FCC, I suppose. The bottom line is that the FCC faces the same choice again. They could reclassify broadband. That\u2019s what groups like us have been urging them to do. Re-establish clear, legal guidelines under the law for broadband, offer clear protections, or they could choose another path, the path they appear to be choosing, which is to concoct a convoluted approach that doesn\u2019t offer real protections. Because the court has made clear if they don\u2019t change how broadband is classified they can\u2019t stop web site blocking, they can\u2019t stop discrimination, so instead they are sanctioning new kinds of discrimination apparently in this new proposal that leaked.<\/p>\n<p>DB:\u00a0Well, now that we know that the FCC chairman was a former lobbyist, I imagine there\u2019s quite a bit of money being spent by lobbyists who want this to go a certain way. Do you have any information on that?<\/p>\n<p>CA: Sure. What I think a lot of people don\u2019t know is that the media sector, Cable, Internet, phone, big media companies are among the biggest spenders in Washington. In fact, I think they\u2019re second only to the pharmaceutical drug industry in terms of their lobbying spending, and campaign spending in Washington. Bigger even than the oil and gas industry, in recent years.<\/p>\n<p>So these are very, very powerful lobbyists, the biggest phone and cable companies and their trade associations employ more than 500 lobbyist. So essentially every member of Congress has their own personal lobbyist from the industry. So that\u2019s, in many ways, what good public policy is up against. And the FCC is an agency, as we just described, where the revolving door is constantly spinning. And so it is very closely tied to industry. A lot of people working for the agency are looking for their next job in [the] industry and that\u2019s\u00a0part of why we\u2019ve had such a series of bad policy decisions, or really weak-kneed approaches from the agency, unfortunately.<\/p>\n<p>DB:\u00a0We know that the Internet has been a democratizer when it comes, for instance, to people of color. Brown people, black people, getting involved in business, being able to use the Internet. This will again, sort of bring back the traditional racism that has undermined black businesses getting started as well as non-profits continuing.<\/p>\n<p>CA:\u00a0I think that\u2019s one of the biggest concerns here. I mean, the Internet has proven to be a huge boon for organizing, labor organizing, the kind of activists organizing that groups like mine do. That\u2019s made possible by a free and open Internet where you can get your message out without necessarily having to go through the mainstream media or knock on doors. It\u2019s a very, very powerful tool. Certainly any of those groups are not going to be offered a spot in the fast lane.<\/p>\n<p>Similarly, small businesses, entrepreneurs, especially those outside of Silicon Valley, essentially storefronts that people are starting online, they aren\u2019t going to get any of the advantages of this system. It\u2019s not going to be offered to them. So I think, whereas the free and open environment as it is now, offers a chance, if you can get online, hey, you can find your audience. You got something interesting to say? You can compete with the New York Times, you can compete with CNN.<\/p>\n<p>But, if you do away with net neutrality, all those opportunities are really put in jeopardy.<\/p>\n<p>DB:\u00a0Let\u2019s talk a little bit about what\u2019s possible here. I know you\u2019re really encouraging people to get out and to take some kind of an action to protest, to demonstrate, to write letters. What\u2019s the process here, and what\u2019s the time frame?<\/p>\n<p>CA:\u00a0So, this is what\u2019s been leaked. It\u2019s essentially what\u2019s called a Notice of Proposed Rule Making. And, so, Tom Wheeler and his office at the FCC has drafted this new rule and in order to put it out publicly, he has to get at least two of his colleagues to support it. And there\u2019s a meeting at the FCC scheduled for May 15th, where we expect this measure will be voted on. If it is indeed voted on then, in its current form or some altered form based on what kind of pressure comes to bear in the next few weeks, then it would go out for further public comment. There would probably be a 60- or 90-day period, for the public to weigh in, followed by another 60-day period for people to reply\u00a0to what others said.<\/p>\n<p>And then ultimately the FCC would make the decision, which could come as soon as late summer. I\u2019ll be surprised if it comes before Election Day, but we\u2019ll see.