CIA blew chances to spot 9/11 threat, says report
· Information on hijackers kept from key personnel
· Former director George Tenet criticised for failings
Ed Pilkington in New York
Wednesday August 22, 2007
The Guardian
 |
 George Tenet. Photograph: Mark Wilson/Getty |
As many as 60 people within the CIA read a cable referring to two of the 19 hijackers involved in the attacks on America on September 11 2001 before the event, yet the information was not shared with the parts of the organisation able to do anything about it, according to the agency’s own internal investigation.The revelation is one of several damning findings from the CIA’s own watchdog, the inspector general, drawn up in June 2005. He accuses the CIA’s top officials in the run-up to 9/11, including the then director, George Tenet, of failure to devise a strategic plan to counter Osama bin Laden in advance of the attacks.
A 19-page summary of the inspector’s report was published yesterday under a new congressional law passed earlier this month, having been kept secret since it was written. It underlines the depth of infighting between the CIA and the National Security Agency which prevented clear lines of responsibility in the fight against al-Qaida.
Though the report found no evidence of misconduct or illegality, it bluntly stated that CIA officers “did not discharge their responsibilities in a satisfactory manner”. The inspector, John Helgerson, went as far as to recommend further panels of inquiry into the conduct of key individuals within the agency to see whether disciplinary action should be taken against them.
Mr Helgerson said that the actions of Mr Tenet, his number two, Jim Pavitt, and the head of the counterterrorism operation, Cofer Black, should all be put under scrutiny. However, the summary reveals that the CIA director at the time of the inspector’s report, Porter Goss, ruled out any further action. In a statement accompanying the declassified summary, the current director, Michael Hayden, said he agreed with his predecessor that no reprimands were called for.
The 2005 internal inquiry concludes that there was no single point of failure or “silver bullet” that would have allowed the CIA to predict or prevent the attacks of 9/11. But if systems had been in place to share and analyse critical information that could have led to a more informed assessment of the threat in the lead up to the assault.
The most direct accusation was that information on the hijackers was widely reviewed before 9/11 but was not followed up. “That so many individuals failed to act in this case reflects a systematic breakdown. There was no coherent, functioning watch-listing programme,” the summary says.
Though the failings of the CIA in the run-up to the attacks on New York and Washington have been publicly examined by several congressional inquiries and the September 11 commission, the latest report gives a more stinging assessment than any previous account of the inadequate responses of individuals. Mr Tenet is singled out for particular criticism.
Full text
13.04.2006: United 93, full transcript
22.07.04: 9/11 Commission report (pdf)
24.07.03: Report by House and Senate intelligence committees (pdf)
Have Your Say: CIA blew chances to spot 9/11 threat, says report
Please read our posting guidelines before posting.
Alternatively you can discuss this report here.
This entry was posted on Wednesday, August 22nd, 2007 at 7:32 am and is filed under 9/11 Truth, Breaking News . You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.
Translations
Loading ...Related News
- CIA publishes pre-9/11 intelligence errors
- CIA report on 9/11 due Labor Day
- CIA ‘impeded 9/11 panel’s inquiry’
- Ex-CIA chief criticises Iraq war
- Congress pledges to support CIA probe
Email This Page To A Friend
Latest Headlines
- More People are Catching on to Corporate Media Lies
- Bisphenol A Chemical in Plastic Bottles Harms Children, Feds Conclude
- Class War Bonfire Night 2008
- US out of Iraq by … “2011″
- ‘MI6 & Weapons of Mass Destruction’
- RIPA Surveillance Law Misused On Merseyside
- Britain: Security Service “facilitated” torture of Guantánamo detainee
- Blackwater-linked firm to train Canadian troops
- Pledge: Refuse To Comply With ID Scheme
- Why can’t energy firms pick up the bill?
More Breaking News
Archive
