RINF.COM: THE BREAKING NEWS ALTERNATIVE
|
|
BREAKING NEWS |
The Next Civil Rights Battle Will Be Over the Mind
Wednesday, April 9th, 2008
By Clive Thompson Trolling down the street in Manhattan, I suddenly hear a woman’s voice. “Who’s there? Who’s there?” she whispers. I look around but can’t figure out where it’s coming from. It seems to emanate from inside my skull. Was I going nuts? Nope. I had simply encountered a new advertising medium: hypersonic sound. It broadcasts audio in a focused beam, so that only a person standing directly in its path hears the message. In this case, the cable channel A&E was using the technology to promote a show about, naturally, the paranormal. I’m a geek, so my first reaction was, “Cool!” But it also felt creepy. We think of our brains as the ultimate private sanctuary, a zone where other people can’t intrude without our knowledge or permission. But its boundaries are gradually eroding. Hypersonic sound is just a portent of what’s coming, one of a host of emerging technologies aimed at tapping into our heads. These tools raise a fascinating, and queasy, new ethical question: Do we have a right to “mental privacy”? “We’re going to be facing this question more and more, and nobody is really ready for it,” says Paul Root Wolpe, a bioethicist and board member of the nonprofit Center for Cognitive Liberty and Ethics. “If the skull is not an absolute domain of privacy, there are no privacy domains left.” He argues that the big personal liberty issues of the 21st century will all be in our heads — the “civil rights of the mind,” he calls it. It’s true that most of this technology is still gestational. But the early experiments are compelling: Some researchers say that fMRI brain scans can detect surprisingly specific mental acts — like whether you’re entertaining racist thoughts, doing arithmetic, reading, or recognizing something. Entrepreneurs are already pushing dubious forms of the tech into the marketplace: You can now hire a firm, No Lie MRI, to conduct a “truth verification” scan if you’re trying to prove you’re on the level. Give it 10 years, ethicists say, and brain tools will be used regularly — sometimes responsibly, often shoddily. Both situations scare civil libertarians. What happens when the government starts using brain scans in criminal investigations — to figure out if, say, a suspect is lying about a terrorist plot? Will the Fifth Amendment protect you from self-incrimination by your own brain? Think about your workplace, too: Your boss can already demand that you pee in a cup. Should she also be allowed to stick your head in an MRI tube as part of your performance review? But this isn’t just about reading minds; it’s also about bombarding them with messages or tweaking their chemistry. Transcranial magnetic stimulation — now used to treat epilepsy — has shown that it can artificially generate states of empathy and euphoria. And you’ve probably heard of propranolol, a drug that can help erase traumatic memories. Let’s say you’ve been assaulted and you want to take propranolol to delete the memory. The state needs that memory to prosecute the assailant. Can it prevent you from taking the drug? “To a certain extent, memories are societal properties,” says Adam Kolber, a visiting professor at Princeton. “Society has always made claims on your memory, such as subpoenaing you.” Or what if you use transcranial stimulation to increase your empathy. Would you be required to disclose that? Could a judge throw you off a jury? Could the Army turn you away? I’d love to give you answers. But the truth is no one knows. Privacy rights vary from state to state, and it’s unclear how, or even if, the protections would apply to mental sanctity. “We really need to articulate a moral code that governs all this,” warns Arthur Caplan, a University of Pennsylvania bioethicist. The good news is that scholars are holding conferences to hash out legal positions. But we’ll need a broad public debate about it, too. Civil liberties thrive only when the public demands them — and understands they’re at risk. That means we need to stop seeing this stuff as science fiction and start thinking about how we’ll react to it. Otherwise, we could all lose our minds. See More:TechnologyHave Your Say: The Next Civil Rights Battle Will Be Over the Mind Please note, only selected comments will be published. Or discuss this report in our our new forums One Response to “The Next Civil Rights Battle Will Be Over the Mind”
|
Translations![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]()
Free Newsletter
Related News
Email This Page To A Friend Latest Headlines
More Breaking News Archive |
TOP NEWS DISCUSSIONS |
LATEST NEWS DISCUSSIONS |
|
|
Your Privacy for Sale: Internet Providers Cash In How Pot Became Demonized The Prosecution of George W. Bush UN suspends aid flights after Burma impounds food BBC kept £106,000 of charity cash The Lucrative Art of War First US aid plane lands in Burma Blackwater back to Iraq Bush warns of Iraq exit terror risk Guantánamo Has Backfired Dreadfully Government admits ID cards have no business case Executions sought for 9/11 defendants |
peter white commented on: Your Privacy for Sale: Internet Providers Cash In how many opt-in depends on the spin and lies and how little real detail of just how... Continue Reading & Reply Villanovajunction commented on: Government admits ID cards have no business case ID Card case still not proven. Case dismissed. If only! Continue Reading & Reply Revolting Mass commented on: Banksy throws London stencil party I went and put up some of my stencils. I thought it was the best exhibition I have ever been to.... Continue Reading & Reply Tessa Van Rompaey commented on: Karachi, Pakistan in large-scale power Hello, My name is Tessa and I live in Karachi. For ym science project, I need to know a... Continue Reading & Reply |
Larry Silverstein LOST MONEY on 911 Some info for conspiracy theorists. Silverstein wa. […] Thread Started By: Sammy Patent For a Pig: The Big Business of Monsanto http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=1669587865. […] Thread Started By: GhostInTheComputer The Mysterious Mr Tesla 1982 BBC Horizon documentary about Nikola Tesla. N. […] Thread Started By: Nostalgia How much do you pay for your weed? Here I'm paying £20 an 8th for skunk and £10 for. […] Thread Started By: the-nameless-one Egypt approves commercialisation of first GM crop Didn't Egypt just have food riots not long ago, in. […] Thread Started By: Nostalgia 15 May 2008 WHITE HOUSE DENIED KNOWLEDGE OF MILITARY ANALYST P. […] Thread Started By: editor ![]() |
The views expressed in the RINF news wire and newsletter are the sole responsibility of the author (s) and do not necessarily reflect the views of the webmaster. RINF.COM: Breaking News & Alternative Media is Copyleft - Copy & Distribute Freely. News Forum |
I’m sure this could be counter balanced by wearing metal head gear… Scientists are the biggest threat to our privacy, its about time they learned how much they are pissing people off!