\u00a0That\u2019s basically the process. But, I would argue that the next three weeks are absolutely crucial because it\u2019s really up to the FCC chair to set the parameters of the debate. And the fact that he had chosen to take this Title 2 broadband reclassification off of the table, effectively, by concocting the rules in this way, I think, is a really big problem.<\/p>\n<p>I think it needs to be part of the discussion if we\u2019re going to make these rules, and frankly, it\u2019s just also an opportunity. Clearly, the FCC is out-of-touch with Internet users, out-of-touch with the American public. They\u2019re spending too much time staring in the faces of these lobbyists, and their old friends from when they were lobbyists. And they need to start hearing from people out all across the country. And they\u2019ve heard some \u2014 a million people signed a petition in just the two weeks after the court decision came down in January.<\/p>\n<p>But it\u2019s very clear that we\u2019re going to have to do a lot more than that if we\u2019re going to reverse this failed approach and actually get the kind of protections we need. So, if all you can do is sign a petition, I hope you go to\u00a0<a style=\"color: #0089c4;\" title=\"http:\/\/freepress.net\/\" href=\"http:\/\/freepress.net\/\">freepress.net<\/a>\u00a0and do that. If you can pick up the phone and call the FCC, I\u2019m urging the people to do that. You can call your members of Congress. That congressional pressure is really key here. And we\u2019ve seen some encouraging statements from Bernie Sanders and Cory Booker criticizing the FCC, something that a lot of Democrats on Capitol Hill have been unwilling to do.<\/p>\n<p>DB:\u00a0Now, this FCC chairman, the former lobbyist, was appointed by Obama?<\/p>\n<p>CA: That\u2019s correct.<\/p>\n<p>DB: So, he\u2019s a Democrat. And I\u2019m concerned because there\u2019s a lot of the liberal television folks, the MSNBC, really spent a lot of time defending Obama, and they\u2019ve been quite silent on this issue. Are you concerned that Obama and the Democrats are deeply embedded in this process that might undermine net neutrality and this beautiful, free Internet that we, so far, can use for the peoples\u2019 benefit?<\/p>\n<p>CA:\u00a0I\u2019m incredibly concerned because Barack Obama, when he was running back in 2008, pledged to take a back seat to no one on net neutrality. This is an issue he\u2019s actually talked about from the Oval Office. That should be all the endorsement that\u2019s needed for a Democratic FCC to move forward with good rules, but it hasn\u2019t happened.<\/p>\n<p>DB:\u00a0But, he hired a lobbyist!<\/p>\n<p>CA:\u00a0That\u2019s exactly it, so there\u2019s the truth of it. You can look at the decisions he\u2019s made. The previous FCC chair was a complete disaster. Julius Genachowski was Wheeler\u2019s predecessor. A lot of people, in this town, tried to sell us on the idea that Tom Wheeler \u2014 \u201che\u2019s at the end of his career\u201d and \u201che\u2019s going to be his own man\u201d \u2014 but I think we\u2019re seeing evidence to the contrary in this decision.<\/p>\n<p>And I think it is a real concern. These companies have invested heavily in the Democratic Party as well as the Republican Party. But companies like Comcast are huge Democratic supporters. Companies like Comcast own MSNBC, so you have to be pretty brave to tackle these stories over there. And with the exception of Chris Hayes, basically no one has been willing to do this.<\/p>\n<p>When the Comcast merger, that they\u2019re trying to push through, got announced, the \u201cMorning Joe Show\u201d had both sides of the debate. They had an executive from Comcast and an executive from Time\/Warner.<\/p>\n<p>DB:\u00a0There\u2019s some balance!<\/p>\n<p>CA:\u00a0There\u2019s the fair-and-balanced approach. So I think it\u2019s a really big concern and I think it\u2019s really problematic that there are a lot of Democratic legislators, there are certainly exceptions to this, but there are plenty who are willing to speak out when it was Republicans making the bad decisions, but who aren\u2019t willing to go against members of their own party. And, that\u2019s frankly, how we got into this mess.<\/p>\n<p>A little bit of statesmanship, of political wisdom \u2026 just foresight, could have avoided so many of these problems, and yet, you know, Capitol Hill has sat back too much, and obviously the corporations are up there, and who\u2019s got the most power? These big companies, including the big Internet companies that at one point were very active in pushing for things like net neutrality and now are less active because maybe they figure, \u201cWell, we can probably cut a deal.\u201d<\/p>\n<p>DB:\u00a0And, should it be a concern, for instance, that you\u2019ve got a news organization like The Washington Post that\u2019s now, shall we say, partners with Amazon news content providers, big corporations? This is all a big problem, isn\u2019t it?<\/p>\n<p>CA: Yeah, I mean media consolidation certainly plays a role here. I think, the Post news side has covered this story quite well and thoroughly. The editorial page has been terrible, before Jeff Bezos was there, and continues to be. They endorsed the Comcast merger just last week. They haven\u2019t been good on these issues of net neutrality. So, in terms of where\u2019s the Washington establishment on this issue? Well, they are certainly not looking out for the average Internet user.<\/p>\n<p>Now, that said, do not get too pessimistic too quickly. We\u2019ve seen when people organize, and when people organize using the Internet in big numbers, they can change the nature of these debates. We saw it in the debate over the SOPA\/PIPA web censorship bills. Ten million people contacted Congress, and all of a sudden co-sponsors of these bills, that were pushed by Hollywood, started bailing off and they stopped that bill from happening.<\/p>\n<p>I think we\u2019ve seen it in the response to NSA spying and surveillance, where a strange bedfellows coalition has not yet passed legislation to rein it in but certainly changed that conversation significantly. So that had happened before on this issue of net neutrality, I absolutely think it can happen again. But it needs to happen now.<\/p>\n<p>DB: And very briefly, in closing, at the core what is lost if net neutrality is lost? What\u2019s the bottom line?<\/p>\n<p>CA:\u00a0We lose the free and open Internet, as we know it. And the Internet, it may not be perfect, but it\u2019s certainly an unrivaled environment for democratic participation, free speech, and economic innovation. And if we give that up, just for the short-term profits of a few big phone and cable companies, we\u2019ll never get it back.<\/p>\n<p><b>Dennis J Bernstein is a host of \u201cFlashpoints\u201d on the Pacifica radio network and the author of\u00a0<a style=\"color: #0089c4;\" href=\"http:\/\/www.nyqbooks.org\/title\/specialed\"><i>Special Ed: Voices from a Hidden Classroom<\/i><\/a>.<\/b><\/p>\n","protected":false},"excerpt":{"rendered":"<p>Dennis J Bernstein Media democracy advocates are up-in-arms over a report that the Federal Communications Commission is set to propose rules on Internet traffic that would allow broadband providers to charge companies a premium for access to their fastest lanes. Opponents to this rule argue that the fast lanes would be out of reach for [&hellip;]<\/p>\n","protected":false},"author":1,"featured_media":0,"comment_status":"open","ping_status":"open","sticky":false,"template":"","format":"standard","meta":{"footnotes":""},"categories":[461],"tags":[],"class_list":{"0":"post-115515","1":"post","2":"type-post","3":"status-publish","4":"format-standard","6":"category-editorials"},"_links":{"self":[{"href":"http:\/\/rinf.com\/alt-news\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/115515","targetHints":{"allow":["GET"]}}],"collection":[{"href":"http:\/\/rinf.com\/alt-news\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts"}],"about":[{"href":"http:\/\/rinf.com\/alt-news\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/types\/post"}],"author":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"http:\/\/rinf.com\/alt-news\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/users\/1"}],"replies":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"http:\/\/rinf.com\/alt-news\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/comments?post=115515"}],"version-history":[{"count":0,"href":"http:\/\/rinf.com\/alt-news\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/115515\/revisions"}],"wp:attachment":[{"href":"http:\/\/rinf.com\/alt-news\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/media?parent=115515"}],"wp:term":[{"taxonomy":"category","embeddable":true,"href":"http:\/\/rinf.com\/alt-news\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/categories?post=115515"},{"taxonomy":"post_tag","embeddable":true,"href":"http:\/\/rinf.com\/alt-news\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/tags?post=115515"}],"curies":[{"name":"wp","href":"https:\/\/api.w.org\/{rel}","templated":true}]}}